6 ms·
> The Education Department has assembled a “behavioral sciences unit” to study the psychology of borrowers and why they don’t repay. Ha! There is a bit of a hy
by rdtsc 11y ago
> The Education Department has assembled a “behavioral sciences unit” to study the psychology of borrowers and why they don’t repay.
Ha! There is a bit of a hypocrisy there -- if big banks / companies piss away money and choose to strategically default then (and some even get bail-outs), it is just business. If people do it for whatever reason, well clearly the are immoral, deficient somehow, their psychology needs to be studied by a special committee.
> Some borrowers aren’t repaying even when they can.
Yap, makes sense. They see banks get bailouts, why shouldn't they get bailouts. Now maybe they shouldn't have been allowed to borrow to start with. But maybe so shouldn't have banks and insurance companies been allowed to leverage to unsustainable levels.
> The singular goal of our student loan program is to help all students get a degree that sets them up for success
One a separate note, that needs to be reviewed and re-evaluated. There are deeper issues here. Simply handing out billions of dollars for degrees like Masters in Basket Weaving from Phoenix University cannot possibly be seen as solution to anything (except well, handing out tax payer money to Phoenix University...)
- letitgo12345 11y agoThe TARP bailout was not money just handed out to banks. It was loans to banking and other industries which was repaid in full overall. And in fact it was the auto industry which failed to repay the loan, not the banking industry. I'm not a fan of the financial sector but let's keep the facts straight here
- kaonashi 11y agoIt was backstopping shitty loans with the full faith & credit of the gov't. Note that the person who received the shitty loan still got foreclosed on and lost their equity. The persons responsible, who made the loan, don't have to take a loss.
- oldmanjay 11y agoWhat sort of belief should I start from to be able to decide that people taking a loan they can't afford bear no responsibility? I imagine it's the same sort of thinking that leads to calling a property they never actually paid for theirs but I am not sure and when I am not sure, I ask.
- kaonashi 11y agoThey both bear responsibility, but only one party got the bailout.
- iambateman 11y agoI hear what you're saying, but bankruptcy is most certainly a bailout relative to debtors prison.
- sk5t 11y agoThat's an interesting perspective, but the U.S.A. does not have debtors' prison. Only bad loans that are not repaid.
- nkurz 11y agothe U.S.A. does not have debtors' prison While true in theory, this may not be true in practice. There are several loopholes, one main one being that failure to pay fees and penalties assessed by the justice system itself can be a criminal offense. In some states a significant percentage (as high as 20%) of current prisoners are being held for failing to pay these LFO's (Legal Financial Obligations). Here are a couple ACLU reports about the practice: In for a Penny: The Rise of America’s New Debtors’ Prisons https://www.aclu.org/files/assets/InForAPenny_web.pdf https://www.aclu.org/files/assets/InForAPenny_web.pdf Modern Day Debtors Prisons: The Ways Court-Imposed Debts Punish People for Being Poor https://aclu-wa.org/sites/default/files/attachments/Modern%20Day%20Debtor's%20Prison%20Final%20(3).pdf https://aclu-wa.org/sites/default/files/attachments/Modern%2...
- pc86 11y ago> failure to pay fees and penalties assessed by the justice system itself can be a criminal offense Which doesn't have much of anything to do with the real estate market, right?
- dragontamer 11y agoWithout help from the government, those loans would have never happened at those rates. If you don't like FAFSA loans, you are perfectly willing to go to any bank (or maybe a rich uncle) and get another loan (or convince your rich uncle to bankroll you). But for the vast majority of people, FAFSA is the only way to pay for college. And taking out 8% or 9%+ loans from NON-FAFSA institutions is a lot worse than taking a 6% to 7% FAFSA loan. I think funding the loans and keeping interest rates lower is a good thing.
- mountaineer22 11y agoIt is an artificial government subsidy, used to fund "non-profit" real estate development.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- dv_dt 11y agoI think the economic phrase that you are referring to is "moral hazard". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moral_hazard https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moral_hazard It's one way that an economy can break down...
- dv_dt 11y agoAnd what of quantative easing where trillions of assets of banks (including junk mortgage backed securities) were purchased by the Fed, relieving banks of the full impact of their actions?
