4 ms·
I'm pretty sure this is the advertised purpose of it. It stops bots AND helps machine learning.
by kevincox 11y ago
I'm pretty sure this is the advertised purpose of it. It stops bots AND helps machine learning.
- kuschku 11y ago*AND helps a company make profit by training their proprietary models. If they were open, it would be a lot better (considering all the training is done by volunteers, too)
- ant6n 11y agoI like to misidentify things to give them bad data.
- kuschku 11y agoWell, I do the same. I won’t destroy any of their dataset, or even have a measurable impact – but in turn, I won’t have a measurable impact in positive direction either. If they want to make a profit from me, they should pay me, or they can license correct CAPTCHA results from me under GPL.
- mehta 11y agoThis argument doesn't really make sense to me. What browser, OS and device are you using to post this comment? Someone made profit when you bought the device, bought the OS and/or browser. A healthy system needs some kind of motivation. In economies, that is profits/money. What's wrong with that? (I know I am being simplistic here but...)
- deelowe 11y agoNapster, torrents, and the free internet warped an entire generation's perspective on things. This sort of "everything should be free" attitude isn't going away any time soon.
- ant6n 11y agoThe devices that I buy generally don't ask me to do work for them. If they do, for example by spying on my behavior, then I'm not so happy. On the other hand, I may accept some spying/doing work for companies if I get something in return - which happens for some Google products, like search. When doing a captcha, I don't really get anything. It's something I have to do because the website I'm using has the problem that they can't find a better way to identify bots. So I do a captcha, fine. But, if there's benefits for whatever company offers them, i.e. I'm doing work for them without getting anything in return, or without everybody getting anything in return (the GPL option), then I'm again not so happy.
- kuschku 11y ago> A healthy system needs some kind of motivation. In economies, that is profits/money. What's wrong with that? (I know I am being simplistic here but...) Simple. I buy a thing, I get something – in that moment the contract is over. VW doesn’t come to me every 3 days with "You bought a car, to continue using it, take this and drive to Hanover and deliver it there". When I bought my computer, or its parts, I bought them, I put them together, and that’s it. The manufacturer has never asked me to do work for them, or pay for them again. I use ARCH Linux and Firefox – projects done by volunteers, and they profit by having a better product for themselves and others. Google profits from ads, and from selling data. That’s a tradeoff, and a reason for me to try to use as few Google products as possible. But when government organizations use ReCaptcha, and I have to work without pay for Google, then I have no choice, and it is not something I agree with.
- deelowe 11y agouhh. Everything they do is arguably for profit. That's why Google is an LLC. What do you expect them to do, put an "* this is done to earn us money" disclaimer on everything?
- bitskits 11y agoThis is a little pedantic and doesn't change your point, but Google is not an LLC. It's a C Corporation.
- chippy 11y agoThe advertised purpose was to digitize the worlds books and help libraries, digital humanities and the world. This ended, and all trace of public good was erased (Check archive.org if you dont believe me) when Google execs mandated that only things that made money can be supported.
- Snowflame 11y agoYou do realize that it was the US court system that put the library-of-the-world version of Google Books on ice, correct? Larry & Sergey wanted a hippy "share all the books to everyone" view of this. The court said no, do what the book publishers say.
- greglindahl 11y agoWhile you're mentioning the Internet Archive, you might also recall that our advertised purpose is to digitize all the world's knowledge :-) I just had a chat with our book guy today about OCR corrections using captchas, one of our volunteers suggested it. We expect to scan 500,000-700,000 books this year.