3 ms·
Unfortunately, this is a huge market gap nobody's currently filling. "I want an open source platform, but I don't want to put together my own wiring" is a surpr
by ocdtrekkie 11y ago
Unfortunately, this is a huge market gap nobody's currently filling. "I want an open source platform, but I don't want to put together my own wiring" is a surprisingly open field. I saw an advert for ONE such device that claimed to be fully open source, but you can't buy it yet, so that doesn't really mean anything yet.
- rimantas 11y agoMaybe that's because this demand is much lower than you imagine? Nobody cares about open source.
- ocdtrekkie 11y agoWe already have huge widespread popularity for things like the Raspberry Pi and the Arduino. The former is nearly a household name, even if people have no idea what to do with them. And even if you don't know what open source does, is, or means, the benefits of such a product will prove itself over on it's own.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoYeah, Open Source / Open Hardware in IoT is a step back in the direction of how things always were and how they are supposed to be - you buy the device, you own it. People understand that. They expect their washing machines and microwave ovens to work until the hardware itself breaks (let's forget for a moment about the sick practice of planned obsolescence). They expect to be able to repair them or find a third party that can. People don't have to understand "open source". They will understand the concept of "works until hardware dies", or "can be taken to a repairman for fixing", or "I can go to a mall and buy an extension from some random vendor and it will work".
- tamana 11y agoPeople do NOT expect to repair their home appliances anymore. Repair costs more than replacement.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoMaybe in the US.
- ocdtrekkie 11y agoThis is doubtful. Nobody buys a new furnace when it has a problem. Ovens, fridges, and dishwashers are all generally far cheaper to repair with a local repairman than replace. A lot of house or condo sales now come with "home warranties", where a flat fee guarantees your appliances for a year, and repairs only cost a $100 deductible. Computers in most cases, even, are now appliance-like. They get replaced less often, and it's often more affordable to repair them than replace them.
- rimantas 11y agoHuge as compared to? Yep, on HN you will get a sizeable proportion of those interested. The world is not HN though.
- soundwave106 11y agoI think people care about open standards a lot, even if they don't know it. EG: When someone buys a USB device, they expect that they can plug it into any computer and (for non-specialized devices) have it Just Work. A lot of the home automation world is a closed, proprietary mishmash right now. (Although there are some open standards ranging from old school stuff like X10 to newer Zigbee stuff, I don't think products like Nest use them). I also think people expect that when they buy a device, some corporate decision isn't going to brick it. (Stories in this line in my opinion will eventually kill the current hype on the "cloud"). "Open source" is probably less important to most end users, but it can be quite important to developers, power users, and tinkerers. And enthusiasts can drive products.
- ocdtrekkie 11y agoFor those curious, this is the one I found. They're advertising this campaign on Facebook and crud. You can't search it, because it's all images, but they say they're open source. https://www.indiegogo.com/projects/protonet-zoe-start-your-secure-smart-home-now#/ https://www.indiegogo.com/projects/protonet-zoe-start-your-s...
- roel_v 11y agoOnce you start doing the numbers it becomes obvious. There is no margin in this. So many crowd funding projects start out like this only to find out months or years later it's impossible to build a sustainable company by selling pre-assembled open source devices. Especially because who care about the 'open' thing will download the image and burn an SD card themselves.
- tajen 11y agoNo margin, and you're in for your research. However OSS on IoT could be a huge competitive advantage, if you can persuade consumers not to buy knock-offs. When Tesla and Nest created a high-end market, they created self-contained objects. They sold because they were good, not because they had a competitive edge on the closed-source software running them. I set Apple apart because they have high margins on accessories, so open APIs would be a drawback here. My point is: We spend that much money for those products because the're good quality in themselves. The fact that they're closed source means knock-offs can't copy the internal design and will be crap. The only thing required for an open-source IoT company to lead is to persuade us that knock-offs will be crap too (e.g. "uncertified", then spread stories about knock-offs exploding, or shorter length of life, or other leaks of PII, or illegal). The rest of open-source is a huge competitive advantage for relevance in the long term, ecosystem, customer recognition, etc. Knives are quite open-source but we still buy €200 knives from time to time.
- ocdtrekkie 11y agoHardware is relatively difficult to knock off well. And with hardware, manufacturing quality is a huge point. Are their cheaper round Wi-Fi thermostats than Nest? Absolutely. ...I have yet to see a single one that even compares on build quality. And it's not like you can't take one apart and see how it's designed.
- roel_v 11y ago"Knives are quite open-source but we still buy €200 knives from time to time." The exact metallurgical details (chemical composition, manufacturing process) of high-end knives are closely guarded trade secrets. Making greats knives requires a lot of research, knowledge and experience, it's not something every joe schmoe with 100k can start a business in. 'Open source' is just not a competitive advantage. I have a drawer full of junk whose main selling point was 'it's open source!' to prove it. Starting from an open source project gets you 90% of the functionality; the other 90%, you have to do yourself. In the mean time, the 'community' (read: the 5 guys on your mailing list/forum who shout the loudest) demand that the 'company' 'gives back' (by sponsoring, blog posts on every minute detail, hand-holding everybody with a 5-line patch, ...) because now you're making money off 'other peoples' work'. But the moment you commit any code you wrote, there are a dozen Chinese (and non-Chinese) vendors who will take what you made and put it into their own product; which is usually just one of dozens; they are smart and diversify. In the mean time, you are left fighting the marketing game where you essentially have to convince every single customer to pay a 20, 30, 100% markup for - what really? Being the one who 'wrote it first'? Good luck. The Kickstarter graveyard is full of dreams like this.
- thearn4 11y agoThere is this, which is built using a raspberry pi but is also very turn-key/works right out of the box: http://www.amazon.com/Intulon-Z-Command-Controller-Z-Stick-Zw090-A/dp/B0103RPHBG?ie=UTF8&psc=1&redirect=true&ref_=oh_aui_search_detailpage http://www.amazon.com/Intulon-Z-Command-Controller-Z-Stick-Z...
- Chris2048 11y agohttp://www.seeedstudio.com/wiki/Grove_System http://www.seeedstudio.com/wiki/Grove_System ?