5 ms·
Reading the article from the Swedish national radio, the court decision found that wikimedia database of photo has a "commercial value" that can compete with co
by belorn 11y ago
Reading the article from the Swedish national radio, the court decision found that wikimedia database of photo has a "commercial value" that can compete with commercial enterprises of the copyright authors who created the public statues or paintings on buildings.
The journalist asked a lawyer if this mean that its illegal now to take a photo of public statues, and the lawyer said that it legal since the law explicitly says so, but it might not be legal to publish it" on the Internet" as that action might be considered to have a commercial value.
In my view, its a bit weird.
- pilif 11y ago> In my view, its a bit weird. I think it's a matter of opportunity cost. By giving away an art-finder like this for free, using the pictures of the sculptures, you take away the incentive for commercial provider to do the same thing. Commercial providers would have to pay money for the pictures and thus, a free app is costing the copyright owner (or the manager of the copyrights) money indirectly. And even failing that: By publishing this on the internet, even if you are offering it for free and without ads, you still create value for third-parties with this content (carriers, platform owners, whoever is injecting ads into your content, etc), so as monetary value is created with this content, the management agency wants to be paid and if they can't be, then they want the content off the net, so other content might appear where they are getting paid. At least that's what I believe to be the reasoning.
- LeifCarrotson 11y agoThat may be the reasoning, but it's nonsense. Anything done for free - picking up litter, sharing photographs online, giving someone directions - could be done commercially. Anything done commercially could be done commercially for more money. This may be the law, but it violates my basic understanding of fairness.
- RobertoG 11y agoThat reasoning make some sense for objects in a museum, but for public art in the street? Something that it's not clear to me is if this "public art" has been paid with public money. That would make all this even more crazy.
- ptaipale 11y ago> Something that it's not clear to me is if this "public art" has been paid with public money Much of it has.
- hjnilsson 11y agoThis court decision is a result of the change of law that in part was motivated to happened to get piracy back in 2005. When it was amended there were many, many more restrictions placed on digital distribution than before. The law in question explicitly say "Artwork can be depicted if contained in a collection or catalogue, but not in digital form". So a book detailing famous art is allowed, but a website doing the same is not. This also means it is not illegal to post Facebook photos with a statue. Since clearly that is not a database, just a random photo. The paragraph in question: https://lagen.nu/1960:729#P24S1 https://lagen.nu/1960:729#P24S1] And the full law: http://rinfo.stage.lagrummet.se//publ/sfs/2005:359/pdf,sv http://rinfo.stage.lagrummet.se//publ/sfs/2005:359/pdf,sv (This law - 2005:359 - is also the law that added the "data tax" in Sweden of 0,4 kronor per MB.)
- fnordsensei 11y agoRight, but wouldn't the Facebook sum total of photos be considered such a database? Or indeed Google Image search?
- Trombone12 11y agoIf you however create a group on facebook and collect photos of statues there along with comments about them on each photo, FB would presumably be liable since I don't think its the sort of thing they prohibit in the ToS.
- phkn1 11y agoUnder this interpretation, wouldn't (say) a collection of Facebook photos with statues, in aggregate, constitute a database and therefore become illegal? At what point does the size and structure of a collection become sufficient to cross the legal line? Would an individual Facebook user therefore be liable? Would Facebook as whole? etc. It seems that the law has created the unintended consequence that the organization of the depictions in question matter more than the actual depictions themselves. Or in other words, of imputing commercial intent to any such collection of copyrighted works, whether intentional or otherwise.
- lukeschlather 11y ago
- quotha 11y agoIs it legal to tweet the picture?!
- 06 11y agoYes. The illegal nature is due to the fact the pictures were held in a catalog. Use by members of the public (such as through the medium of social media) is legal. Outside of Sweden, I come to understand, it isn't illegal to catalog the images either, this is exclusively a Swedish law.
- jug 11y agoHow can it have commercial value if released with a "libre" license?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- digitalneal 11y agoWouldn't this mean a Google Map of public statues would be considered of Commercial value and should be removed?