3 ms·
So I don't understand why this guy specifically is targeted. He posted some scripts to disable the webcam for normal users, he talked about using the software t
by cookiecaper 17y ago
So I don't understand why this guy specifically is targeted. He posted some scripts to disable the webcam for normal users, he talked about using the software to do what it was intended to do. I'm not convinced that because he didn't mention "theft recovery" until the middle of the podcast (granted, I did not listen to the podcast), he must have been remotely controlling users' computers. I don't see any evidence that incriminates Mr. Pibrix as anything more than IT guy taking orders, and I think it's irresponsible to post information like this without due process or at least offering Pibrix a chance to respond.
- hga 17y ago"I was just following orders" to set up a system that would inevitably create child porn does not sound like a sufficient defense to me. The software in question would phone home whenever the laptop was connected from other than the school's LAN and start making pictures; at that point, the only thing the system could do would be to allow retention of them or not.
- rdtsc 17y agoHis rational superiors should obviously start scapegoating him by now to divert attention and blame. Their strategy at this point should be to paint this guy as a deranged, power hungry nerd who took matters into his own hands. They should fire him immediately. (I am not saying whether it is his fault or someone above him ordered it, but I am assuming his superiors are soulless bastards who can hire expensive attorneys. He might be just as bad, but he cannot hire lawyers and PR firms).
- olefoo 17y agoI was just talking about this with a friend of mine. He seems like the ideal candidate to be thrown to the wolves. I think the vice principal, and any other staff with knowledge of the spying capabilities should not be allowed to shove the blame onto the tech staff. Everyone involved should be punished to the full extent of the law.
- cookiecaper 17y agoWell, I think there may have been a plausible justification. Not that they could up with one that actually makes this acceptable, but they might be able to come up with one that, while still undesirable, isn't quite as blatant as "this system will inevitably create child porn". IT people are often put in situations where they have to implement the will of the less-technically-enlightened who sign their paychecks, even when it violates the privacy standards that the IT staff would prefer. For instance, invasive filtering at work that logs all of one's activity by default and attempts to prevent external HTTPS or proxy usage is against the ideals of most who have to implement and maintain such a system, but thousands have to do it every day. There are many, many alternatives to the malicious "inevitable child porn" point-of-view. Maybe Pibrix thought that "stolen mode" wasn't activated until someone reported it, because someone higher-up than him had set all of the computers to report back anytime they are outside of the school's network. He's just one high school network tech, he's not necessarily the end-all here. We don't know how the rules for "stolen mode" were determined; perhaps they could be updated when students connected to the school's network. Therefore, when normal students complained of spontaneous light-blinking at home, when their laptops weren't even reported stolen, Pibrix could have sincerely believed it was a glitch. We just don't know, so let's not target potentially-innocent people here, ok? We should at least let this thing flesh out a bit more before we start with the marking of public enemies, right? This should scare anyone whose employer may potentially incriminate their employees in the employer's shady dealings. I mean, I don't know, maybe he was guilty, maybe he did push for this system so he could watch the kids in compromising or private positions and get his kicks off of that, maybe he was saving all of the incidental nudes and posting them to 4chan. We don't know, and I'm not saying that the guy did or didn't. I just think it's a little early to incriminate this one guy just because he talked about how the software they use works and how to make it so non-privileged users can't use the webcam.
- hga 17y agoI think we're pretty sure he's the top dog for this IT, he certainly talked at length about this feature and how great it was (http://yro.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=1559200&cid=31234034 http://yro.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=1559200&cid=3123...). The only question here is that did he realize the laptops have to always be in phone home mode for this to work? The anti-theft feature obviously doesn't work if the laptop doesn't make contact a server after the former is stolen. Plus there's the blink of the green spycam light; school IT knew about it, we won't know until discovery or its criminal equivalent if they realized that it was due the actions of their spyware. But I insist on saying "this system will inevitably create child porn" and that his not realizing that is no excuse. The child porn laws do not care about mens rea (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mens_rea http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mens_rea).