7 ms·
Apple's aging Mac Pro is falling behind Windows rivals
- wstrange 11y agoWhat I'd like to see is a new 15" MacBook Pro - with USB C
- tartuffe78 11y agoBut not only 1 USB C.
- patrickmay 11y agoI'd like to see another 17" model. I miss the extra screen space.
- derefr 11y agoAnnoyingly, the MBPs, being "workhorse" machines, depend on 'legacy' connectors to whatever people need to use to get their work done, in a way that the consumer-level notebooks don't. The Macbook can get away with an adapter for USB because people rarely plug things into it. I'm always plugging things into my rMBP, often random things I wasn't aware I would need to plug in, so requiring adapters would be much more annoying.
- jwr 11y agoIt is worth mentioning that many developers were left out in the cold even when the cylindrical Mac Pro was originally announced. I care about CPU speeds and storage, not so much about the GPU, so the form factor and dual-GPU architecture of the new Mac Pro was a set of bad tradeoffs. I never wanted to pay for an extra GPU, and the cost of attached Thunderbolt drive arrays is astronomical. I hope Apple will release a "developer machine": something with tons of CPU power, easily expandable internal storage, and a mid-range single GPU. And for heaven's sake, don't try to make it small, thin, or round. I'd buy it in an instant.
- lallysingh 11y agoWhat does a modern developer do now? Bear with this or an MBP? Cross compile?
- fossuser 11y agoFrom what I've seen it's a mixture of Macbook Pro or running a Linux desktop - probably largely depends on what you're actually making.
- atemerev 11y agoI use a Mac Mini from the times it was still upgradable. Put in 2 SSDs and maxed the RAM — cheap and convenient.
- jeremy7600 11y agoDevelop on a PC?
- walshemj 11y agoBy a dual xenon pc and run windows or Linux
- joeld42 11y agoI am primarily a Mac/iOS developer, but occasionally have to do CPU or GPU intensive stuff. I use a macbook for most of my work but have a windows desktop machine for when I need it. (Ironically, the beefy windows machine was cheaper). For example: lightmap baking. Switching between the two is annoying.
- coldtea 11y ago>Ironically, the beefy windows machine was cheaper That's logical, since Apple focuses on all other aspects of a machine than raw specs first (construction, size, weight, battery life, trackpad, screen, etc).
- ivm 11y agoLate 2012 i7 Mac Mini with 10gb RAM and manually replaced SSD is a very powerful machine. I hope Apple will release a better one this year because 2014 model lacks i7 option.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- emdog4 11y agoApple is waiting for the successor to the aging X99 Intel chipset. Intel has released the 100 series chipset but there are only max 20 PCIe lanes compared to the 40 max PCIe lanes possible with X99. this means the only possible configurations with the 100 series chipsets is x16,x4 or x8,x8,x4. With PCIe being the central bus with the Mac Pro it doesn't make sense for Apple to have released a new Mac Pro yet. The chipset technology in the current Mac Pro is still top of the line. Sure, you can get new processors with more cores and DDR4, but the number of PCIe lanes and memory speed/latency is optimal for the Mac Pro as as of now there is no better option for them to build a successor.
- bryanlarsen 11y agoIntel's newest Xeon processors no longer work with the consumer chipsets such as X99, a Xeon class chipset must be used. If Intel was going to release a new chipset for Xeon, they would have released it with the E5 v4 last week. It's quite possible Apple was waiting for E5 v4 and is still waiting for AMD Polaris or nVidia Pascal, though.
- walshemj 11y agoSome people actually prefer the workstation class mb and there ones designed for use in place of x99
- pier25 11y agoSounds plausible, but why not even release an upgrade to the outdated GPUs or the CPU? The current 15'' rMBP is faster in single core operations...
- extra88 11y agoAs a rule, don't buy a Mac Pro when you're doing single core operations. It's often not worth the money even for multi-core, multi-core plus using the GPUs is when it's the right pick. I'm referring to choosing a Mac, not comparing Macs & PCs.
- Sanddancer 11y ago
- hartator 11y agoThey will probably be updated at the coming WWDC in june alongside the macbook and macbook pro.
- lucaspiller 11y agoThe same is true for notebooks too. Compare the top models of the Dell XPS 15 [0] with the 15" Macbook Pro (Retina) ranges [1]: 6th generation Quad-core i7 vs 5th generation Quad-core i7 32GB DDR4 vs 16GB DDR3 GTX 960M vs R9 M370X 3840x2160 4K display vs 2880x1800 'Retina' display Thunderbolt 3 vs Thunderbolt 2 Both 1TB SSD 1.78kg vs 2.04kg $3049 vs $3199 It's kind of sad that a few years ago Apple was the one leading notebook technology, but now they are just playing catch up and don't even seem to be trying. [0] http://www.dell.com/us/business/p/xps-15-9550-laptop/pd?oc=cax15w10s1631&model_id=xps-15-9550-laptop http://www.dell.com/us/business/p/xps-15-9550-laptop/pd?oc=c... [1] http://www.apple.com/shop/buy-mac/macbook-pro?product=MJLT2LL/A&step=config# http://www.apple.com/shop/buy-mac/macbook-pro?product=MJLT2L...
