4 ms·
Seems neat. Interface style could use some improvements by pro designers. That's intuitive guess rather than professional advice. I like that you mostly copied
by nickpsecurity 11y ago
Seems neat. Interface style could use some improvements by pro designers. That's intuitive guess rather than professional advice. I like that you mostly copied Facebooks model without getting close enough for a lawsuit. Makes it easy to understand. You've attracted an interesting crowd including what looks like hookers lol. The people in the feed mostly look young on my end so I can't tell if it's long-term or a temporary fad to them. Facebook used explosive growth followed by lock-in and acquiring competition to avoid that risk. noije in upper-right is cute idea but maybe bad since it's not intuitive: many are unwilling to Google what they expect to be an indicator of not signed in or their username.
Those are first impressions. There's potential here. The one concern I have not addressed by the site is if this is venture funded. I'm guessing "Apply HN" means it's intended to be but that would be a negative for me. Anything long-term, esp security/privacy related, shouldn't be trusted if it's venture funded as their model is selling out to firms that tend to unravel good quality, service, or security startups created. Short-term, create interest, experiment, and make a lot of money? There's still potential there.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- nickpsecurity 11y ago"Thank you for your comments, very interesting to read. I've taken note of some of your feedback." Hope it helps you. Long-term, VC or not, I'd rather have your model dominant than Facebook's. I also doubt you're more scheming than Zuckerberg as he's like a special breed of it. That said, it might be valuable to allow people the option (at some point) of paying you directly not to be tracked or to be barely tracked. That way, they can explicitly decide if you're working for advertisers or them in the case of their data/activity. "If you are to take out the element of the public identity, you end up with something like the "anti-Facebook" - a place where you can be who you want to be, where you don't care so much how you act, or even what others think of you." You end up with 4chan, Reddit, Youtube comments, and the like. I've seen this too many times. It overpromises the potential but ignores human nature. The combination of social power that can be projected with anonymity leads to domination. Only a combo of reputation, culture, and effective moderation seems to create good, anonymous/pseudononymous communities. Keep that in mind as exploring combinations of that might help you in your goal. "But after 12 years of Facebook, things are definitely changing - and we're listening closely so that we stay in tune with what people want." You're so lucky to have started at this time. Or smart. I agree. I think the reason is that Facebook is so big and capitalizing on lock-in that they don't give a damn about their users. They've been doing it for years but people are noticing a bit more. Things like videos they can't turn off that blow up their bandwidth, people tagged in photos that don't use Facebook, no protection against creeps using tricks that are years old, and so on. Time is ripe for disrupting Facebook even if it's just a niche of people (a) care about privacy or (b) just want to be counter to Facebook.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]