7 ms·
Who wrote this paragraph? "While some people prefer energy efficient cars, other drivers are more concerned that their car have a powerful engine. Almost 14% o
by dsr_ 11y ago
Who wrote this paragraph?
"While some people prefer energy efficient cars, other drivers are more concerned that their car have a powerful engine. Almost 14% of the cars we service have an eight-cylinder V engine, more commonly known as a V8. V8 engines are more powerful than the four and six cylinder engines found in more than two thirds of the cars we service."
This stands out as filler written by someone who doesn't speak English or Car.
- hammock 11y agoMore likely it's writing from someone whose editor has told them no acronyms are allowed without prior explanation, which is fairly common in journalism.
- jjp 11y agoOr it's been SEO'd to cover all the bases of related keywords.
- crispyambulance 11y agoAt first I thought it was on hacker news because the article was auto-generated by software (a "Show HN"), but actually, it appears to be written by a real person. Welcome to journalism in the era of dying newspapers, I guess.
- ryanSrich 11y agoIt's on HN because Your Mechanic is a YC company. A lot of readers blindly upvote anything YC related.
- eterm 11y agoHN is very opaque about how it ranks articles, I suspect that it's not only blind upvoting. If you look how articles move on hnranking, some move more naturally than others. This story in particular has a couple of very large boosts: http://hnrankings.info/11469285/ http://hnrankings.info/11469285/
- delinka 11y agoDo people memorize the YC company list? Are there enough that do and just instantly click 'upvote?'
- raldi 11y agoFor those of us who aren't as savvy as you, could you explain what the "Car" mistakes are?
- dsmithatx 11y agoI think he means that anyone who knows even a smidgen about cars would say v8 and not explain it like the audience didn't know what a v8 was.
- raldi 11y agoAh, I see; all true Scotsmen know what a V8 is. (I, for one, appreciated the extra clarification. If the article had just said, "14% of cars we service have a V8" it would have been accessible to a far narrower audience.)
- umanwizard 11y agoThe no true Scotsman fallacy doesn't mean that words don't have meanings or that it's impossible to reason about things. "This person writes like a novice and therefore probably doesn't know much about cars" doesn't invoke the fallacy at all, regardless of whether it happens to be true.
- raldi 11y agoI was referring to the remark that, "anyone who knows even a smidgen about cars" needs no explanation about V8s. I know more than a smidgen about cars, but I appreciated the explanation. Presumably, OP believes that I must not know a true smidgen about cars.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Erik816 11y agoEngine cylinders is also not a 1:1 predictor of engine "power." A 1970's or 80's V8 will have way less horsepower than some turbocharged 4 cylinder engine on a modern luxury car. All things being equal more cylinders could equal more power, but there are MANY other things that are not equal.
- mturmon 11y agoThe other one I noticed is the closing paragraph: "The car is at the very center of many Americans [sic] lives. It can be a necessity, passion and a way to establish identity. As the number of car choices has increased, the car makeup of American cities have [sic] become vastly different. People in the Midwest are more likely to choose powerful American cars, while people on the coast are more likely to go for foreign, energy efficiency [sic] ones. Increased choice has unveiled the distinct character of American automotive desires." It reads like a by-the-numbers high school essay. Tell them what you're going to tell them, tell them, tell them what you told them. Sprinkle in outright errors, failures of parallelism, passive voice, and wordiness (...are more likely to...are more likely to...). The rote approach combined with the anodyne results put this reader to sleep.
- MajorLOL 11y agoYeah... or the chart that talks about Subaru ownership but forgot to edit the caption below and it still the same thing as the V8 chart...
- serge2k 11y agoIt reads like an "ELI5 V8"