2 ms·
The Constitution is not binding, in that people can leave its jurisdiction at any time--by renouncing their U.S. citizenship. If a person doesn't like the contr
by snowwrestler 11y ago
The Constitution is not binding, in that people can leave its jurisdiction at any time--by renouncing their U.S. citizenship. If a person doesn't like the contract, they can terminate it.
It is a contract, though. That means that terminating it will also terminate the many benefits of U.S. citizenship. This is a point that, IME, is often lost on people who want to talk about how the Constitution doesn't bind anyone. They want to live in the U.S. with all the rights and privileges of a U.S. citizen, but opt out of taxes, rules, regulations, fees, etc. at their discretion. That's not how contracts work!
So how do people enter into this contract? They are entered into it by their parents when they are minors. Minors cannot execute contracts, but can be subjected to contracts by their parents.
If one wants to look at U.S. citizenship as a contract, then here is the answer. Just like swim class, summer camp, or private school, your parents get to tell you what to do, and that includes being a U.S. citizen. Once a U.S. citizen is 18, they are free to terminate the contract as described above.
- jack9 11y ago> It is a contract, though. I didn't sign it. > Minors cannot execute contracts, but can be subjected to contracts by their parents. They didn't sign it either. Not one of my ancestors did. > That's not how contracts work! That's the point?
- snowwrestler 11y agoA person does not have to sign anything to accept a contract and be subject to its terms. Anyway, I don't believe that U.S. citizenship is literally the same as a business contract. My point is that people who do try to make that equivalence, usually don't understand contracts well enough to make any sort of logical point.