5 ms·
>Dear lord these guys are putting in work. man I wish they would bring something new, cool and innovative to the space, instead being bent on doing feature-by-
by dominotw 11y ago
>Dear lord these guys are putting in work.
man I wish they would bring something new, cool and innovative to the space, instead being bent on doing feature-by-feature copy of github.
They have an amazing opportunity now to take advantage of github fatigue. But they are throwing it all away by trying to become an inferior clone of github.
- connorshea 11y agoIt has integrated CI whereas GitHub requires using a third-party CI system, it's had Reaction Emoji (called Award Emoji for GitLab) for a while now, it has "Merge when build succeeds", CE is entirely FOSS, etc.
- sytse 11y agoThanks! People also seem to like our new todo's https://about.gitlab.com/2016/03/02/gitlab-todos-feature-highlight/ https://about.gitlab.com/2016/03/02/gitlab-todos-feature-hig... that allow you to respond to what's important even if your mailbox is a mess.
- ianleeclark 11y agoI'd honestly be really surprised if Github didn't end up acquiring one of those CI systems which they already integrate with.
- sdesol 11y agoI'd be surprised if they did. I really don't see a business reason for them doing so. They are clearly laser focused on enterprise, which means massively bespoked internal build systems and work flow. And they'll be competing against a lot of entrenched internal solutions. GitLab and Atlassian have a pricing model for displacing existing systems and encouraging adoption, but I can't see GitHub following suit. GitHub looks to like they want to be the Apple in the Apple vs Android. Android has the largest user base but due to Apple's premium pricing, they have the largest profit.
- dominotw 11y agoThere seems to be a healthy competition between various ci software that works with github. Why would github try to kill that and take on such a high touch area. Its quite puzzling why gitlab went that route, they are basically discouraging ci systems from integrating with them. I think this is would turn out to be a bad decision for gitlab.
- tiplus 11y agoWell, their CI is pretty good for starters... compared to self hosting jenkins, or paying for Travis CI. Self hosting gitlab integrated CI runners is a big plus for me. As a third party service provider you could still host and/or modify those CI runners for specific tasks like node, go, etc.
- sytse 11y agoThanks tiplus! And to give some additional background to dominotw's question. We didn't like the options for CI on-premises. And by integrating it directly into GitLab it is very easy set up a new project, encouraging people to use CI on more projects. Having people use GitLab CI will mean GitLab is a less attractive platform for other CI products. We do have a good commit status API since GitLab 8.1 and there is a great Jenkins plugin that supports that http://doc.gitlab.com/ee/integration/jenkins.html http://doc.gitlab.com/ee/integration/jenkins.html
- wyldfire 11y agoRequirements likely driven by sales/marketing team: either they see the gap or they hear it from potential customers.
- gsmethells 11y agoThey do have some differences if you look close enough.
- braythwayt 11y agoI’m a juuuuge GitHub supporter, but let me provide a different perspective: In business, there is product innovation and there is also business innovation. Sometimes, you provide exactly the same product, but the way in which you do business around that product is the innovation. For example, a 100% open-source implementation of the JVM needn’t provide any technical innovation whatsoever: The innovations are in how it’s developed and how it’s licensed. I won’t speak to whether GitLab is providing any business innovation or not, I’m just pointing out that if they are, that’s something of value in its own right.
- fourthark 11y agoThey were getting a lot of heat when they refused to copy GitHub, because a lot (most?) of GitHub's features are just obvious and helpful. So... being a clone shouldn't be your whole strategy, but you should still learn from the competition.