- dpark 11y agoThat's a pretty different comparison. The current-generation Retina Macbook Pro was released almost exactly a year ago. It's due for a refresh. The XPS 15 you're linking was released in October and likely won't be refreshed again for another 6 months. The Dell might well be the better of the two, but you would expect that since it's a recent release. It's not as if the MacBook Pro Retina has languished for years, though.
- eludwig 11y agoI think it's worth mentioning that Windows really still isn't ready for "retina" prime time. Setting a > 100% scaling results in all kinds of GUI horror all over the place, especially in 3rd party apps. Things are better now than they were 2 years ago, true, but still not a good situation. On the other hand, there is pretty much no problem anywhere on the Mac. Apple just handled it. Pretty much all 3rd party apps were updated within a few months and most just "worked" without modification. A remarkable feat, at least to me. The Mac is still the only way to go if you want a 100% retina desktop experience without glitches. That said, I have no clue if linux is better in this regard. So I guess my point is that the 4K on a Windows laptop is largely wasted. The GPU is not up to driving it for games and the GUI is not up to driving it for daily use. A shame, truly. Disclaimer: I have a 2013 MacPro (with 2 4K Dell monitors) and love it. I use it for Photoshop and software dev.
- spicklove 11y agoApple is really starting to suck in the enterprise, windows desktop OS is coming along but still has flaws, android is the future of computing. this is coming from and industry certified apple tech who has been certified on every major make of PC as well. Most dip shots don't need a real computer for surfing the interwebs. google chrome does fine for most stuff out there. Virtualization and web platforms like vision and AWS give low powered devices infinite hardware and software capabilities. Where does a desktop even fit in this world any more, besides the IT office or possibly the accounting offices. I had an apple rep to tell me to drop Open Directory in favor of Active Directory. I am not sure they even care about enterprise customers any more and just want to sell stupid IOS devices they can brick whenever they want you to buy a new one and release an update to kill it. Who would ever want to try and manage mac OS with Active Directory, that is really dumb. I might as well get Windows OS or google chrome OS and manage it with native tools for the OS.
- derefr 11y agoI mostly agree with you, but I don't see why iOS isn't a potential contender against Android in the future Enterprise market. Have you been watching what Apple has been doing with iOS in education lately (http://www.apple.com/ca/education/it/ http://www.apple.com/ca/education/it/)? Seems very likely that's a targeted "first user-story" for technology that's very generally applicable in the enterprise.
- darreld 11y agoI almost see what you see. In our large enterprise Android is not really even a player. Macs do kind of suck especially for some of our multifactor security requirements(CAC/PIV cards). Windows rules the desktop and iOS is the preferred mobile platform.
- spicklove 11y agoApple is really starting to suck in the enterprise, windows desktop OS is coming along but still has flaws, android is the future of computing. this is coming from and industry certified apple tech who has been certified on every major make of PC as well. Most dip shots don't need a real computer for surfing the interwebs. google chrome does fine for most stuff out there. Virtualization and web platforms like vision and AWS give low powered devices infinite hardware and software capabilities. Where does a desktop even fit in this world any more, besides the IT office or possibly the accounting offices. I had an apple rep to tell me to drop Open Directory in favor of Active Directory. I am not sure they even care about enterprise customers any more and just want to sell stupid IOS devices they can brick whenever they want you to buy a new one and release an update to kill it. Who would ever want to try and manage mac OS with Active Directory, that is really dumb. I might as well get Windows OS or google chrome OS and manage it with native tools for the OS.
- touchofevil 11y agoApple has been steadily been abandoning the "creative pro" market for a long time. The two most recent indicators were dropping Final Cut Pro 7 for Final Cut Pro X, which was not ready for professional editing at release. The new Mac Pro confirmed the move away from the pro market, since it only supported one CPU. For compressing feature films, dual CPUs are a must.
- derefr 11y ago> which was not ready for professional editing at release Some would argue that that sounds more like a project management failure than a change in market strategy—that they shipped a beta product as done, that someone screwed up somewhere, etc. I don't think so, though; I think Apple just made a correct call in shipping the "core" of the product early (in the same way most enterprise products get 'Early Access' releases) to allow actual professionals to start evaluating the architecture of the software and tailoring their pipelines to fit it. Professional-use software doesn't get used on day 1 of release; it gets played with by an internal pipeline infrastructure team for six months while the working craftspeople continue to use the stable pipeline. Handing out something that would be "patched into usefulness" at right about the same time it would actually be put into use makes sense, in strictly consequentialist terms, for both Apple and the professional studios—although Apple latching onto that release to do a bunch of marketing of their product as if it was usable for indies already, could be seen as a bit scummy. > since it only supported one CPU. For compressing feature films, dual CPUs are a must. This might not be the case right now (I don't know much about video encoding), but encoded video has keyframes, and effectively you can "chunk out" a set of raw frames to become a keyframe plus its successor interstitial frames, and then parallelize on those chunks, right? In which case, I'd expect Apple figured that even if CPU-based compression is currently en vogue for this use-case, it'd be obviated by GPU-based highly-parallel compression soon enough, making the dual GPUs a much more significant benefit and the single CPU a much less significant drawback. Tell me if I'm getting that wrong; I honestly have no idea.
