7 ms·
So 2016 is _finally_ the year of Linux on the Desktop?
by bigiain 11y ago
So 2016 is _finally_ the year of Linux on the Desktop?
- chx 11y agoNo, Linux on the Desktop has just died. I expect both the KDE and Gnome projects dead within a (very few) years, probably X.org close behind. All hail Winux though. (That's the name for this mix I came up with.) Before you downvote this without thinking ... consider, for example, KDE is severely understaffed and this will deplete them further. Who will bother with X.org bugs and drivers now? What's the point? Who is your target audience? You need to drink a real big dose of Stallman kool-aid to continue with Linux if this thing on Windows works as promised. I have been using Linux solely on my laptop since 2004. I am sick of the constant driver problems. Yes, yes, you can connect to your home router or the router in the cafe. Now go and try and connect to an enterprise network. Perhaps with VPN.
- cyphar 11y agoI do all of the things you mention without problem. I don't definitely don't think GNU/Linux will die as a result. First off, syscall emulation will always be clunky. Secondly, many people care about their freedom. Thirdly, what makes you think that a majority of people using GNU/Linux will switch. I haven't had driver or network problems for the past 3 years on any of my various machines.
- andresmanz 11y agoSame here. I use Windows maybe once or twice a year, and it's always a pain. "Winux" won't change that for me and to be honest, I don't really want to support Microsoft. Sure, I think VS is a pretty nice piece of software, but that's about it - too few reasons to switch.
- chx 11y agoCongrats! What about this guy https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11445505 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11445505 and what I typed up https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11413469 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11413469 here.
- cyphar 11y agoNo need to be flippant. Yes, I read those comments and I don't share those experiences. I've used my fair share of odd hardware and I've never had problems that couldn't be resolved without half an hour if Googling.
- emilsedgh 11y agoKDE has always been understaffed and will always be understaffed. But it has been improving all the time with every single release. The problem is that you (and millions of people who were looking for Linux desktop to "win") are just not excited anymore since new form factors (phones, tablets) arrived. But I actually think Linux desktop is a winner. There are several high quality desktop enviroments suitable for all kinds of use cases. Yeah we are not dominating the world. That was a short naive dream in the early 2000. But we have awesome desktops and thats what matters. Disclaimer: minor KDE contributor but these were my thoughts not KDE's. Btw, give KDE a try its so good these days :)
- chx 11y agoI am typing this from KDE. Obviously? I guess. And so what. That is not the problem.
- cies 11y ago> Linux on the Desktop has just died. It becomes even more approachable by "Winux". Let people learn the basic of the CLI and get comfy with more open source tools -- then reinstall your computer to a Linux distro (and put your Win-only apps in a VM or on Wine) is a small move.
- gizmo385 11y agoI highly doubt that "Winux" will really result in a large increase of people learning CLI tools. People that want to use those tools already have way that they're doing so. Consider that most people have difficulty using a basic word processor, much less Unix tools.
- cies 11y agoI'm considering the masses. But many in higher-education are on Windows (my experience here in the Netherlands). I can imagine that, for instance, they will use Winux at some point. Same for some IT professionals that use Windows (either since their job demands it, or out of preference). They might install Winux at some point to get some aspect of their work done faster. Again a lower barrier to get your CLI skills up and get comfy with common open source tools. I believe there is a lot of value in "CLI skills and common open source tools" that Windows users are currently missing out on.
- TheLogothete 11y agoAnd why would they switch to full linux when they can get their cli tools AND Windows productivity?
- cies 11y agoSecurity, parity with the server platform, rough edges of Winux, "cool", wanting to learn something... Just to name a few.
- fsloth 11y agoAs I understand it, vendors will probably have paying clients for Linux desktops for some time to come. It is very hard to imagine a situation where the demand for a Linux desktop become so low that no-one will maintain the required software infrastructure.
- godzillabrennus 11y agoKeep in mind Windows 10 let's the folks at Redmond remotely remove software from you machine. Before you go declaring Linux dead you might want to think about how that could impact you. Not to mention that Microsoft has been known to Embrace, Extend, Extinguish.
- sz4kerto 11y agoThis is true for every single popular OS though -- Windows, iOS, Android. Not that it's good, just that's the reality.
- godzillabrennus 11y agoYep. But not true on Linux, yet.
- zxcvcxz 11y ago>Winux I've deemed it "Frankenstein OS" because they've sewn a whole bunch of parts together to make an unwieldy monster that doesn't quite work as good as the individual pieces did on their own.
