3 ms·
I was under the impression that a carbon tax hurts the poor. http://news.stanford.edu/news/2014/february/kolstad-carbon-tax-022814.html http://news.stanford.ed
by melling 11y ago
I was under the impression that a carbon tax hurts the poor.
http://news.stanford.edu/news/2014/february/kolstad-carbon-tax-022814.html http://news.stanford.edu/news/2014/february/kolstad-carbon-t...
- toomuchtodo 11y agoNot when you rebate it back to those under a certain income threshold.
- melling 11y agoHow do you know what to rebate people? The carbon tax will hit more than their electric bill. Also, some people have greener electricity than others. Here's how electricity is generated by state: https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/national/power-plants/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/national/power-plant...
- epistasis 11y agoIf it affects the poor, it would make the most sense to rebate purely on income level, equally based on income level. If the idea is to just give it back to the people that paid into it, that completelt defeats the entire purpose.
- melling 11y agoSo, someone who lives in a state with green electricity, and buys products from "green companies", will get the same as someone from a coal state, like West Virginia? The question is why are you giving rebates to people who are mostly using green energy?
- epistasis 11y agoBecause they aren't dumping as much carbon into the atmosphere. Thats the entire point of it all! Those who are dumping carbon into the atmosphere are free loading on the rest of society, expecting others to pay for their externalities. And it's not "giving rebate" it's returning tax revenues to those that can least afford them. But there are many other sources of carbon than poorly planned electrical systems. Driving, flying, and industry.
- melling 11y agoThe poor person in West Virginia getting his electricity from dirty coal and driving a 10 year old F150 is getting the same rebate. He's buying stuff from Walmart that's shipped from China. Are you rewarding people for using less carbon or is the rebate to help offset the cost past through from companies passing on the extra tax onto consumers? Two different claims are being made.
- MaysonL 11y agoThey may be getting the same rebate, but they aren't paying the same tax. If the rebate is the same for all, then those who use less will make a profit, considering the $rebate - $tax amounts, while those using more will pay more tax than they get in rebates. (This is assuming a revenue neutral arrangement).
- will_hughes 11y agoI havn't looked into it in detail, but I was under the impression that it wasn't so much to affect consumer choices directly, as commercial behavior. That is, putting a price on carbon will result in businesses either putting up prices, or choosing lower emission production options. All other things being equal, this should result in having lower emission companies having a pricing edge, and then consumers picking those products.
- SilasX 11y agoBetter to just rebate a fixed amount to everyone so that you preserve the incentives for cutting back any marginal unit of fossil fuel consumption, while mitigating the overall income effect.
- aoeusnth1 11y agoJust adjust income tax to compensate. Penalizing carbon production is a simple incentive-compatible way to have society receive compensation for the actual damage of people's actions.
- greglindahl 11y agoYou can find citations to discussions & proposals for how to mitigate that in many places, such as the Wikipedia Carbon Tax article: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_tax#Distributional_impacts https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_tax#Distributional_impa...
- SilasX 11y agoIn the sense that it's a kind of consumption tax, and consumption taxes are (considered[1]) regressive, then yes. So? Consumption (of fossil fuels) is the problem. Any policy measure that cuts fossil fuel consumption will thus necessarily be regressive to the extent that it precisely targets the problem. It's not like cap-and-trade or efficiency mandates somehow avoid that. But whatever anti-fossil-fuel measure you impose can be mitigated with orthogonal welfare policies. Also, it's not policy options can ever lack downsides. [1] I saw "considered" because the traditional result only gets that by a confused accounting basis. Yes, a consumption tax hits less of a rich person's income, but it hits the same amount of their later consumption. Don't compare income apples to consumption oranges.
- Gibbon1 11y agoIf a carbon tax will hurt the poor imagine what climate change is going to do to them. Personally I think poor people tend to be in this sort of budgetary Malthusian squeeze. If you raise the price of one thing then something else will have to give. Tax their gasoline more the end result is they'll buy 'less car' and have less money left over for rent. Since rents are likely the only other fungible cost that's where the money will ultimately come from.
- fpoling 11y agoIt reminds me of an old joke when Soviet Union tried to decrease alcohol consumption through rising alcohol prises: When father came home, his son announced that vodka would cost 50% more and said: - Father, does it mean that you are going to drink less? - No son, it means that you are going to eat less.
- mikekchar 11y agoThis is something you will have to deal with anyway. Let's take the the US for an example (although this will apply virtually anywhere in the world). I don't have time to gather excellent data, but wikipedia tells me that in 2010 28% of households made less than $25K, 51% made less than $50K, 69% made less than $75K. So in reality, about 30% are in a fairly serious pinch nearly all the time and 50% are probably doing OK, but still having to watch their budgets pretty closely. Only 30% of the population has the kind of earnings that people on HN generally consider acceptable. Let's say that energy which doesn't liberate much carbon is 20% more expensive than carbon intensive energy (who knows). Really, only 30% of the population can easily swallow that cost increase. And even then, if we are talking about replacing cars, etc, etc the capital costs are actually outside the reach of a large percentage of those people (imagine being told that you have to replace your car today... could you afford it?) In reality, if only the people who could afford it switched, it would not actually represent a large reduction in carbon usage. You have to disproportionately affect lower income brackets because that's were the vast majority of people live. So if you tax carbon to make it attractive to switch, it's really not any more expensive. The main issue is making sure that people are able to deal with the capital expenses. Otherwise they won't switch. So IMHO, you are correct that carbon tax alone won't be enough. But there isn't really a downside to such a tax as long as you find a way to deal with capital expenses. In order to be successful, the poor must switch to the more expensive option.
- WalterBright 11y agoA carbon tax could be coupled with a reduction in, say, sales tax. The incentive to reduce carbon would still be there, but the regressive effect on the poor would be mitigated.