3 ms·
Something is broken here. Feinstein is so off base and so unaware of the implications of her proposal, she's forwarded a proposal that basically breaks the enti
by stcredzero 11y ago
Something is broken here. Feinstein is so off base and so unaware of the implications of her proposal, she's forwarded a proposal that basically breaks the entire internet. (Over time, all data security would degrade.) Especially considering that she has a history of doing this with legislation involving technical stuff. Dunning-Kruger with literally global downside. (Knee-jerk emotionally motivated legislation that's horribly broken.)
- abtinf 11y ago>and so unaware of the implications of her proposal I suggest you check your premises.
- stcredzero 11y agoIt fits the pattern of her misguided anti-gun laws. I think the implications don't matter to her, so long as the legislation resonates emotionally with uninformed voters. (EDIT: To clarify: from a rational perspective, some of her sponsored anti-gun laws primarily have the effect of alienating and galvanizing the opposition with nonsensical and ineffective laws. From a rational anti-gun perspective, they have done more harm than good.)
- munificent 11y agoYou can look at the legislature like a biological ecosystem subject to evolution. The natural selection force that acts on it is election ("natural election"?). Legislators who do not get elected do not survive in the ecosystem. That means the direct evolutionary pressure is for legislators who focus on re-election above all else. Any actors who have different priorities are quickly outcompeted and kicked out of the gene pool.
- Retra 11y agoYou could look at insulation like it's made of whipped cream, but that doesn't make it a good pie topping. In other words, government officials are not in fact bound by the rules of natural selection whatsoever, and they can live perfectly comfortable, happy lives without getting reelected.
- stcredzero 11y agoWhat's evolving due to natural selection in the gp comment is not Diane Feinstein nor any other member of Homo sapiens. What's evolving are patterns of behavior of legislators and elected officials. Dawkins memes as received wisdom on how to be a Congressperson or Senator. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meme#Origins https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meme#Origins
- etjossem 11y agoI'm convinced Feinstein's office doesn't understand how bad this proposal is for American businesses. It would force business communications vendors to maintain a way to decrypt customers' trade secrets. Those vendors would become incredibly high-value targets overnight. She just passed a bill to legally protect American companies' trade secrets (https://twitter.com/SenFeinstein/status/717387073804767233 https://twitter.com/SenFeinstein/status/717387073804767233), so it's not like she doesn't care about intellectual property. I think if she understood the implications, she wouldn't back this. Give her a call or write a letter, especially if you're in her constituency: http://www.feinstein.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/state-offices http://www.feinstein.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/state-offic...
- stcredzero 11y agoThose vendors would become incredibly high-value targets overnight. Almost literally overnight. I suspect that someone would be trying to break into those vendors' networks in anticipation of the law's implementation.
- kijin 11y agoThe other bill might be related to this one. Lawmakers have a tendency to expect that when they pass a bill to protect something, it will in fact be protected. Since they are at the top of the "security by policy" game, they don't really think about the value of "security by design". So she passes a bill to protect trade secrets just before she proposes another bill that might put trade secrets in jeopardy. "Don't worry, they're still protected by this other bill!"
- stcredzero 11y agoSince they are at the top of the "security by policy" game, they don't really think about the value of "security by design". So she passes a bill to protect trade secrets just before she proposes another bill that might put trade secrets in jeopardy. "Don't worry, they're still protected by this other bill!" Which would just mean open season for governments with state-sponsored hacking for industrial espionage. This includes China and the US.
- cb18 11y agoDunning-Kruger What's even worse, is that she might be aware of what she is doing. >Blum's wife, Senator Dianne Feinstein, has received scrutiny due to her husband's government contracts and extensive business dealings with China and her past votes on trade issues with the country. Blum has denied any wrongdoing, however.[4] Critics have argued that business contracts with the US government awarded to a company (Perini) controlled by Blum may raise a potential conflict-of-interest issue with the voting and policy activities of his wife.[5] URS Corp, which Blum had a substantial stake in, bought EG&G, a leading provider of technical services and management to the U.S. military, from The Carlyle Group in 2002; EG&G subsequently won a $600m defense contract.[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_C._Blum#Controversy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_C._Blum#Controversy Why isn't there a non-voluntary recusement protocol for government employees?
- rayiner 11y agoI'm no fan of Feinstein, but that sort of thing is the most brainless sort of smear attempt. There's no evidence that Feinstein had anything to do with the awarding of that contract.
- stcredzero 11y agoYeah, it's enough to get people to be aware of the cluelessness at face value. I'm not sure I even want to contemplate the level of cynical deviousness implied by the harm being intentional. Or, as is often said, never attribute to malice what can be explained by cluelessness.
- cb18 11y agoIt wasn't really meant as a smear, I can see that interpretation though. I agree it would be quite sad for a woman of such advanced age to sell out her country for a few dollars. Any age of course, but at that age it would be extra curious. As I said, it wasn't a smear. Just a presentation of the facts and asking a question. There are plenty of people in Congress and yet we have the member whose husband has an interest in a government contractor that provides technical services, drafting legislation that involves the mandating of technical services. If members of congress don't have the dignity and integrity to recuse themselves in such situations where there are obviously avenues of inquiry even if everything is above board, but really how could it be, people's biases are subtle... So the question is, if members of congress, and other governmental bodies can't recognize these potential biases in themselves and do the right thing and recuse themselves from conflicting matters, why aren't systems in place to make sure they recuse themselves?
- dcposch 11y agoThis law is toxic to every part of California that works with technology. Can we primary her?
- Bluestrike2 11y agoThis should have happened years ago. Maybe this time Silicon Valley will be pissed off enough to marshal the resources necessary to kick her out of her seat. Her views on encryption are dangerous enough, but when they're held by someone with her seniority and committee power, it's much worse. But she's incredibly popular in California. Beating her is an uphill battle. And most people aren't willing to make encryption a primary issue in how they vote.
- cb18 11y ago>This law is toxic to every part of California that works with technology. The scope is really much broader than that. Does your non-"tech company" company use an online payroll system? That would negatively affected. Do you buy food at a grocery store? Guess what, most of them transmit encrypted data on the internet! etc. etc.
- morgante 11y agoThe worst part of all is that Feinstein supposedly represents California. She's creating a bill which directly and unequivocally attacks business interests in her home state. If tech companies want to be serious about security, they should be putting substantial money into getting this pariah kicked out of office.