7 ms·
Supermassive black holes may be lurking everywhere in the universe
- ck2 11y agoWould our brains even be able to detect the moments the earth entered one? We'd probably get a little warning from amateur astronomers as they freaked out months before it happens.
- huuu 11y agoWhat if we entered one and came out on the other side without even noticing something happened?
- sunshinerag 11y agoWhat if that already happened/happening/happenwhen
- gonzo41 11y agothere is no other side. its not a physical hole. its a gravity hole. Think of a moon that drags you onto it. You can't ever have enough power to reverse moving towards it. Light isn't quick enough to leave the pull. thus it is dark.
- nonbel 11y ago>"there is no other side. its not a physical hole." Isn't a black hole more like an edge of the universe? My understanding is that you end up with a Zeno's paradox situation where no matter how close you get you can never actually reach it.
- xtacy 11y agoNot quite -- in your reference frame, you cross the blackhole's event horizon and go inside, but an observer (who is outside the event horizon) will only see you reach the event horizon and slowly "fade away."
- nonbel 11y agoThanks, so what is the deal with the four-velocity always equaling c^2? Ie (maybe it is totally wrong): c^2 = (v_t)^2 - (v_x)^2 - (v_y)^2 - (v_z)^2 where v_i indicates speed along that dimension. I thought this was why all the weird time dilation effects occur, velocity along time v_t ->0 as velocity through space increases. You seem to be saying that from the traveler's perspective they are not accelerating faster and faster towards the black hole. As I said, maybe my understanding is just totally incorrect here. Edit: Actually, I was really confused (this is all based on looking it up the other day). According to the above, v_t would need to increase as eg v_x increases. This is just wrong, but I'll leave it here in case someone wants to explain it correctly.
- raattgift 11y agoThis is asking an essential Special Relativity (SR) question into a conversation about an object where gravitation is not just relevant but central, so I'll also give you an a modern Special Relativity answer cast in such a way to follow with a couple of comments about "c" in General Relativity. Below you'll note that I'll treat GR strictly as geometry. Your equation is some algebraic mangling of the Minkowski line-element, which we can write as ds^2 = -cdt^2 + dx^2 + dy^2 + dz^2 in Cartesian coordinates with a -+++ metric signature. That's the interval in flat spacetime (aka Minkowski spacetime, although in both cases sometimes "time" is omitted when a reader will not be confused). The conversion constant "c" there is the sole free parameter of the Poincare group, which is the local isometry group of Minkowski spacetime (i.e., it applies each point in spacetime), which includes translations, Lorentz boosts and rotations on the three spacelike axes (x, y, and z in the form above) and a unidirectional translation on the timelike axis (t). The parameter corresponds (in SR) to the speed of a massless particle, and light is assumed to be massless. It's a postulate of Special Relativity that all non-gravitational physics is invariant under the Poincare group, and that's baked into the Standard Model, for instance. However, in GR "c" corresponds to the surface of a nonempty, convex, open cone of tangent vectors at some point p on the (curved) manifold; light at point p is constrained to that surface exactly, and massive particles at point p stay inside that boundary. In GR we can only meaningfully compare speed and velocity locally, where that means either in the limit as spacetime intervals go to zero, or equivalently in the local section of the fibre bundle, because the very definition of spacetime curvature means the parallel transport of one vector to another for comparison purposes is path-dependent, and that applies on all four axes, so we cannot even meaningfully compare two clocks (with which we might measure relative velocity) unless they are at the same point in spacetime. However, we can work things out so that a small (but not exactly zero-sized) region of spacetime is treated as flat, and then use Special Relativity or even Newtonian mechanics to discuss the matter content in that region, right down to comparing velocities. This "flattening" can be done quite successfully in a number of ways, and can even be done in a region with significant curvature by using the formalisms of semiclassical gravity. The cost is in artifacts introduced into the non-gravitational content of the region of non-negligbly curved spacetime, most noticeably in terms of differences in particle count and even the interpretation of matter field excitations as particles. This mathematical "flattening away" of the curvature returns us from a causal cone built on a hyperbolization of a series of first-order quasilinear partial differential equations (the Einstein Field Equations) to the Poincare group applying at every point, and thus we return to "c" as being mathematically special, rather than relating to one of perhaps many causal cones (since one can have many hyperbolizations, and thus many timelike-spacelike conversion constants although so far there is only evidence for one).
- huuu 11y agoOf course I was half joking. It's not about if light is quick enough to leave the pull. It's about the light not being fast enough to be stopped by the mass. If light is accelerating towards the center fast enough so the mass won't be able to stop it the light will go though it. But ofcourse that means that light should go faster than light.
