4 ms·
With 131 properties she probably also has an employee or two to help her manage and repair them. My main problem is I just don't see what the alternative is.
by CydeWeys 11y ago
With 131 properties she probably also has an employee or two to help her manage and repair them.
My main problem is I just don't see what the alternative is. Any rental housing needs to be minimally profitable or no one will bother providing it. That applies at all ends of the pricing spectrum. So if a profit can't even be made, what is the alternative? Millions of people homeless because there are no properties rentable at a price they can afford?
- danharaj 11y agoYou don't see any alternatives because you are not challenging the premise of private property enforced by a state. That is a very strong assumption that precludes most possibilities. And state property is just a degenerate form of private property where one entity owns everything.
- CydeWeys 11y agoSo what exactly are you proposing then? If no one can own anything then the best available will be little more than tents; think nomadic hunter-gatherer societies.
- danharaj 11y agoThat's an incredible statement, what's your support for it?
- CydeWeys 11y agoHow about you answer one of my questions before you ask me yet another one. What exactly are you proposing if neither people nor government are allowed to own property? I'm not aware of any such scheme in all of modern civilization. The onus is on you to explain.
- danharaj 11y agoI think that's a very open ended question, but a very good scholarly source describing alternative systems to governing resources that isn't too radical but is also substantially different from privatization and market systems is "Governing the Commons" by Elinor Ostrom. She's got a Nobel prize in economics if that lends her work any credibility.
- tamana 11y agoLand-Value Tax. Landlord makes money by improving the land and providing services to residents, not by merely owning land in perpetuity. Land is common wealth.
- CydeWeys 11y agoSo I'll admit that personally I'm intrigued by land-value tax, but it's not an answer to the other guy's question. He was precluding all public and private land ownership. There can't be taxes on land of any kind if no one owns anything and no ownership is enforced.
- undersuit 11y agoWhy can't there be taxes on land and no ownership? You can't tax land use? Are all the shelters floating above the land? No records? What's the problem that makes taxing land with no ownership untenable?
- CydeWeys 11y agoThere wouldn't be any shelters on unowned land because it would be foolish to improve it if anyone could take your improvements from you at a moment's notice. Now you need a government to enforce exclusive use of the land by a given person, and guess what, that's ownership.
- undersuit 11y agoBut you're paying taxes on the shelter. Your shelter. If someone takes your improvement from you that's theft. We have laws regarding theft in most countries do we not?