3 ms·
> Putting aside ... whether the statistical model was correct You can't put that aside. If the model is simply flawed then following it can't be a good idea. I
by dspillett 11y ago
> Putting aside ... whether the statistical model was correct
You can't put that aside. If the model is simply flawed then following it can't be a good idea. If the model is perfectly true and accurate then not following it is a bad idea. Of course nothing is perfect, so it would never be as black/white as that, but I don't see how any discussion that ignores the model is at all pointful.
> the questions of racial profiling
As with any statistical modelling this can get pretty hairy and potentially has recursive effects that are self-fulfilling. If you search just black people because the model says more of them get caught carrying drugs, you risk perpetuating the statistic whether it is correct or not because if you are hardly ever searching white people few are going to get cause so it will remain that more black people are found to be carrying. Unfortunately good statistical modelling is damn hard and criminal profiling is far from the only place you'll find these problems (many a scientific study has been discredited or otherwise written off some time later because flaws in the modelling and measuring are noticed in subsequent analysis).