4 ms·
If you suspect an order is fraud, don't go out and say to the criminal "hey, I declined your super suspicious order!". Instead, play dead. Pretend they got you.
by stcredzero 11y ago
If you suspect an order is fraud, don't go out and say to the criminal "hey, I declined your super suspicious order!". Instead, play dead. Pretend they got you. Tell them "thank you for your order", behaving exactly the same way as if it really was a successful order.
The name of the game is to make things cost more for your enemies than they cost for you. Removing instant feedback is key. Instant feedback is great. Delayed feedback is costly.
This is in large part why most DRM and anti-cheat failures happened. Companies and developers need to think about the economics of what's going on. It's not the side with the trickiest mechanism that wins. It's the team with economics on their side.
(Amateurs: tactics, pros: logistics)
- SilasX 11y agoYeah I was just talking to an employee of a CC fraud prevention company and that was my thought: they proudly talk about how they can identify fraud and refuse the transaction, when my question was, why not just look like you're approving the order and then follow it right to the fraudster? Better to reliably catch the humans behind this and impose stringent legal penalties than allow them to keep guessing without a cost for being wrong.
- fweespee_ch 11y ago> Yeah I was just talking to an employee of a CC fraud prevention company and that was my thought: they proudly talk about how they can identify fraud and refuse the transaction, when my question was, why not just look like you're approving the order and then follow it right to the fraudster? You can get disposable physical addresses as well. It is part of why some companies flag a mailing address I use as a fraudulent order. I primarily use it to avoid handing out my RL address on domains that don't allow whois protection.
- kyle6884 11y agoThis may work nicely for a subscription business where you have 2 weeks to identify problematic orders. But what about everyone else? Should we silently fail on orders where a customer accidentally mistyped their CC#? Imagine all the extra work involved when you could have had them fix it on the spot.
- pjc50 11y agoYou can report "failed checksum" or "not a valid account" to people, although you should rate limit - the problem is data that is valid but stolen.
- occamrazor 11y agoMistyped card numbers can be identified client-side (CC numbers have a checksum digit). If the number is valid, but the transaction is declined, then fail silently (and possibly send a failure email after manual review of the transaction)
- tomp 11y agoIt could also be declined because of mistyped expiry date or address or name. Or simply declined because the customer is over their credit limit. In all of these cases, timely feedback is useful for genuine customers.
- pc86 11y agoWhich is why it says in the article that these countermeasures almost always come at a cost to customers as well. It is a trade off. In some instances it is worth it to make the experience marginally worse for customers because the savings by preventing a percentage of fraud are so large.
- duaneb 11y agoNonetheless, this doesn't contradict the "failing silently" for chargebacks. It's not fraud if they enter the data poorly or there's no credit left so the charge is never made.
- optimiz3 11y agoThis also applies to customer service. Nice customers get fast response times. Toxic entitled customers (especially of the free plan) wait 2-3+ days before getting a response.
- josu 11y agoI'm not disagreeing with your point, but I love it when I get great customer support as a free/low value customer, and it definitely increases my chances of conversion.
- Matt3o12_ 11y agoMaybe op was referring to free customers that are rude, and impose big costs to you (way above the average support ticket). But agreed, if I get bad support as a free customer, how can I know that the support will get any better if I start paying (except for services that sell support). When I get an instant response to a question from a friendly support, I would say that I'm far more likely to upgrade to their paid server.
- optimiz3 11y agoThe point is that toxic customers tend to sap your bandwidth. If you impose a time cost on them it throttles their ability to do so. One way or another the problem works itself out, which lets you focus on the paying (i.e. actual customers).
- paulpauper 11y agothat why every social network does ghosting to trick spammers and trolls
- lis 11y agoBlue Byte did something along the lines of your suggestion with the copyright protection of Settlers III. When the game detected that the DRM was broken, iron smelters would only produce pigs instead of iron. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Settlers_III https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Settlers_III
- viggity 11y agoreminds me of "Game Dev Tycoon", where if it detected it was cracked, the player had a hard time progressing because their virtual company kept getting ripped off by crackers. http://gameological.com/2013/05/inventory-9-games-with-creative-drm-copy-protection/ http://gameological.com/2013/05/inventory-9-games-with-creat... (it is the first one)
- hellbanner 11y agoMore specifically, the player's simualated video game company goes bankrupt, "due to piracy", according to the game. More details & discussion from Game Dev Tycoon's developer blog: http://www.greenheartgames.com/2013/04/29/what-happens-when-pirates-play-a-game-development-simulator-and-then-go-bankrupt-because-of-piracy/ http://www.greenheartgames.com/2013/04/29/what-happens-when-...
- Symbiote 11y agoFor a much older example, Sim City gave continual disasters after about 10 minutes if the version was detected as pirated. This was 1990 or so.
- stcredzero 11y agoNot bad, but even that reads like a bit of an FU from the devs. ("Pig Iron?") The best thing to do is to make it definitely seem like it was a bug introduced by the crack. (Maybe James Bond villains giving their secret projects suggestive code names and telling their entire plan isn't unrealistic?)
- jldugger 11y ago
- brightball 11y ago100% agree. They care about ROI also. At my last company I build systems specifically designed around wasting the time of people that we "caught". We used to keep a dashboard with the top abusers on a wall in the office once they'd be caught to show how much of their time we were wasting. It was therapeutic.
- Lavel 11y agoValve will sometimes delay banning CS:GO hackers to confuse them about just what triggered the ban.
- groaner 11y agoWhat happens if you have a very small false positive rate for fraud, and end up stiffing the customer? You could easily land in deep trouble with consumer protection laws after falsely satisfying their order.