7 ms·
No it sounds actually like good police work. Running a Tor exit node shouldn't give you some blanket against police investigations.
by dogma1138 11y ago
No it sounds actually like good police work.
Running a Tor exit node shouldn't give you some blanket against police investigations.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- AndrewUnmuted 11y agoI would have said the same, if it were not for the police's unnecessary and demeaning execution of their warrant at 6:00AM. If the police knew he was a tor exit node operator, then surely they could have executed this search at a more reasonable hour?
- homero 11y agoBut a no knock swat raid killing people's dog is more fun
- brbsix 11y agoAt least he still has intact ear drums and door frame. Sounds fairly reasonable at least by contemporary standards.
- throweway 11y agoThey didn't seize the house either
- kbenson 11y agoWhen planning an operation like this you need to plan for a time when the suspect is likely to be home. I imagine the most likely time someone is to be home is right at their regular waking time (people often get home at different times). Additionally, 6:00 AM is not excessively early for a large swath of the population. It's not a convenient time, but when is?
- Godel_unicode 11y agoI couldn't help but imagine the police sending a request to view his outlook calendar while reading your comment.
- dogma1138 11y agoLike at an hour when kids are up and running around maybe just on their way to school?
- pc86 11y agoA. That's not what "demeaning" means. B. As others have said 6:00 AM is among the most likely time that most working professionals will be home. C. I'm not sure what his status as an exit node operator has to do with the hour at which a search is executed?
- logfromblammo 11y agoYou are correct. The thing that should give you the blanket against police investigations is the fact that an IP address does not identify any particular person, and never has. It identifies--temporarily, I might add--a network interface. A warrant based on an IP address should be specific to the computing device associated with that IP address at the time it was logged. The cops should never be able to threaten someone with additional seizures--beyond what is specified on the warrant--to coerce cooperation.
- blacksmith_tb 11y agoI wonder if it wouldn't be prudent, if you wanted to run an exit, to pay for dedicated static IP, maybe even on a totally different ISP. Hard to guess what the warrant would cover, exactly, in that case (probably still a free pass to all your machines). Of course, it's easy to imagine the opposite situation, where someone connects an exit node to ${random neighbors ap}, with terrible results.
- Godel_unicode 11y ago"...The computing device associated with that IP..." Just the NAT router? Computer(s) behind the NAT router? Phones which have wi-fi and may or may not have been on it at the time? Computers on the other end of the site-site VPN which routes traffic out that NAT router to get around Geo IP restrictions? