3 ms·
If that was all it had done, and if it had defined men as "people who have a penis" and woman as "people who do not have a penis" or something along those lines
by tzs 11y ago
If that was all it had done, and if it had defined men as "people who have a penis" and woman as "people who do not have a penis" or something along those lines, then unless one objected to the whole idea of separate men's and women's rooms it would be fairly hard to come up with a decent objection. (Why do we have separate men's and women's rooms? We didn't have them in student housing at my college, and it was never a problem.)
Others have already pointed out that this is not all it does. It goes far beyond the bathroom.
In addition to that, it also botches the bathroom portion because it sorts people into bathrooms by what is on their birth certificate. If your birth certificate says "male", for instance, but you've had male to female sex reassignment surgery you'd still be sorted into the men's room under this law.
The proponents of the law say that it is easy in North Carolina to get your birth certificate changed to match your new sex when it changes, such as due to sex reassignment surgery.
The problem with that is that there are actually people who are born outside of North Carolina, but for inexplicable reasons move there. North Carolina did not issue their birth certificates, and so North Carolina's ease of changing a birth certificate is irrelevant to them.
Idaho, for example, does not allow amending the sex on a birth certificate. A person who is born female in Idaho, moves to North Carolina, and undergoes female to male sex reassignment surgery will be required to use the woman's room, despite sporting a penis, in North Carolina.
Maybe we are splitting bathrooms wrong. Maybe instead of men/women, the split should be stand/sit. Have one kind of bathroom that just has urinals, and one that just has enclosed stalls. If you have a penis and just need to urinate, you use the former. If you do not have a penis or you need to defecate you use the latter.
Since the latter would have enclosed stalls, you should have enough privacy that it doesn't matter who else is using the other stalls.