3 ms·
It would be cheaper to provide free uber than to build a train line in any moderate sized American city. And it's unfortunate that people don't understand that
by CamperBob2 11y ago
It would be cheaper to provide free uber than to build a train line in any moderate sized American city.
And it's unfortunate that people don't understand that this is exactly the right thing to do.
Once autonomous vehicles are ready for prime time, mass transit will be instantly forgotten. This whole article is about spending $50,000,000,000 on shiny new stables and hitching posts.
- PantaloonFlames 11y ago> mass transit will be instantly forgotten. yep, the economies of scale of "mass" transit will then be available to "individual" transit, and that will be very attractive to people.
- criddell 11y agoMass transit will still make a lot of sense where there's, you know, masses of people. Frequent train service into Manhattan works much better than a fleet of Uber's. Outside of dense areas though, Uber-like services (or even privately owned self-driving cars) win.
- CamperBob2 11y agoA fleet of synchronized autonomous vehicles is a train. The idea of spending billions of dollars on hardwired tracks when it's so obviously the wrong thing to do in the long term is just forehead-slappingly dumb.
- jacalata 11y agoAre you picturing some kind of pod-like vehicle about one square foot big?
- CamperBob2 11y agoAre you picturing a train that actually goes where people need to end up? A busy road can move more people in an hour than a train can move in a day.
- timthelion 11y agoThe two metro(subway) stations at Vaclav square in Prague have between 1 and 2 thousand people arriving AND leaving every 10 minutes at rush hour, how are you going to get that kind of capacity using cars, without having some kind if dedicated tunnel(which would be the same as a subway, just less efficient).
- CamperBob2 11y agoThat's basically the capacity of a single lane of traffic per hour (http://onlinepubs.trb.org/onlinepubs/nchrp/nchrp_rpt_599.pdf http://onlinepubs.trb.org/onlinepubs/nchrp/nchrp_rpt_599.pdf p. 13), generously assuming all single-occupancy vehicles. So we can build train stations that are guaranteed not to be where people need to end up, or we can use existing roads more intelligently. To me, that doesn't sound like such a tough choice.
- timthelion 11y agoYes, but that's per HOUR not per 10 minutes. And you cannot multiply by 6 and put in 6 lanes, because Vaclav square is only 3 lanes wide and is a PEDESTRIAN area. Also, 6 lanes wouldn't work at that capacity, because people would have to cross those lanes. Also, that capacity is for driving through, not stopping and getting on/off.
- CamperBob2 11y agoSorry, I don't agree that there's a material difference. You're comparing one highway to the single busiest train station in the city, and that just doesn't make sense. Trains are not going to be the answer. Nobody is going to be taking the train 50 years from now, or any other form of fixed-rail urban transit.
- culturestate 11y ago> Once autonomous vehicles are ready for prime time, mass transit will be instantly forgotten. In some places, perhaps -- big American cities with decent overground infrastructure capacity -- but the world will not just stop needing subways and trams. I cannot possibly imagine the chaos if the 5 million people who use the Hong Kong MTR every day suddenly started using cars.
- CamperBob2 11y agoI cannot possibly imagine the chaos if the 5 million people who use the Hong Kong MTR every day suddenly started using cars. That's because you haven't thought through what it's going to be like when those cars aren't driven by humans.
- culturestate 11y agoI've heard this assertion many times, but it almost never accounts for the fact that most of the world's urban cores are simply not designed for large volumes of vehicular traffic. There are about 550 miles of roadway in the parts of Hong Kong where the vast majority of people live and work; most of that is narrow, much of it is on steep grade, and almost all of it dates back to the days of pulled rickshaws. Self-driving cars will almost certainly replace the taxi fleet and may well kill the bus lines, but they have no hope of matching the capacity of an underground train in places like this.
- CamperBob2 11y agoI can't speak with regard to Hong Kong. This article is about Seattle. Underground tunneling here is very expensive and subject to unique engineering problems that most areas don't have, which have been covered adequately elsewhere.
- culturestate 11y agoThe limitations we find in HK are broadly the same in every big, old city -- New York, Boston, London, Tokyo, Istanbul, and most any other place that got its start as a major population center before the early 1900s. Even if we throw out tunneled trains, something like Chicago's El will be miles more efficient in a dense urban core than trying to cram thousands more cars into streets that weren't designed for them.
- vkou 11y agoIn any major metro area, if you were to replace mass transit with self-driving cars overnight, you'd have permanent gridlock. [1] No number of autonomous vehicles will get you out of the fact that automobiles are the least efficient way to transport people over roadways. [1] http://www.core77.com/posts/8015/car-bus-bicycle-taking-up-space-in-the-same-place-8015 http://www.core77.com/posts/8015/car-bus-bicycle-taking-up-s...
- CamperBob2 11y agoI didn't read the document at [1]. Is it based on the idea that self-driving cars won't operate under coordinated supervision, and will behave just like cars driven by humans? Because if it is, it isn't worth the space it takes up on the Internet. Self-driving cars won't be any more vulnerable to gridlock than trains are. And none of this stuff is going to happen "overnight," especially in Seattle.
- vkou 11y agoYou should. It's a simple picture that compares road throughput of mass transit vs automobiles. I don't care if the self-driving car revolution will take two decades - if we abandon mass transit, we will either have to greatly reduce our trips, or demolish half the city to build more roads.