- ceejayoz 11y agoThe stars would start disappearing and being distorted millennia before, I'd imagine.
- imglorp 11y agoWe'd see it coming long before. They emit radiation at many frequencies, plus all the stars orbiting them (ie, a galaxy) indicate the mass of what they're orbiting. So if you happen to see any galaxies coming towards us in the next billion years (aside from Andromeda) do let the world know.
- jfoster 11y agoAre there any risks associated with them? For instance, a burst of radiation that obliterates us? Is that possible?
- ianlevesque 11y agoNo, but definitely don't look up gamma ray bursts.
- MichaelApproved 11y agoA couple of great YouTube channel for anyone interested in this stuff. The videos range from surface explanations to actual math equations. https://www.youtube.com/pbsspacetime https://www.youtube.com/pbsspacetime and https://www.youtube.com/user/sixtysymbols https://www.youtube.com/user/sixtysymbols
- MichaelApproved 11y agoHere's a classic video that helps grasp (if that's even possible) the size of a supermassive black hole https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QgNDao7m41M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QgNDao7m41M
- Fiahil 11y agoThanks, it was short, but informative! If I may, I would like to point to another kind of supermassive black hole: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xsp3_a-PMTw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xsp3_a-PMTw :)
- SagelyGuru 11y agoCould someone please explain to me in plain English, how is it that the black holes "emit radiation at many frequencies" and, at the same time, "the light is unable to leave their pull"??
- badlogic 11y agoAs surrounding matter falls into the black hole, it heats up and emits radiation. There's also Hawking radiation, but that's not detectable.
- alphydan 11y agoTo be slightly more specific: Astronomers think there is a black hole when you see gas moving very very fast towards an invisible and massive object. That gas heats up from the friction of its particles moving rapidly towards the black hole. This heated gas emits X or Gamma radiation when it travels that fast. However, once it goes past the event horizon nothing else is seen. So you have something very heavy which is attracting objects and accelerating the surrounding gas. At the very "edge", sometimes pairs of particles are formed out of the vacuum (for example an electron and an anti-electron (positron)). Hawking asked: What if one particle leaves away from the horizon, but the other one leaves towards the center of the black hole? We would see an object that is sending particles from its event horizon. So in some sense particles would escape from the edge of the black hole. That's Hawking radiation (in simplified terms).
- pflanze 11y agoHmm, so there is this thing where physical theories seem to predict that each piece of matter should be complemented with an according piece of anti-matter (because those then make themselves "whole" by turning into pure energy), but we don't know where the anti-matter is. Your description made me think, could it all be in black holes?
- Natanael_L 11y agoAntimatter is still regular matter, but with the exact opposite charge to the common particles we keep seeing. So technically yes, it could all have disappeared into black holes, but it wouldn't really be antimatter anymore after entering the singularity due to being effectively broken down into pure energy/matter.
- kowdermeister 11y agoRelated reading, URL says it all https://aeon.co/essays/is-the-black-hole-at-our-galaxy-s-centre-a-quantum-computer https://aeon.co/essays/is-the-black-hole-at-our-galaxy-s-cen... Imagine a civilization building black hole computers in their solar system. That's pretty badass :)
- swatkat 11y agoOff-topic query: The above linked aeon.co article has these opening lines: After you die, your body’s atoms will disperse and find new venues, making their way into oceans, trees and other bodies. But according to the laws of quantum mechanics, all of the information about your body’s build and function will prevail. The relations between the atoms, the uncountable particulars that made you you, will remain forever preserved, albeit in unrecognisably scrambled form – lost in practice, but immortal in principle. Can anyone point me to the article or wiki of this theory/phenomenon? I would like to read up more about it.
- Natanael_L 11y agoStudy the overlap between information theory / entropy and physics.
- wodenokoto 11y agoIf you think of the world as being deterministic then the way your atoms will react with other atoms (their place in time and space) will be a direct consequence of where they were before, which again is a consequence of their previous state and we can track this all the way back to your current life.
- deathanatos 11y agoThat assumes that the universe is both deterministic and reversible. SHA2 is deterministic, but good luck reversing it. Essentially, to work backwards, time, when going forwards from state A would need to move to some unique state B. Consider two hills with a valley between them. In one universe, I roll a ball down one hill. In the other, I roll it down the opposite hill. In both, the ball ends up in the valley, and the information about which hill the ball rolled down is lost. You could perhaps argue that other effects (me disturbing the air on the hill I walked up) might still imply which hill the ball rolled down, but the question really is if such a scenario could exist, probably in a more simple form.