3 ms·
I'm with you on that. I recall back when there were affordable PPC systems really competing with Intel running alternative OS's. Fun stuff. I've even told peopl
by nickpsecurity 11y ago
I'm with you on that. I recall back when there were affordable PPC systems really competing with Intel running alternative OS's. Fun stuff. I've even told people about each new POWER chip because they're often badass in some way. Yet, it's constantly out of reach for most of us because the numbers don't add up at these prices.
Further, I speculate this is harming it in the long-run because so much code out there comes from the scratching an itch phenomenon. People usually do that on whatever boxes they like working with. If basically none have POWER machines, then basically none of that code is going to be for POWER architecture. I don't have the data to test or prove this but I'm sure there's network effects there.
Just look at the explosion of code for ARM following the explosion of cheap devices. And Intel before it. And the major microcontrollers. And so on.
- mindcrime 11y agoJust look at the explosion of code for ARM following the explosion of cheap devices. And Intel before it. And the major microcontrollers. And so on. Exactly. This is why I never understood why IBM didn't do more to appeal to the experimenter / hobbyist / consumer market, even if their primary market was big enterprise accounts. Getting hardware out there for the tinkerers, OSS developers, etc., to seed the software space could only be beneficial to them.
- jabl 11y agoI'm sure everyone involved in this OpenPOWER game is aware of the "attack of the killer micros". So the question is, why try again with the same recipe that already failed? Getting something out there which is bang-for-buck competitive with Xeons is really the key here. But without massive volume, it's probably very hard to do. And the Intel division that makes Xeons apparently runs at 50% gross margins, so if they feel threatened the are certainly able to dump prices to make life for any competitor even more difficult.
- hga 11y agoBut if they were serious about making a go at it, they'd, say, sell the motherboards and CPUs at cost and/or perhaps twice what Xeon systems go for. But everything I've heard before and in this discussion puts them at $3K per socket (I think for a barebones system), and that's a non-starter for something that isn't 10 times better than the competition (a common metric for what it takes to get attention when there's an entrenched competent competition).
- nickpsecurity 11y agoIntel Xeon funding and lots of ecosystem it uses came from other CPU's that cost less. So, I'd say POWER needs such benefits that come from lower-end if Xeon needed it to get where it is. POWER actually needs more since it's way the heck behind Xeon in balance of price, performance, and capabilities in SW.