4 ms·
This doesn't really go into hotlinking, does it? What's the legality of hotlinking? = embedding an image in your page by using an URL directly to an image that
by kzrdude 11y ago
This doesn't really go into hotlinking, does it?
What's the legality of hotlinking? = embedding an image in your page by using an URL directly to an image that is hosted & controlled by someone else.
- extra88 11y agoNo, not hotlinking. I don't think hotlinking inherently could break a law, I think that would require some understanding that the host provides the content for one particular use and any other use would be a violation. There probably are sites with license agreements/terms of service that state as much in which case hotlinking would be breaking the contract. If ad blocking were illegal, it would be for the same reason. Hotlinking could be involved in criminal or civil actions, e.g. used to perpetrate fraud or used maliciously (intended to use up host's resources or even DDOS).
- pcr0 11y agoI'm no lawyer, but from an end user's perspective if you hotlinked an unauthorized image instead of linking to a page containing the image, then you aren't just "pointing" to the image anymore, you're practically displaying the image on your website.
- michaelmrose 11y agoThe content you have merely contains a link to the provided resource. The user can fetch your page without violating the law, the user can also legally fetch the image from the owner. So neither you nor your user have committed a crime. You could try to argue that the user requires a license to combine the 2 in ways not considered by you however this has several problems. - Its laughably unenforceable - In the us it would probably be fair use - It would make literally the entire internet illegal - It would make adblocking on your end illegal - It would make you a world wide source of negativity and scorn. Basically there is a technical solution to most hotlinking issues and every imaginable legal solution would be a cure worse than the disease.
- icebraining 11y agoThe Ninth Circuit says hotlinking is not infringing: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perfect_10,_Inc._v._Amazon.com,_Inc https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perfect_10,_Inc._v._Amazon.com....
- kzrdude 11y agoThank you for a very relevant link, yet (as legal things go) this case has its special setting. They were using thumbnails, and they were not pretending or that the image belonged to them or their own content. If I write a news article, and I hotlink in an illustration with no credit or comment, that still seems problematic.
- icebraining 11y agoI'm not sure the distintion is relevant. In the decision[1] which affirmed the lower court's, the judges applied the "server test"; essentially, they've said it's never copyright infringement if you don't actually distribute it yourself, but merely tell the browser where it can get the image. This excerpt is particularly relevant: Perfect 10 argues that Google displays a copy of the full- size images by framing the full-size images, which gives the impression that Google is showing the image within a single Google webpage. While in-line linking and framing may cause some computer users to believe they are viewing a sin- gle Google webpage, the Copyright Act, unlike the Trade- mark Act, does not protect a copyright holder against acts that cause consumer confusion. http://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2007/12/03/0655405.pdf http://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2007/12/03/06...
- ComodoHacker 11y agoSo a URL of JPEG file put in 'img' tag is infringing and the same URL put in 'a' tag is not? Sounds rather silly to me.