- maaku 11y agoI was going to call you out on conflating TARP with QE, which bought Treasury bonds, but I now see that was just QE1. QE2 and 3 bought mortgage backed securities and bad bank debt. Disgusting.
- eellpp 11y agoHow about gov do quantitative easing for these student loans. Basically provide contracts and various incentives for companies that are employing these students who have loans. Also to various vendors like house owners etc who provide service to these students. This would create a negative impact on students who did not took loans or got good jobs and paid up in time etc. But that's how largely it was done for QE also. /s
- Nihilartikel 11y agoYou can't inject wealth into the system at the demand side like that! The rabble will spend it all on natty ice and chalupas! Gotta give it to the job creators!
- chadzawistowski 11y ago"QE for the people" is essentially just Basic Income.
- dv_dt 11y agoSort of: Just this morning Ray Dalio commented in an interview on problems with Fed controls via interest rates or injecting money via QE, vs times when the economy might respond better to 'helicopter money' or injecting money directly to the people. http://www.marketplace.org/2016/04/06/world/economy-debt-cycle http://www.marketplace.org/2016/04/06/world/economy-debt-cyc... I'm reading further than the Dalio comments, but if one were to implement Basic income with some ratio of "helicopter" injection selectable by the Fed, it would give the Fed another control pedal to better manage the economy. In particular, when investment level injection is just circulating among the financial circles and not making it down to the main street economy which cycles money with buying and selling of more real goods.
- erichocean 11y agoYou mean, they paid it back by having the USG buy all their shitty home loans to get them off the books? I'm not a fan of the financial sector but let's keep the facts straight here
- maxerickson 11y agoIt anyway isn't the case that TARP and QE are aimed just at the financial sector. They are aimed at preserving the existing economic order. If insurance companies start defaulting, things get exciting.
- meric 11y agoIf banks can 'pay back' their TARP loans with bad debts, students ought to be able to 'pay back' their student loans with promise of future earnings excess of minimum wage, that was supposed to be enabled by taking on a degree.
- djsumdog 11y agoNo. They were hand outs. Only some banks got them. PNC got $5 billion from TARP. They then bought National City Bank, a regional bank in Ohio. National City was not allowed to even apply for TARP. PNC bought NC with that $5 billion, then got a tax break for $5 billion for "saving" them. PNC bought National City for free, using tax payers money. TARP was not a loan. It backed every bank debt 100% (when it should have been pennies on the dollar) and allowed the strong banks to kill all the weaker ones, literally for free. Had TARP not gone though, the banks would have had to sell mortgages back to debtors at a fraction of the price. Instead, they continued to collect loans on debtors, feed the rich and destroy the savings of the middle class.
- praxulus 11y agoIt sounds like the tax break was the handout, not the TARP loan.
- TheLogothete 11y agoAll the banks and companies received loans, not handouts. The govmnt. made a profit on all of it, actually.
- jld89 11y agoOh please... paying back with little to no interest means it was a government handout. The banks got rich using that money (giving loans with that money at much higher interest of what they were paying the government, it was a bonanza for them), the taxpayers money at the expense of the middle class. So yes, let's keep the facts straight here.
- cryoshon 11y ago>If people do it for whatever reason, well clearly the are immoral, deficient somehow, their psychology needs to be studied by a special committee. Yeah. There's also the marginal utility of money. The banks can piss away billions without really getting that hurt. Their debts are business agreements that can be broken under the profitable circumstances. Student loan payments each month hurt people far more, yet defaulters are looked down on. The solution is a mass debt strike, until there's a student loan bailout or other large concessions. Threatening to crash the economy further got the banks their trillions during the crisis, so why don't normal people team up and do the same?
- itchyouch 11y agoThose that can't pay it, simply can not, but those who can pay it don't want to suffer the individual penalties of doing so. Mess one's credit report up and now an individual has to hope not to get sued and harassed by collections calls and probably give up financing anything for the next 7 years whether it's a new credit card, car, or house. There's also a small minority of people also savvy enough to pull off defaulting without the legal repercussions. Unless there is a coordinated effort, simply defaulting by one's self would be suicide. There is also the risk/reward factor. Defaulting on 100-200k loans with no income? high risk, but also a high reward potential. Lawyers know you can extract blood from a stone. Defaulting on 5k worth of loans making 50-60k/year? High risk, low reward. Better to just make the payments for 1-3 years and be done with them.
