4 ms·
Complaints about the carried interest issue bug me. (It's not an exception -- it's just how partnerships work.) IMO the problem has nothing to do with carried
by amluto 11y ago
Complaints about the carried interest issue bug me. (It's not an exception -- it's just how partnerships work.)
IMO the problem has nothing to do with carried interest or hedge funds in particular. I think the real issue is our bizarre idea that certain types of income (long-term capital gains) are special and should be taxed less. Hedge funds (and only the kind that generate long-term gains) are just easy things to pick on.
Have you noticed that pretty much every large corporation carefully avoids corporate taxes and arranges for its principals' income to be mostly long-term capital gains or qualified dividends? It's the same failure mode, minus the hedge fund.
So yes, I think Congress should fix the problem, but I don't think that carried interest is the problem.
- drawkbox 11y agoIn a perfect game system you'd probably make labor income taxes less than capital gains on investment. Yes you want to encourage investment but you also want to feed the economy with monetary velocity or cash money. The fact is lower/middle class labor income workers put more directly back into the economy than the wealthy "job creators", so who are the real job creators? Demand is the job creator! Demand comes from people that spend having cash. Capital locked up in hoarding does not help the economy as much especially in downturns. Lower/middle class spend almost all their incremental income dollar while the rich typically spend less than 5% of each incremental dollar. If the lower/middle class has cash then you have demand, demand leads to investment, and jobs/growth.
- Anonobread 11y ago> In a perfect game system you'd probably make labor income taxes less than capital gains on investment Indeed you would [1]. According to some legal scholars, wages earned from labor were/are not supposed to be taxed at all in America. The tax code was designed to tax investment gains only. Just imagine if that were upheld > The fact is lower/middle class labor income workers put more directly back into the economy than the wealthy "job creators" By doing what? Consuming consumables marketed to them by Corporations? The same Corporations that would just as soon replace most of their menial labor with robots. Also, I'd curb your exuberance towards believing the lower/middle class "puts more back into the economy", because to the extent the lower/middle class is increasingly replaced by robots or cheap foreign labor, if this is your true belief then we should institute a universal income. Because that's going to "put more back into the economy". > Demand comes from people that spend But for example, planned obsolescence encourages spending. But is planned obsolescence really a tangible benefit for the "people that spend"? Also, imagine if "cash" was of fixed supply (Bitcoin) rather than inflationary. In which case, you could make paper gains over time by not spending it or investing it. Wouldn't this provide more people with financial security given the risks and complexity of investing money in general? [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_protester_statutory_arguments https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_protester_statutory_argume...
- drawkbox 11y ago> Also, imagine if "cash" was of fixed supply (Bitcoin) rather than inflationary. In which case, you could make paper gains over time by not spending it or investing it. Wouldn't this provide more people with financial security given the risks and complexity of investing money in general? New currencies are needed but bitcoin and old school gold for that matter encourage hoarding, gold is worse because the control of gold is owned by physical mining. At least bitcoin doesn't leave monetary value up to physical mining, but still it does encourage hoarding. If a currency gains value over time doing nothing then investment will be lower. Fiat currencies encourage investment because the value of your money goes down if it sits and is hoarded. Even though control of the currency is by the Fed and shadowy banking cabals, at least it spawns investment by wealth as they like to increase their money not see it slowly fade away to inflation. Investment is key to growth/innovation but there has to be some demand there. Demand creation is always overlooked, when wages aren't raised, when companies move out of the US etc. These things directly impact demand and purchasing power of consumers at all levels eventually. What will the robots build, sell or manage if noone has any money to buy anything? I don't necessarily buy that robots will remove all work. Computers were supposed to do the same, it has just enabled productivity gains to do more with less. There will always be more work to do, we haven't even explored very far off this rock. We need robots at every level but it won't mean less work, we'll have robot armies and it will enable entrepreneurs to do more with less.
- jcfrei 11y ago>What will the robots build, sell or manage if noone has any money to buy anything? I don't necessarily buy that robots will remove all work. I believe we will witness the rise of the leisure economy. Most people who still hold jobs will perform them in fields related to tourism and leisure activities, such as yoga teachers, tour guides, climbing, diving, boxing, golf instructors, etc. Basically robots/computers will eventually perform all tasks which do not necessarily require a human. Or in other words: The leisure industry will always require humans because it's catering for human experiences and not human needs.
- Anonobread 11y agoConsumers don't buy 2% more chicken at the grocery store just because "inflation is 2%". That's total nonsense with no basis in reality. And investors will still make traditional investments in a deflationary environment, BTC denominated loan markets and "IPOs" are the case in point to that end. Granted, in a deflationary environment, investments will be less profitable if the projects being invested in are dependent on consumers spending money frivolously. > Investment is key to growth/innovation but there has to be some demand there. Demand creation is always overlooked, when wages aren't raised, when companies move out of the US etc. These things directly impact demand and purchasing power of consumers at all levels eventually. Society gains purchasing power at large in a deflationary environment. And note that, if the American economy grows 10% in a year, the Fed will still strive for inflation. If economic growth is 10% and inflation is 1%, the upper echelons of society will have skimmed 10% off the top, robbing society of that growth. Conversely, in a Bitcoin world, the 10% economic growth is returned to the savers in the form of more purchasing power.
