4 ms·
Stephen Douglas, the politician who was too smart for his own good
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- gumby 11y agoA great example; there are many more (e.g. Gore), many of whom did attain power but failed as a result. It's a good lesson for founders as well.
- dosgonlogs 11y agoGeorge W.Bush is actually incredibly smart. I have read the book Bushisms. I know he has said plenty of stupid things on camera, and that he wasn't an A student at Yale, but I am tired of hearing this myth. http://keithhennessey.com/2013/04/24/smarter/ http://keithhennessey.com/2013/04/24/smarter/
- smitherfield 11y agoOne of my professors (a Democrat, and himself one of the smartest people I know) told me that, pre-presidency, he once spoke with Bush 43 for ~15 minutes, and came away extremely impressed with how intelligent and well-read Bush was. I think any of us would look pretty dumb if people obsessively transcribed every time we ever misspoke.
- jallmann 11y agoAgreed, leading the article with that was irksome -- and rather surprising, since the rest of the article did decent job of expounding on the the policy nuances of Stephen Douglas. Too often, media characterization of politics is a blunt caricature, which paints people and the issues in an unfair and misleading light. Reading the bit about the contested nominating convention was interesting, given that we might be headed into one this year. The contrast between now and then is stark -- the incredible gravity of the situation in 1860, whereas today's campaigns seem to draw more on personality than principle. I suppose we should consider ourselves fortunate enough that we can afford to be a little embarrassed of our politics right now -- a vote one way or the other is not going to pose an existential threat to the country for the next four years.
- humanrebar 11y ago> ...whereas today's campaigns seem to draw more on personality than principle. I disagree. There are lots of principles at stake. The open Supreme Court seat, for instance, is entirely a substantive issue. And almost everyone agrees it's one of (if not the) most important issue. But what is there to debate in 30 second soundbytes? What's missing is substantive debate on our principles. In the absence of actual debate, the media covers political contests as if they were horse races or sporting events. So it looks like people vote on personality, not issues. But what, I think, people are looking for is trust that the official will break their way when the chips are down, political pressure is on, and messy facts are laid out. In that way, the controversy over Douglas isn't that foreign, really. Voters who like Trump seem to think he's head-and-shoulders over the other candidates on certain issues (immigration being an obvious one).
- jallmann 11y ago> The open Supreme Court seat, for instance, is entirely a substantive issue It's important, but the "issue" is also entirely because of political grandstanding, not sensible policy making. It is also one which the presidential candidates really have no control over -- either they will get to appoint a new justice, or they won't. > But what is there to debate in 30 second soundbytes Nothing, which points to the problem: the 30 second soundbites themselves. So you have to ask, is that responsible journalism, or linkbait, using bumper sticker slogans to grab on to flighty eyeballs? Maybe the problem boils down to human nature, and our willingness to exploit it. > What's missing is substantive debate on our principles. Precisely. But I'll go out on a limb here and say that, in terms of historical precedent, the principles (or "issues," to put a less moralistic bent on it) we do have to debate are fairly shallow. More on that below. > people are looking for is trust that the official will break their way Indeed -- but a vote for trust is a vote for personality. Most people don't really listen to the specific details of policy positions -- they respond to whoever resonates with them on a personal level. Why is Hillary Clinton so popular with African-Americans? She is a master of identity politics. To say nothing of Donald Trump and his connection with blue-collar America. Ted Cruz and evangelicals, and so forth. In some way, the fact we're left with "trusting" our politicians is the crux of voter apathy. Most of the "issues" on the debate stage have little to no impact on the day-to-day lives of most Americans. Immigration, for example, is an important topic... for everybody not in the country. If you're already here, it's just a vote for who you think should be allowed into the club. Likewise for foreign policy, abortion, gay marriage, and so on... in most cases, it is people making decisions about other people (usually the majority for the minority), rather than a visible, tangible, deeply divisible national issue. In many ways, that's a blessing -- politics in America is a lot less fraught than even 50 years ago.
- salmonet 11y agoAgreed. Oddly, it seems like a lot of people have no problem believing that he was both an evil mastermind and also unintelligent.
- michaelbuddy 11y agoYup. Bush's people who have written books all talk about his focus and sharpness. We don't really know Obama's grades they are sealed.
- squozzer 11y agoThe article was interesting but rather unfair to Douglas and history. Douglas' weakness was not his intelligence but the boundaries in which it was applied. But the greatest flaw of this - and most analyses of the antebellum era - is that it does not sympathize with the problems of the past. In 1840, every step of cotton production involved human or animal power. There would be no technological solution delivered in time to avert a crisis. Consider the following possibilities if abolition had won a bloodless political victory - 1) former slaves compensated for their labor at market rates = US cotton production no longer economically viable, requiring a huge readjustment (i.e. recession.) And / or 2) slaves owners receiving compensation under amendment 5 of US Constitution = probably bankrupting the country. Stated more simply, the abolitionist position was ultimately a question of whose back would bear the burden of emancipation. The other fear - of whites whose labor was not cost-competitive in slave states, also could not be ignored in 1840. Adding to this was the stream of European migrants - who were also poor - into the North, whose only realistic choice was to move West. So, fellow HNers, what would you do in such a situation? Taking unilateral military action off the table of course. Without compromise, would the North been able to handle the South better in 1840 than 1860? Keep in mind our military strength relative to Mexico and Canada was not as lopsided as it is today. A political rupture in 1840 might have proved fatal as opportunists took advantage - consider how much blood France had to spill fighting off enemies after its revolution. The war did provide two political benefits - it mostly settled the slavery question, and it did not shift the burden entirely upon the South; the North had to put a little of its own skin in the game.
- rpgmaker 11y ago> But the greatest flaw of this - and most analyses of the antebellum era - is that it does not sympathize with the problems of the past. I think you're critiquing a different article than the one submitted here. The author never questions whether it was understandable that the South went to war to defend its economic interests. You're giving way too much credit to the South by implying that they were interested in finding an alternative to slavery which they weren't. After the war alternatives were found, were they not? They had less wealth but wealth generated from the use of slave labor is wealth that shouldn't exist in the first place. > The war did provide two political benefits - it mostly settled the slavery question, and it did not shift the burden entirely upon the South; the North had to put a little of its own skin in the game. If you accept that slavery isn't moral why is it a benefit that the North had to put some "skin in the game" in order to end it? After all, anyone in the North involved with the slave trade, however indirectly, already had some skin in the game and was going to feel the adverse economical effect if the practice was ended.