6 ms·
When Facebook was relatively new, that's exactly what its users (including me) did. In many ways, it was a better short-blogging platform than LiveJournal, and
by otterley 11y ago
When Facebook was relatively new, that's exactly what its users (including me) did. In many ways, it was a better short-blogging platform than LiveJournal, and many us of left to enjoy the future of personal sharing.
Then, over time, Facebook added new kinds of content to the News Feed, and added one-click re-sharing. People eventually found it easier to just click mouse buttons than make their own statements.
Next, they started curating people's News Feeds, selecting the content Facebook thought was important, instead of showing a raw stream of their friends' updates. Personal updates were squelched; linkbait and social gaming (Zynga, anyone?) were promoted.
To make matters worse, they stopped allowing subscribers to control their own News Feeds' content. Sure, you could hide updates from certain posters, or express a vague preference to "hide content like this" (whatever that means), but you could only do that one item at a time. There was never a way to control the News Feed to filter out everything but personal content. As a consequence of these maneuvers, Facebook expressed a clear business preference to keep people engaged through low-quality, quick-dopamine-hit content.
And those who continued to try to use Facebook as they'd done before noticed these changes. Their "Like" counts went down. People stopped commenting. In fact it became clear that perhaps what they were posting -- even party invitations -- were never being seen by their friends at all.
So, it's natural that people stopped posting personal updates. For many, if Facebook isn't going to guarantee that your friends see them, taking the time to write starts to seem like wasted effort. And that's exactly what it felt like for me.
So, now Facebook wants us to post more about ourselves. But they created this problem. If they want to solve it, they already know how, because the site made it a great place to do so 10 years ago. But I doubt that they will, because it conflicts too strongly with their profit motive.
- sdegutis 11y agoIt's fascinating to watch a few college kids fill a niche, become super successful, and then ruin the whole thing. It started out as an exclusive social club, which is what made it work. Now everyone and their grandma (literally) uses it as nothing more than an alternative to email and newspapers. The writing's on the wall, Facebook is already dead, they just don't realize it.
- vt240 11y agoThis is the same reason I don't share anymore. I will post photos from a trip and my own parents wont see it in their news feed. It just feels like, "what's the point?", I might as well just e-mail them directly. Edit: At the same time, boosted posts for business pages targeting friends of friends seem to actually work well now. For a $20 investment, the phone actually rings, and it generates real sales.
- nickjackson 11y agoGreat reply!
- ams6110 11y agoI think you nailed it. I never was a facebook user, but my wife, kids, and in-laws got into it. None of them use it anymore because it's too difficult to use as a personal sharing platform and there's too much noise that they aren't interested in.
- Terr_ 11y agoExactly right. Facebook contains useful and visible content... But the visible content is not useful, and the useful content is not visible. It's a trap they built for themselves out of short-term thinking in the past, and even if they manage to change their own behavior (unlikely) it'll be a slow process replenishing the base of "users who care".
- wlesieutre 11y agoIt also used to enforce the "$name is _________" format on status updates. You could put whatever you wanted in the box, but it was structured for posting about yourself / your life. IIRC they went to the freeform timeline posts in order to imitate twitter's "share whatever at whoever" market, lest users who wanted to post other content go somewhere else with it.
- Jordrok 11y agoI couldn't agree more. I joined thefacebook in 2004 and at the time it was a great way to connect with peers and get to know a bit about how they think and what their interests are. (Remember when clicking on a movie title or band name would just show you a list of other people in your network who also had it listed?) These days there's just so much noise that it becomes a waste of time to do anything more involved than clicking the like button and moving on. Facebook needs to realize that they can't have it both ways. Facebook is either a site for people or a site for advertisers, not both.
- wodenokoto 11y ago> There was never a way to control the News Feed to filter out everything but personal content. What do you mean? You can ban links on a domain level.
- wodenokoto 11y agoIf someone shares a link from buzzfeed you can hide the post from your feed and then choose "Never see links from buzzfeed again"