- jwdunne 11y agoIt's interesting because, as a layman, this sounds a lot like what Keynes said: aggregate demand is the most relevant factor. Hell, using those ideas pulled us out of the great depression. Then there's the Friedman supply-side argument that only aggregate supply matters. The demand curve is effectively vertical. Arguably, this seemed to have heaved Britain out of stagflation thanks to Thatcher. We now see raging inequality that these policies seem to promote. Between these two theories of macroeconomics, it seems to mW that we swing between either extreme without considering a middle ground - both are important. Either extreme seems to have a long-term negative effect. When aggregate demand falls sharply in a recession, measures to rectify seems appropriate. This keeps people spending in a time where they typically wouldn't. When businesses struggle, due to a shock in supply, measures to ease this on that end too seem appropriate. In a way, it seems a lot of economics is used with political bias. Certain all-or-nothing theories tend to be used as the means to an ideologue's ends within a democratic system.
- dnautics 11y agoWhat if the middle ground just gives you the worst of the both worlds. What if the idea of measuring the success of an economy via an aggregate quantity is flawed? It seems to me that optimizing for aggregate demand or aggregate supply will merely result in redistributing to politically connected individuals who are able to convince the authorities that their programme will improve that metric.
- jwdunne 11y agoIn fairness, if economics is the study of allocation of scarce resources, which is implicitly a study of human behaviour wrt a limited resource in individuals, slightly larger functional groups (families and firms) and then large populations as a whole, then surely we are within the realm of psychology and sociology. The thing is that psychology gives us ideas that shows how humans can be influenced individually (think foot in the door or an incredible offer that ain't really an incredible offer). Sociology gives us ideas of how humans can be influenced in groups that, in literal terms, will give away their freedom and rights with tears of happiness in their eyes to a charismatic speaker who says the right things in hard times. How does supply and demand fit in all of that when the assumption in the model is that we behave rationally? How does the work on habit formation fit into that? How does peer pressure? I smoke cigs. I pay for take out food and chocolate. Before I got a car, I'd get a cab to work even though I had a bus pass. Now I'm not holding myself up as a model of the actual man but that's the point: the homo economicus is like the description of someone's ideal of homo sapiens. Ideally, that's how we should make decisions about resources. In actuality, I think it's just far off the mark to cause what would be sound decisions to work out not so well. Economics to me is like a social science trying to be used as a hard science and in a position to be quite dangerous.
- sidko 11y agoTaxing capital gains less than ordinary income is a crude method to ensure that you're not being taxed on your losses (in terms of real purchasing power). Unless that's fixed first, there is no way you should be paying for losses. Based on today's taxation laws, if you bought a stock for $100 10 years ago, and sold it for $110 today, you'll be taxed for the $10 "gain" even though in real terms you lost a fair amount of money. Calculating the real loss (not the nominal gain) is complicated because you need to consider inflation each year into the calculation and the IRS doesn't allow for that. Not disagreeing that capital and labor need to be taxed at the same rate, but the situation is trickier than just saying "lets tax all gains and wages at the same rate".
- Retric 11y agoThe benefit of inflation is punishing unproductive investments and keep capital in play. Which is why economists want 2-3% not 0. As such low long term capital gains taxes are a bad idea economically. Ideally the tax rate should increase for every year an asset is held. Such that there is no bias for liquidating new assets instead of old ones. Which is effectivly the same as paying capital gains each year. On the flip side the annual rate could be set as low as 5% or capital gains = 1 - (0.95^(number of years)). Which is actually rather close to inflation targets.
- dnautics 11y agoThe downside of inflation is that is screws the poor and redistributes wealth to the already rich. The former is evidenced by our need to continually increase the minimum wage and the latter occurs because the middle class is pushed into investments to beat inflation, socializing business risk while leaving the gains to the already wealthy.
- knughit 11y agoInflation punishes people who assets. Poor people only suffer when their nominal wages don't grow to match inflation -- but that's exactly the same as their employers lowering wages in an inflation-free environment. Inflation is only superficially related to the problem of real wage reductions.
- kemiller 11y agoThe trouble with high taxes on capital gains and dividends is that the corporation itself is subject to a rather high tax already. So the underlying productive activity in a corp is taxed twice on its way to the ultimate owners. (Barring trickery.)
- knughit 11y agoDividends, yet. But not all stock growth is due to realized profit. Look at AMZN for example.
- amluto 11y agoIf I could rewrite the tax code myself, in addition to treating capital gains and ordinary income the same, I'd seriously consider sharply reducing or even eliminating the corporate tax. As you said, the corporate tax is an annoying form of double taxation, but governments have also proven to be terrible at actually collecting the corporate tax from big corporations. So really it's the smaller corporations' owners being double taxed. The one thing I don't like about that scheme is that it makes C corporations into a way for anyone to defer taxation as long as they like. This isn't necessarily a terrible thing, but it could make sense to force owners of corporations (or at least of new fancy untaxed corporations) to realize their gains periodically. Obviously this isn't 100% thought out. But neither is the current US tax code.
- millama 11y agoCarried interest isn't the problem, but it is a problem. I get you're upset because you combined a tautology (arguing that it's fine for carried interest to be taxed how it is because that's how it's taxed) with pedantry (being upset that people refer to a carried interest exemption, when they really mean that the tax laws which define income were written in an exploitable manner, such that partnership income is considered capital gains even if the risk capital was provided by others and the partners were engaging in ordinary professional activity). But what the hell is the point of your post, beyond letting us all know that you're not terribly intelligent? Was that it? Did you just think that the world needs to know that amluto is a silly and unintelligent pedant? If so, well done!
- tim333 11y ago>carried interest [is] not an exception -- it's just how partnerships work Oh bollocks. Carried interest is blatantly income for the fund managers. Treating it as anything else for tax purposes is down to basically bribing politicians. The whole concept of calling it "carried interest" rather than income is a US only invention.