4 ms·
> For a judge to be able to order your computer unlocked, means people at Microsoft, at Lenovo (or whoever you use), and at your ISP all have the keys to unlock
by tzs 11y ago
> For a judge to be able to order your computer unlocked, means people at Microsoft, at Lenovo (or whoever you use), and at your ISP all have the keys to unlock your data even if you used an “encryption” feature. You have to trust every company, everywhere to never have a security incident involving the keys.
I've only read the thing once and so may have overlooked it, but I didn't see anything that implies that companies will have to keep keys. For encrypted data, they have to provide technical assistance in decrypting the data, but I didn't see anything that would make assisting with a brute force attack not qualify as technical assistance.
There was something in there about having to respond expeditiously (or something like that), but I think one could make a good argument that brute force is responding expeditiously as long as there is not a known faster way for that particular device.
- jhayward 11y agoDid you miss the part where they have to be able to decrypt conversations in real-time?
- woodman 11y ago> I didn't see anything that implies that companies will have to keep keys. That is the intent and the logical consequence, obviously they can't say "backdoor". If plain text goes into your device, software or service, and is stored, than you'd be required to provide the plain text on demand. Your product isn't a sha-2 algorithm that just happens to have a massive cloud backup service behind it, your product is a secure remote backup service. The folks who think this is a good idea are going to be the same ones nailing your ass to the wall for breaking their law, they won't entertain the excuse - they'll say that your choice in implementing a non-reversible feature demonstrates predetermination, a cyber booby-trap.