- kenny_r 11y agoThis brings many of the parts that make up Ubuntu to Windows, but the Linux kernel isn't one of them. That being said, I'm typing this comment my workstation running Linux and I for one am getting very tired of this year of the Linux desktop joke. What OS you run is an individual choice, stop trying to declare a single winner.
- piyush_soni 11y ago>> I for one am getting very tired of this year of the Linux desktop joke You != masses. There might not be a clear single winner, but there is a clear single loser. Statistically speaking.
- phaer 11y agoOnly if you understand desktop market share of an operating system as a battle. Myself and a lot of other people are using GNU/Linux and other libre operating systems with great pleasure and, finally, growing hardware support. I could not care less if 90% of desktops are Windows systems or if an additional 9% are OS X machines or whatever. tl;dr: Just use what works for you. If it supports your ethical values, itäs even better!
- piyush_soni 11y agoSure, if all users believe in "use what works for you", they shouldn't get pissed off when others make jokes on that. *nix users are not going to like it, but in real world comparisons are bound to happen for things of same categories and you can't prevent that. Better to move on, and that was the reason I wrote my comment.
- andkenneth 11y agoLinux users were going around for a while saying "this is the year of linux on the desktop", and yeah it kind of turned into a bit of a meme. Realistically linux did hit it big, but on a phone OS. It's now one of the most installed kernels in the world, but its brand is hidden. Linux is also incredibly important in the server space, and everyone knows this. Linux will never have its year on the desktop in my opinion, but it will still be all over the place in the server/phone space. It just won out in other areas than the desktop.
- ccozan 11y agoLet's say it is like getting a seat at the big Microsoft Desktop table.
- captainmuon 11y agoA bit offtopic, but 2009 was the year of the Linux Desktop for me (using Ubuntu). Performant on older hardware, eye candy (compiz) on newer hardware, the Gnome 2 interface was familiar and incredibly polished, and you had a lot of choice (linuxshouldbeaboutchoice.com). They lost me with all the rewriteritis and monodaemonisation that followed. I switched to MacOS (hackintosh) and was very happy for a while, since it could run all the Unix stuff, most of the productivity stuff (MS Office), and many games. It was for a long time the most plain, conservative OS (while Windows was going crazy with 8). But recently, I've found Windows to be the OS that "just works" and gets out of my way - which was pretty surprising to me. If anybody killed alternative desktops, it is not MS, but the desktops themselves.
- zxcvcxz 11y ago>I've found Windows to be the OS that "just works" and gets out of my way I've had the opposite experience. Windows does not "just work" and it certainly does not "stay out of the way". I have USB headphones I can't use in Windows because they connect but Windows doesn't let me switch to them. When I plug in an external monitor my OS comes to a crawl and it doesn't speed back up until I restart the whole thing. When I unplug a monitor it loses my windows. And did you hear the story about the guy who lost his job because Windows decided to update the .NET framework right before he was scheduled to do a presentation at a business meeting? Doesn't sound like Windows stays out of the way to me. I wish Windows "just worked" but it doesn't. It breaks all the time unless you're a power user. Giving my parents Linux was the best thing I ever did for them because it turned their laptops from a source of constant frustration to an always-on communication machine. We went from hundreds of ads and dozens of toolbars on windows to a Linux machine that just works. Now I'm just trying to get my dad to switch to Linux for work so he doesn't have to install his printer drivers again every time he wants to print something. All he uses for work is Chrome any way.
- m_mueller 11y agoTotally agreed. 11y OSX user, tried to give Windows 10 a chance as the host system on a $2800 tablet (Vaio Canvas). HiDPI still a mess, tablet mode is worse than ever because it doesn't automatically bring up the keyboard for most apps (and even hides the keyboard tray icon by default - wtf?), system settings are complete and utter shit compared to OSX or even Windows 7, touchpad is unusable as always. Only good thing is the nice looking hardware, especially the stand, but it's tainted by the hideous power adapter (and very short batt. life no matter how you use it).
- davidgerard 11y ago2007 was the year of Linux on the Desktop - with netbooks, Linux was literally competition for Windows on the desktop for the first time and Microsoft had to make XP super-cheap.
- StreamBright 11y agoPretty much, finally MS decided to make it happen. :) On a more serious note, you can get all of the benefits of windows and linux in one without docker or any vm running. This is great!