4 ms·
>> What is the alternative? These people aren't forced to live there. If there were a cheaper, better alternative available to them, they'd probably take it. W
by YeGoblynQueenne 11y ago
>> What is the alternative? These people aren't forced to live there. If there were a cheaper, better alternative available to them, they'd probably take it.
What sort of lame excuse is that for exploitation? "These people could be much
worse off if they were being exploited more"? Well, duh. The point is that
they're in a dire situation in the first place because they're being
exploited. Their landlord is not some benevolent benefactor, he or she is the
purveyor of their misery, that's the only reason why he or she has a say in how
deep that misery is.
By analogy, imagine you grab someone off the street and beat the shit out of them.
You break their ribs, kick their teeth in, bash in their skull, but stop just
short of killing them. Then you go "hey, it could be much worse: I could have
killed you".
Well, yeah, you could have. You could also have avoided attacking them in the
first place. They're not "better off" thanks to you, they're much worse off than
they could have been because of you.
- thecopy 11y agoSo what you are, in effect, saying, is that these poor people would be better off if the owner of the trailer park would kick them all out? Then they would not be "exploited". I am inclined to believe you are a troll, because the distinction between an aggression of violence and a voluntary free exchange on the market is quite easy to make, which in your argument you fail to do.
- crdoconnor 11y agoIf every time you took an ambulance you were forced to sign over 80% of your wealth or be left to die in the streets in a 'voluntary exchange', that would be exploitation. The difference between that and slumlords is simply a matter of degree. Desperation is the route to profit in both cases. Truly voluntary exchanges without gaping chasms of systemic inequality do not provide opportunities for sustained profit.
- thecopy 11y agoI get the point in your scenario. The simple matter of "degree" in this case might be simple but it is very big. First of all, i would say that your scenario is unrealistic. It is made up and it would never happen in actual real life. First of all, what psychopaths would leave a dying man, woman or child like that? Also, how would these ambulances get customers? Thirdly, who would sign up for their ambulance service? Yes, if we accept your premise of a society where this psychopath ambulance service has a monopoly and everyone is forced to use it, then sure, it is exploitation. But on the other hand, someone with authority has therefore sanctioned this psychopath monopoly ambulance service. Where did this authority get this mandate? Democracy? If you want to argue that this scenario would happen on the free market, i would like to see your arguments to why this ambulance service would still have customers. If you control the premise of the arguments, it is easy to "win".
- crdoconnor 11y agoThe largest fortune in the Roman empire was amassed in almost exactly the same manner (Marcus Linnus Crassus - he ran a fire service). Desperation is a rich source of profit. Neoclassical economics, instead of analyzing this sordid detail, masks it with assumptions. That's why you view it as an unrealistic scenario despite the massive amount of historical precedent. Under econ 101 models (perfectly equal wealth; perfectly competitive market) it is an unrealistic scenario.
- pyrale 11y ago> First of all, what psychopaths would leave a dying man, woman or child like that? Apparently, the same kind that would leave children living in a cardboard box in front of their job. Life as described in the article sucks, but it's still orders of magnitude better than living on the street.
- pliny 11y ago>If every time you took an ambulance you were forced to sign over 80% of your wealth or be left to die in the streets in a 'voluntary exchange', that would be exploitation. What is wrong with this scenario? If there were no ambulance service I automatically choose "Die" (which is, apart from matters of inheritance, always the wrong choice), but if there is the ambulance service I can buy my life for the relatively meagre price of 80% of my wealth, then having neither children nor wife I would take that deal ten times out of ten.
- crdoconnor 11y agoI presume you're familiar with the term "false dilemma" and how it applies to your post?
- pliny 11y agoI don't see the false dilemma, I think you're hinting at a third choice where the ambulance company charges a price that is not extortionate, but if that was part of the hypothetical then, sure, I would have chosen to get my emergency care from the company that charges less (but it's not, the GP postulated that all ambulance companies charge 80%). Either way it's not exploitation, even if there's a company that charges prices that always bankrupt their patients, I still choose broke over dead, and if I wanted to choose dead I can do that too.
- logfromblammo 11y agoAll prices, everywhere, are limited in some way by the cost of a torches-and-pitchforks mob to storm the chateau. I'd pay the price on the spot, because I like not being dead. But afterward, I think I'd try to rob that guy to get my 80% back, and maybe some of the 80% from some other people. That's not a "thank you so much, you're my hero" price. That's a "better watch your back" price. When too many people start to see you as a parasite upon their community rather than a foundation pillar for it, they will certainly reduce their rate of cooperation with you, and some may retaliate. You may have to acquire a taste for other people's spit in your restaurant food, for instance. And worst of all, you may motivate someone to launch a business in direct competition with yours. Then, if your choice is 80% to the dirty exploiter or waiting a few more minutes for a Medic-Uber to pick you up take you to the hospital, you would almost have to be gushing blood from a major artery to accept the former.
- Kalium 11y agoBy this logic, all economic exchanges are terrifying exploitative coercion, differing only in degree.
- YeGoblynQueenne 11y ago>> I am inclined to believe you are a troll Classy.
- darawk 11y agoIn what sense is their landlord purveying their misery? They need a place to live. The landlord offers such a place. They enter into a voluntary exchange of domicile for cash, terminable at any time. Where is the exploitation? Nobody is being tricked or duped. Two people are coming together to exchange something without coercion, intimidation, or trickery.
- YeGoblynQueenne 11y ago>>In what sense is their landlord purveying their misery? In the sense that he or she is charging 70% of their monthly income for rent. And it's coercion alright if the alternative is being left homeless.
- thecopy 11y ago>In the sense that he or she is charging 70% of their monthly income for rent. No. He or she is charging an absolute amount, not a percentage of their payslip. >And it's coercion alright if the alternative is being left homeless. Coercion /koʊˈɜːrʃən/ is the practice of forcing another party to act in an involuntary manner by use of intimidation or threats or some other form of pressure. There is no coercion here. Poor people are not mindless sheep, they have their own will, their own goals and their own plans. If they live there it is because they chose it. Not the landlord, and not "the rich".
- YeGoblynQueenne 11y ago>> He or she is charging an absolute amount, not a percentage of their payslip. Here's another analogy. I make this beautiful and unique item that you want to buy. I charge - literally - an arm and a leg over it. Like, the actual body parts. You protest: "You're asking for a part of my body??". I reply "I'm asking for an arm and a leg, not a part of your body". Hey, maybe you can pay me with someone else's arm-and-a-leg, right? That is how absurd it is to say what you just said. >> There is no coercion here. Yeah, there totally is. It's the same kind of coercion the Mafia employes. "You don't want to pay us to protect your establishment? Well, fine, but then something may happen to it". You don't want to pay 70% of your income to stay at my dirty, dilapidated hovel? That's fine, but then you might find yourself homeless. The tactics are similar because the mindset is similar. Pay up or else. It's exactly how it works and it's precisely why it's coercive and morally repugnant. More to the point: I find it morally repugnant because I don't have to pay 70% of my income to stay at a trailer, and I make probably 70 times more than the people who are forced to live there. There is no excuse for that. If I payed 70% of my income to live in a shithole, then I would think, OK, that's how it goes. That's life, see? Except, it's not. I know it's quite easy to get a much better deal, as I got. If someone forced me to live in such conditions, I'd be up in arms. Therefore, I also do mind a lot that other people are living in such conditions.