- touchofevil 11y agoFinal Cut X was really a huge disappointment to the professional editing community when it was released. It was missing features that made it unusable for professionals. For example, when it was released, it was not possible to export sound as an OMF or AFF (which is the format required for sending sound to a professional sound mixer). I saw it as an indication that Apple no longer needed to cater to the pro market (see also apple dropping Shake and the XServe and the Xserve RAID) now that Apple had the iphone, ipad, itunes, etc. As for compressing films, maybe GPUs will pick up the slack. But there are still other applications like Maya and After Effects that depend almost entirely on the CPU for rendering, so having dual CPUs makes a big difference. I don't really mind Apple leaving the pro market. Adobe Premiere has taken Final Cut Pro's place for most people I know. I just use Windows machines now for my video and graphics work.
- Animats 11y agoBut the Mac Pro is round. That's the important thing. Other lame computers are square. The cool Apple computer is round. That's what's important. Half the people who buy that thing probably never use more than the browser and some music/video play apps.
- qihqi 11y agoBasically saying that Apple's release cycle is slower for desktop and laptops than the PC counterparts. Nothing really new here. Because there are several PC makers. Even if all of them releases new hardware in the same rate as Apple (say 2 year generation), having 3 of them can easily interscale release dates and make it look like PCs are releasing new stuff much faster.
- derefr 11y agoI think, also, that Apple is serving an entirely different market with the Mac Pro than the PC makers are (mostly) serving on the high end. PC makers can get a continuous incremental revenue stream from gamers and independent professionals. But most Mac Pros are likely sold to companies (even if just tiny one-man companies) that refresh them on a set schedule rather than whenever a shiny new thing comes out.
- eldavido 11y agoApple earned only 6-7billion last quarter selling Macs, in a quarter with 50-60 billion in overall sales. [1] I think there's a real possibility Apple will stop selling computers. They already don't care about the "high-end creative" market. OTOH I don't know what people would use to develop for iOS/Watch, but...you heard it here first. [1] http://www.statista.com/statistics/263428/apples-revenue-from-macintosh-computers-since-first-quarter-2006/ http://www.statista.com/statistics/263428/apples-revenue-fro...
- frandroid 11y agoThey're not going to relinquish the only platform to develop iDevice apps on, not to mention the mindshare they get from being a super important dev platform for all kinds of creative leaders. It's just not a financial question, there are tons of downstream implications.
- eric_h 11y agoI suspect that Apple will always continue making the "trucks" of the computing world (to borrow Steve Jobs' analogy). To continue the analogy, compare their revenue numbers with, say Daimler[0]. Daimler sells more Mercedes cars than their other vehicles, but they still get revenue from trucks and buses and other pro/commercial vehicles.
- pier25 11y agoI find it hard to believe. iOS is not ready for prime time and Apple refuses to create a Surface like device and merging iOS with OSX.
- danhon 11y agoThere's an argument to be made for Apple selling a go-to workstation for making VR content. They might not care about consumer VR (for now), but in terms of their history, it feels a bit weird for them not to support the nascent VR content field.
- joeld42 11y agoWhat history? Apple was never very big in the 3D content creation biz. Their 3D support has always lagged a few years behind windows.
- fblp 11y agoThe Mac Pro has not been updated in 841 days (av 449) The Retina Macbook Pro has not been updated in 325 days (average 214). Although chipset cycles could be part of the delay, I wonder if virtual reality hardware and software support could also be part of the plan too. further reading: http://buyersguide.macrumors.com/ http://buyersguide.macrumors.com/ http://www.macrumors.com/roundup/apple-vr-project/ http://www.macrumors.com/roundup/apple-vr-project/
- edanuff 11y agoI've got one of these and love it and I know a few other developers who do too. The main negatives I've seen are from people who want to stick PC GPU cards in for gaming. As a developer desktop computer it's a joy to use, virtually silent and can power multiple 4K displays. It's a shame Apple hasn't done an update though.
- satysin 11y agoConsidering all the fuss Apple made about the new design of the Mac Pro it is strange they have not kept it top of the line. I guess they care more about the 5K iMac and MacBook being super thin and pretty.
- pier25 11y agoIt's really strange. A lot of effort was put into that Mac Pro and it's components. Maybe sales were not as high as Apple expected?
- jmnicolas 11y agoBla bla bla ... it should be understood by now that Apple don't care about these niche markets and will do whatever they want. The only people using Apple workstations are because they either really want to use a MAC or because the software they use is not available on PC. In both cases they won't buy a cheaper and faster PC. I'm a disgruntled Apple NON-customer : they never created the desktop I wanted (basically an affordable version of the old MAC pro line) or a phone I could afford without having to sell a kidney on the black market. So I use Windows and Android with the satisfaction of knowing that I use both of the bests keyloggers disguised as an OS on the market.
- outworlder 11y agoWhat about the Thunderbolt display? It is much older and still being offered. At the same launch price.