3 ms·
Of course it profitable, which is why we have things like minimum wage - if WalMart et. al. could, they would pay 3 cents an hour, or even better consume people
by grecy 11y ago
Of course it profitable, which is why we have things like minimum wage - if WalMart et. al. could, they would pay 3 cents an hour, or even better consume peoples living and eating and entire lives like factories in China.
At some point the governments in developed countries have stepped in to set some kind of limit on what's "reasonable".
IMHO, they're not doing enough in America right now, the enormous social divide is showing that to us clearly. Developed countries that have stronger laws have less people in severe poverty, because the government forces the wealthy to distribute their wealth.
- brbsix 11y agoDon't you want to get the highest salary for a particular job? Don't you want to pay the lowest price for a particular product? Employers are just doing the same. So what if WalMart wants to hire someone for 3 cents an hour? Maybe I'd like to pay my doctor $1/hr. Either way, it's probably not going to happen. People will not accept $0.03/hr for a job unless it is of benefit to them. Also I find it incredibly condescending to believe you (or the government) know the opportunities available to people in poverty better than they themselves do. Lastly with regards to 'government forces the wealthy to distribute their wealth', wealthy people generally have quite a few options, to include the option to exempt themselves from paying what some would consider "their fair share".
- cmdrfred 11y agoWhile not 3 cents an hour currently Walmart pays wages below the cost of living. How do they achieve this you ask? The government steps in and raises these wages with a number of social programs (food stamps, housing subsidies, tax credits, etc). Cut the social programs and those workers won't be able to afford coming into work. Pretty soon, up goes wages.
- orangecat 11y agoif WalMart et. al. could, they would pay 3 cents an hour Sure. Of course they can't, because most of the time even poor people have other options. Also WalMart has in fact supported raising the minimum wage, which is either a virtuous act of corporate responsibility or an attempt to increase the burden on their competitors. because the government forces the wealthy to distribute their wealth I just finished my taxes. Quite a bit of my wealth is being "distributed", unfortunately mostly to well-off retired people and on bombs to drop on the Middle East.
- grecy 11y ago> Sure. Of course they can't, because most of the time even poor people have other options. If there were no laws, every company would do this, and there wouldn't be other option. You think people work in factories in China for $0.50/day even though they have an option to make a good wage? > Quite a bit of my wealth is being "distributed" Not nearly as much as if you lived in another developed country, where your money would be paying for healthcare for all, higher education for all, etc. etc.
- brbsix 11y agoWhat you've just said is pretty much identical to "if there were no laws, every company would charge $1 million for every product and there wouldn't be another option". Do you realize how utterly ridiculous that sounds? You really think the only thing preventing a company from paying employees $0.03/hr is a law? Minimum wage in SF is $12.25. By your logic, I should expect every employer to pay no more than $12.25/hr. Why do I not see this?
- grecy 11y agoMy "logic" is real, not theory. Without laws, there are people making $0.50/day and the air is not breathable in China.
- throwaway_exer 11y ago> "Not nearly as much as if you lived in another developed country, where your money would be paying for healthcare for all, higher education for all, etc. etc. " Really, you're going to trot out American healthcare? There is no place on earth with higher healthcare costs than the USA.
- tamana 11y agoWalmart can "Support" raising the minimum wage but conveniently fail to achieve it.