4 ms·
First, if they appeared 5+ times in the top 25, the maybe that's a sign that their users want those apps. Secondly, it sounds more like a problem with the app
by jasonlotito 17y ago
First, if they appeared 5+ times in the top 25, the maybe that's a sign that their users want those apps. Secondly, it sounds more like a problem with the app store then with the applications offered. If the app store is displaying information you aren't interested in, then that's Apple's problem. They didn't solve the problem. The App Store's ability to show you apps hasn't improved. It was the easy way out.
- GHFigs 17y agoIf the app store is displaying information you aren't interested in, then that's Apple's problem. They didn't solve the problem. Actually, for some set of their customers, they did. Not every adult is interested in buying softcore pornography.
- jasonlotito 17y agoNo, they didn't solve the problem. They removed a consequence of a problem, but the problem still exists: a poor app store.
- GHFigs 17y agoThe problem defined by the parent comment was "the app store is displaying information you aren't interested in". For the set of users that are not interested in "iBoobs", etc. the App Store no longer displays that information. I thought that by quoting it was clear that was the problem I was referring to, and not something as vague as "a poor app store". You may disagree with the method, but to say this does not solve a problem for a set of users is just ignorant. The problem was doing X, and now it no longer does X. I don't see how anybody can not consider that at least a partial solution to the more general problem.
- jasonlotito 17y agoNo, the problem had a consequence. They merely removed the consequence of the problem. The problem still exists. I understand what you are saying. I just think the 'solution' was lazy, shortsighted, and doesn't help Apple consumers in the long run, and doesn't solve the problem.
- silencio 17y agoI'm not interested at all in most of the Sports apps. I'm also not really interested in most of the Medical apps. Et cetera. Apple's not going to get rid of those, they're not as offensive to people, right? It's not about the audience or who doesn't want to be part of that audience. It's about the idea that some people are just so offended at these apps being so popular they can't bear to let their kids potentially access them (oh, did we totally just gloss over the parental controls and ratings? oh why yes we did!)
- GHFigs 17y agoRead what I wrote again. I said adults because presumably all of these applications were already age limited to adults. The thing is, as I said, not all adults want softcore pornography. Hence, for that set of users, the App Store just got better. What Apple is assuming is that the set of their users who categorically do not want softcore pornography is larger than the set that do, and that removing themselves from the business of selling and distributing softcore pornography will be a net gain. The same is probably not true of any other distinct class of applications.
- silencio 17y agoThe only way the app would have been age limited for viewing and downloading was if the app was rated accordingly and parental controls were active. Otherwise anyone can see them, logged in or not, on the storefront (of all places!) in one of the top 10 lists or something. Anyone could have downloaded it as well, with only a warning about the application rating at download (you know, the same warning you see on apps with any user-generated content, adult rated or not). It didn't need to be like that. Apple could have had an opt-in verification-required category for adult apps that only shows up at the bottom of the dropdown list of app categories and nowhere else only if you are signed into your verified account. They could have improved ratings and parental controls to satisfy parents and educators. Then the kids going to schools that want to use iPads for education don't have to see these, and the adults that don't want softcore porn in their face won't have to see them either. Instead, Apple just went and removed these apps (well...not even all of them. nice double standard going on with SI and Playboy still on the app store...). That, I think, was a mistake.