2 ms·
Well that was a bit unusual: > Posted by Thomas Frank ... > Reading Thomas Frank's new book, Listen, Liberal, or What Ever Happened to the Party of the Peopl
by tzs 11y ago
Well that was a bit unusual:
> Posted by Thomas Frank
...
> Reading Thomas Frank's new book, Listen, Liberal, or What Ever Happened to the Party of the People? [...]
...
> Let me just add that, as Frank makes clear in his brilliant new work [...]
...
> [...] Frank does a typically brainy thing.
You usually don't see people review their own books from a third person viewpoint, or point out how brilliant or brainy they are. The few times I have seen that have been in contexts where they were obviously trying to project an image of a giant ego for humorous purposes. I'm not familiar enough with this author to know if that's what he's going for in this review, or if he is seriously praising himself.
- mturmon 11y agoNah, you are mistaken, and the article has led you astray. The writer who wrote a few introductory paragraphs to the large book excerpt is not Thomas Frank himself. It's not 100% explicit, but the person writing these laudatory words is almost certainly Tom Englehart, the editor of TomDispatch. I've seen Thomas Frank speak and followed him for many years, since he and others founded the Baffler in Chicago in the late 80s. He's a Midwesterner through and through, grew up in suburban Kansas City, and has the characteristic modesty of the area.
- tzs 11y agoThat does appear to be the case, based on looking at some other reviews. It looks like it works like this, at least for authors who are TomsDispatch regulars: 1. Author Foo writes a book. 2. Tom Englehart writes a review, which consists of introductory material and then a long excerpt from the book. 3. Englehart's review appears on the site, but it says "Posted by Foo" at the top. The only mention of Englehart is that it says "Tom" in italics immediately after the last sentence of the introductory material. 4. At the bottom it says "Foo, a TomsDispatch regular, is the author of <name of book>". 5. At the bottom it says "Copyright <year> Foo". Basically everything on the page except for that lone italicized "Tom" after the introductory material makes it look like Foo wrote the review. In the case where firstname_of(Foo) == "Tom", everything on the page makes it look like Foo wrote the review.
- ars 11y agoPerhaps he just posted it, but did not write it?
- jamestnz 11y agoWow, that does come across as slightly unusual! I googled some verbatim sentences from the review, and it seems like various aggregators/wires have picked it up, and at least several are bylining the review to Tom Engelhardt (the "tom" of tomdispatch.com) and not to Thomas Frank himself. So maybe that's it. Here's one: http://www.unz.com/tengelhardt/thomas-frank-the-inequality-sweepstakes/ http://www.unz.com/tengelhardt/thomas-frank-the-inequality-s...