3 ms·
The minimalism in the examples is a brand statement and a form of social signalling. It's UX - in the marketing sense - rather than UI. And yes, a lot of web m
by TheOtherHobbes 11y ago
The minimalism in the examples is a brand statement and a form of social signalling.
It's UX - in the marketing sense - rather than UI. And yes, a lot of web marketing assumes the buyer is exactly the kind of person you're suggesting - maybe because often they are.
Craigslist, Plenty of Fish, and all the other "Can't be bothered to add styling" sites are taking the opposite approach.
The lack of overt social signalling becomes an inclusive social signal of its own. By making the design as functional as possible and not aiming for any demographic, they're more likely to create something that's acceptably styled and useful for all of them.
Trained designers don't seem to understand this, because although they pay lip service to the idea of usability, they're mostly only interested in designs that include aesthetic signalling.
In fact there's a whole tradition of professional 'get shit done" design in hardware and software which gives users all the options they need at the same time with minimal fuss. This kind of flat design can be very productive, but it rarely looks pretty.
Tangentially, I think FB has the worst of all worlds. The aesthetic choices are poor. The ergonomics are poor. Critical settings are hidden. Content appears more or less randomly. You have limited control over what you get.
FB is only popular because of network effects. If the design was less dictatorial, it would be more popular still.
- stcredzero 11y agoTrained designers don't seem to understand this, because although they pay lip service to the idea of usability, they're mostly only interested in designs that include aesthetic signalling. This is a very common human pattern: Confusing signalling+lip-service around a complicated and subtle issue with genuine understanding. I suspect it's a common pattern because it's a part of the learning process.