5 ms·
Facebook adds video search to combat original content sharing decline
- magicalist 11y agoHopefully this will make it easier for people to find their videos that have been reuploaded and take them down. Really annoying to constantly see videos in my feed that are just blurry, partially cropped copies (what is this, VHS?) of videos from a great youtube channel with no attribution and no context. When this whole controversy came up last summer and fall, it was said there would be easy ways for viewers to flag videos (since the original creators have no way of finding arbitrary uploads of their videos), but I can find no way of doing that. Maybe this will help on the other side, at least.
- minimaxir 11y agoThat's impractical. No one can check for video theft 24/7, and by the time a video would be taken down by Facebook staff anyways, the damage would be done. If Facebook offered an API for Video Search, that would be different, but Facebook's depreciation of APIs that can pull data from arbitrary profiles makes that hard. (you could scrape the Pages of likely suspects though.)
- minikites 11y agoYouTube's ContentID seems to work? Or am I misunderstanding the issue?
- JBReefer 11y agoRadically different methods of enumeration
- minimaxir 11y agoOn YouTube, ContentID can only be used by the big publishers, not the little guy whose videos are getting stolen. Facebook is 10x worse as you might expect.
- sp332 11y agoAnyone can register content with the ContentID database and choose to remove or put ads on any matching videos. Big players have access to delete any video they want from YouTube.
- snsr 11y agoI guess it depends on perspective - ContentID is far too aggressive, and all dispute claims are judged by the accuser.
- ProAm 11y ago> Hopefully this will make it easier for people to find their videos that have been reuploaded and take them down Can't facebook do this for you? I don't want to have to police facebook 24/7 when I'm their product. They can lend a hand here.
- prostoalex 11y agoThey're most likely protected by DMCA safe harbor provision, so while they probably can, they don't really have to.
- ProAm 11y agoDon't have to sure, but if they are concerned with the drop off of original user created content they obviously care about it.
- earlz 11y agoThe really crappy part to me is when I see an obvious rip of a content creator I know, I go in and look for how to make a pirated content report. Facebook makes this _IMPOSSIBLE_ unless you are the rights holder
- joelrunyon 11y agoHow has facebook not implemented their own version of Youtube's content ID yet? YouTube did that how many years ago & it seems like Facebook would have at least the engineering capability to do that now. I think you'd see a huge movement for them to do something like that if big movie companies were having their stuff ripped & uploaded, but since it mostly effects small players - it seems no one at FB really cares all that much :(
- bigdubs 11y agoThe cynical answer is that bookface is turning a blind eye to content theft because they need the eyeballs on videos, regardless of their provenance. It (theoretically) helps metrics and allows them to woo advertising money. There is no proof of this, I'm sure a ContentID like system is prioritized or even is implemented. Ultimately if you're a legitimate content producer, having a system like this in place would only encourage you to use the platform and it would have a net benefit to usage overall.
- TheLogothete 11y agoI think it has more to do with forcing content creators to come, than with beefing netrics up.
- tristanj 11y agoFacebook is not legally required to build a Content ID-like system.
- ethanbond 11y agoNow that's a motto I can get behind: "Do no thing that's not absolutely strictly required by legal code."
- coroutines 11y agoMaybe I don't use Facebook enough but I find it really inconvenient to watch any videos I'm not directly linked to. If they show up among my friends' postings they're always pre-muted, so I miss the first couple seconds as they autoplay and have to run it back after unmuting. Even if I wanted to watch videos, they're interspersed among all this social crap - I'm not in the mood when I'm really only looking to get an idea of what others are doing. Wish it were easy to filter content if you don't want to see everything. Anyway, I hate Facebook as much as the next guy - but this seems like an obvious feature one would add, regardless of content sharing 'decline'.
- simula67 11y ago> While people are sharing plenty of news, they’re posting less photos and status updates about their own lives. Facebook seems to have become this battleground for status. People post to Facebook when they : a) are travelling to some exotic or foreign locations b) got admissions to prestigious schools or got amazing jobs c) had a pretty picture of themselves taken d) are outraged by some social injustice etc When I meet past friends who are going through a slump in their life I am reminded how little I know what is happening to them. They would have stopped posting to Facebook a long time ago. The site offers less human connection these days.
- johnchristopher 11y ago> a) are travelling to some exotic or foreign locations > b) got admissions to prestigious schools or got amazing jobs > c) had a pretty picture of themselves taken What do you mean by `photos and status updates about their own lives` if these points don't match that description ?
- derefr 11y agoThose points are certainly a subset of "photos and status updates", but they're a very unrepresentative one, and one I personally prefer to avoid consuming. Ideally, what I want to get from people on Facebook is the kind of 'candid' talk I would get if I were to take them out for drinks—because the people I add to Facebook are exactly the people who I don't live close enough to to take out for drinks. Originally, this was what Facebook was actually used for—asynchronous catching-up. In this it was contrasted against e.g. Twitter, which was much more about broadcasting your "personal brand." These days, I feel like the place to get what you used to get from Facebook is Tumblr (at least for teenagers.) The same sort of "I'm going to sit here and whine into a pipe; you can listen if you like; we can have a back-and-forth running thread if we are all mutual friends" vibe of Facebook ca 2009.
- randycupertino 11y agoFrom my view, here's how I'd break all the social networks out there down, though I'm sure I'm missing some: Linkedin: online resume twitter: for people to broadcast clever witticisms, suck up to their professional contacts, complain to brands. Very front line of "personal brand." Seems like people have two twitters pretty often- one for random chat about whatever and one "professional" one to push their career agendas. facebook: bragbook for social striving/status updates of vacations, jobs, new cars, cute kids, flattering photos. Also to cheer on and suck up to friends and family/like their content. Getting more and more annoying lately with political posts. Being able to block people from your newsfeed has helped with this immensely. instagram: more personal photos than facebook, less likely to be "friends" with your boss etc, also less likely to be attached to your real name, so easier to showcase your real personality/quirks. More artsy than facebook. snapchat: original video content, people are more "real" than on facebook because there is less perceived risk of people they know irl or professionally finding them and seeing all their doofy posts. Here I am riding my bike, here I am at the beach making a silly face, etc. People feel more free and less worried about it hurting their careers. More fun than facebook with the facial editing tools and stickers which seem really neat. periscope: dunno, never used it but heard it's the hip new thing about.me : I still don't understand this one. Guess it's supposed to be the landing page for all your other social medias? medium.com: starting to pick up lately, not just a place to write Open Letters to Whoever anymore! Extension of personal brand for writers. Path: dead Google plus: annoying, stupid Reddit: enjoy the anonymity, so refreshing after being forced to use the "real you" constantly on facebook etc. Surprisingly intelligent discussion and relevant content in the subs. Was actually recruited for a fantastic job off of my reddit comment history of all things! hackernews: kinda new, still learning the ropes around here but I've been loving the intelligent discussions and learning a lot. quora: Place to show off your smarts and push your personal brand. I am actually really annoyed about this because I used to answer and ask a lot of great questions on quora about embarrassing stuff (LOTR, Star trek, whatever) and then all my coworkers and professional contacts started following on me and now I feel very constrained on there. any other thoughts?