3 ms·
The first one gives me a bit of pause. It seems awfully close to saying that you should design around SEO--- designing for users sorta, but always with an eye t
by _delirium 17y ago
The first one gives me a bit of pause. It seems awfully close to saying that you should design around SEO--- designing for users sorta, but always with an eye to how you can "leverage" your users for SEO purposes. Doesn't that come close to suggesting you might make decisions that, if they were made without taking SEO into consideration, would be a clear loss for user experience, and are really not what your users want?
- whatusername 17y agoAre you building something like Yelp, Mahalo and Stack Overflow or something like Gmail and Basecamp. If you have a site full of content - then you should be designing around SEO. Spolsky's thought that the front page of SO is Google.com is very true. Discoverable content is useful content. If you have a Private web-app (think gmail) then Search Results aren't all that important.
- dualogy 17y agoHowever, there might be classes of web apps where Search Results can help attract new users, albeit maybe not at scale.
- _delirium 17y agoWell, much of this week's HN discussion, to my satisfaction at least, held up Mahalo as an example of what you don't want to do. ;-) To my mind, building a returning base of satisfied users ought to be the main goal: what is missing on the internet, and how can I provide it? That is, what's missing for actual users? The other approach seems to teeter on the edge of the gray-hat SEO abyss.
- axod 17y agoI agree completely. Sites like Mahalo and Scribd are just wrapping up content and duping people into clicking through SEO to their site, and then clicking on adSense adverts to get what they really wanted in the first place. There's a reverse incentive at work there - they have no incentive to provide a better user experience, since then, users would get what they want, and wouldn't need to click on the ads. Google could, and definitely should IMHO detect that user behaviour, and penalize sites for it. For example: * If a user clicks on a natural search listing * If that same user quickly clicks on an adSense advert at the site * We can assume that the landing page was bad quality * Now penalize them either by not paying the adsense, or reduce their ranking for that page. If you have a valuable site, Google should only be there to provide you new users, not all your users. I think the quote about Google being the frontpage to stackoverflow is pretty ridiculous personally.
- qeorge 17y ago"I think the quote about Google being the frontpage to stackoverflow is pretty ridiculous personally." Why? Because its true? There's a lot of content sites I use all the time but never visit directly. Yahoo Answers comes to mind.
- axod 17y agoI just don't think it's a useful state of affairs once a site has tens, even hundreds of millions of pages indexed by google. Why wouldn't you go to Yahoo answers and do a search there? I'm just not too into the business model of "We know about everything", lets get listed for every single search on google. For stackoverflow, personally I don't usually find the content useful, so it's just irritating to have to specify I don't want stackoverflow results. It'd be good if Google could better judge quality of pages, as in "Is this just user generated / scraped content, or is it verified reliable fact".
- ericd 17y agoYou don't go to Yahoo answers directly because you can either search one, or search them all at once. Do you still go to the bakery, then the butcher, then the vegetable stand, or do you go to a supermarket? As for judging quality and verifying as a reliable fact, I agree, that would be excellent. This is something I was thinking about as part of a potential startup. Unfortunately, it's wicked hard to do without resorting to (probably paid) human experts.
- axod 17y ago>> "Do you still go to the bakery, then the butcher, then the vegetable stand, or do you go to a supermarket?" I often still go to the bakery, then the butcher, then the farm shop actually. The quality is far better than anything you get in a supermarket.
- ericd 17y agoHeh actually I wish I had all of those things located nearby, I've never been disappointed when I've spent the time to go to all of those.
- jasonkester 17y agoI think you really have to build SEO into any business, regardless of what type. And it doesn't have to compromise anything about the user experience. As an example, my current project is an online tutoring site. There are literally thousands of online tutoring sites out there, and dozens of ones that are good enough to rank well on Google. So even though the thing I'm building is head and shoulders above what's out there today, nobody will ever know about it if it's not ranking well for something like "online spanish tutoring" or "learn spanish online". With that in mind, it's fundamentally important to the success of my business that SEO is baked in from the start. The tutor profile URLs need to be simple vanity ones that people are proud to give out via Twitter, on a blog entry, their school's homepage, or even scribbled onto the back of a business card. The browse results in the marketplace need to have good titles and meta descriptions so that people will actually want to click them if they show up in a Google search. We need to offer a way for existing Spanish Schools to embed a co-branded version of our site into theirs if they want. There are dozens of architectural and business decisions that stem directly from SEO. It's not something that you can tack on at the end and hope for the best. And if you look carefully at the above, you might notice that each of those things above actually improve the user experience in some way.