4 ms·
I feel like the problem is that people hate contrived examples. "You have to choose whether to kill one person to save five." Well, I don't want that choice, so
by AnthonyMouse 11y ago
I feel like the problem is that people hate contrived examples. "You have to choose whether to kill one person to save five." Well, I don't want that choice, so the first thing I'm going to do is look for alternatives that don't kill anybody. In the hypothetical that isn't allowed but in real life it is. A sufficiently clever person can in many cases figure out a way to save everybody, and either way the person who tries is justifiably more valued than the person who doesn't.
So what's wrong isn't choosing to save five people at the expense of one, it's the easy acceptance of killing anyone as a reasonable option.
- drdeca 11y agoI don't think it is impossible for a situation to occur where one has no option that saves any of the five without killing the one. Perhaps not any situation that ever has or ever will happen, but I don't think that there is not any situation that ever could happen like that. And therefore, while it might not have a high priority, I think it is a valid question.
- CapitalistCartr 11y agoThe question lacks nuance; its black and white, more than people's supposed morality. In reality, the World is complex. Maybe there isn't a way to save everyone, but people aren't going to take your word for it. The real-world answer is to look for a way. Ask black-and-white questions; get stupid, black-and-white answers.
- drdeca 11y agoWell, yeah, look for a way, and then, what do you do upon not finding one? You either act, or you do not, but you must choose.
- tim333 11y agoThat assumes you only have a yes no choice. That's almost never the case in real life.
- drdeca 11y agoSee "Perhaps not any situation that ever has or ever will happen, but I don't think that there is not any situation that ever could happen like that [I.e. I think that it is /possible/ for such a situation to happen.]. And therefore, while it might not have a high priority, I think it is a valid question." So, yes, I agree, such situations (where, upon looking, one finds no option better than either of the two) would be extremely rare. I still think the question of "If it does happen, what should you do?" is a valid one.
- x5n1 11y agoYou read stories about WWII and other military decisions which followed this sort of logic and sent millions of people to death or tested chemical weapons on their own troops. It was exactly this sort of contrived sort of logic. And you are absolutely right we always have other options available, if we just tune the axioms in our logic to look for those answers. It's funny but we see superheros in comics and movies deal a lot more effectively with these questions then we do some of our leaders. Who frame it in terms of win and lose, and the worst part is when they go against people that use that sort of logic, they are locked into these sorts of zero sum games.