4 ms·
How do these compare to the Power8 chips? I know Power8 is targeting supercomputers, government research and some large banks.
by bogomipz 11y ago
How do these compare to the Power8 chips? I know Power8 is targeting supercomputers, government research and some large banks.
- _chris_ 11y agoThere are a million things that influence performance to a greater degree than the ISA. However, there's no reason to believe you can't make a perfectly good high-performance RISC-V processor. In my own benchmarking of ARM, x86, and RISC-V CPUs, I've found bigger differences between different GCC compiler versions than between ISAs themselves.
- PeCaN 11y agoIt doesn't. How does Apple's A9X compare to a Xeon E7? RISC-V is excellent for hobbyist boards, mobile CPUs, high-efficiency low-performance servers, as a base for DSPs, high-efficiency network equipment, etc. Everything from the DSP in your phone to a Rasperry Pi to a Macbook Air. POWER8 is excellent for high-performance computing, supercomputers, and workstations (Talos[1] when?! :( ). Things like CAPI, Nvlink, etc—stuff that's well outside the scope of RISC-V (though I suppose you could make an ISA targeting HPC based on the RISC-V base integer ISA, but it would only tangentially resemble RISC-V by the time you're done). Personally I'm looking forward to using both of them in the future! 1. https://raptorengineeringinc.com/TALOS/prerelease.php https://raptorengineeringinc.com/TALOS/prerelease.php
- bogomipz 11y agoThe Talos stuff looks interesting but $3,700 is a bit of sticker shock. Hopefully demand and economies of scale will drive down those price points.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoPOWER has been overpriced for too long. From my past looks at catalogs, paying $3,700 today would be a steal to get a high-performance, POWER workstation. Not necessarily competitive price/performance with Intel but certainly with older RISC workstations.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoYou could use RISC-V in those POWER8 applications with a suitable implementation. I don't think it would be POWER and probably be only a fraction of it. Just so much careful optimization and design in POWER at ISA and implementation level for number crunching. Yet, an Octeon III-like implementation of RISC-V esp w/ accelerators for SIMD/MIMD or onboard GPU could kill a lot of Intel and POWER processors in performance while getting us close to top contenders.
- renox 11y agoAnd RISC-V target low power usage. The easiest example to show the difference is big int computations: they aren't very easy/efficient on RISC-V as it doesn't have a "condition code register".