- caseysoftware 11y agoThe reasoning here is simple: If you think your loans are going to be forgiven, why not stop paying on them? In fact, it's stupid to keep paying them. If I still had student loans, I'd consider the same. In all honesty, I doubt there's going to be a serious re-evaluation of these programs until the system breaks. There are many degrees that people here consider absurd but there is inertia and programs and efforts to make sure that those are the best protected. Can you imagine the headlines if a university canceled the "women's studies" degree and shifted the money to something resembling vocational training?
- dragontamer 11y ago> Ha! There is a bit of a hypocrisy there -- if big banks / companies piss away money and choose to strategically default then (and some even get bail-outs), it is just business. If people do it for whatever reason, well clearly the are immoral, deficient somehow, their psychology needs to be studied by a special committee. A lot of misunderstanding here. Education department doesn't have any enforcement arm as far as I'm aware. Understanding why students are defaulting on loans is 100% in the realm of what the education department SHOULD be doing.
- maaku 11y ago> Education department doesn't have any enforcement arm as far as I'm aware. The IRS will garnish wages for student loans.
- dragontamer 11y agoYes. IRS. Not Department of Education. IRS is in Department of Treasury, run by Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner. On the other hand, a study conducted by the Department of Education, run by Education Secretary John King Jr, makes a lot of sense. and is hardly malicious at all. Department of Education wanting to know the effectiveness of their FAFSA loan program (and why or why not people are able to pay those loans back) is definitely a good thing. Besides, all the loans are being handled by Sallie Mae (a private company with some Government support). So its Sallie Mae who is officially on the hook with regards to collections and such. The Department of Education is rather removed from the whole finances thing, as far as I'm aware. So basically, you can assume a malicious force if the IRS or maybe even Sallie Mae began to conduct this sort of investigation. But the Department of Education? Collections isn't their thing. They're likely interested in the state of education, college readiness and the like.
- joshdickson 11y agoTim Geithner has not been Treasury Sec in years. Jack Lew is the current head.
- mountaineer22 11y ago
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- pc86 11y agoIt seems like you are arguing in favor of people even with the ability to pay back a loan, simply deciding not to because they don't want to. If that's accurate, it is absolutely disgusting. This is not about TARP. It's not about taxpayer-funded bailouts of whatever industry the royal you happens to dislike today. There are two completely separate obligations in play. 1. The legal (civil) obligation: There should be stiff penalties for people who decide not to pay back a student loan because "LOL TARP." Especially if it's a loan where the government ends up on the hook. Wage garnishments and sub-500 credit scores seem appropriate. Not to mention the fact that signing a prom 2. The moral obligation: You said you'd pay it back. Keep your word. Despite extenuating circumstances, you're just a plain old bad person otherwise. None of this applies to people who can't pay back the loan because they're a barista with a law degree. I think we need to look at why they spent the money they did on a degree that is apparently doing nothing for them but regardless they don't have the ability. But they're in for a world of hurt when the loan is forgiven and they have a 4 figure (or higher) tax bill from the IRS for the income.
- rdtsc 11y ago> 2. The moral obligation: You said you'd pay it back. Keep your word. Despite extenuating circumstances, you're just a plain old bad person otherwise. That's exactly the problem. You are applying guilt and morality to people (and not just you, this is a popular PR technique) but when businesses choose to not pay the fines, loans, or choose to continuously violate a law (because paying a fine is cheaper than complying), for whatever business reason, then it is seen "as a business decision". For example, during the housing crises years, there were a few articles warning about the second wave of housing crisis -- that where wealthy people who see their house under water, would stop paying even if they could. They would choose to mail the keys to the bank and walk away because 7 years of bad credit is better than paying an extra $200k over the value of their house. And that was scaring some economists -- that fact that people will start acting rationally and applying "normal business principles" to their own affairs. > There should be stiff penalties for people who decide not to pay back a student loan because "LOL TARP." Where are the stiff penalties for banks and insurance companies pissing away money on shady deals? People were not blind they saw what happened.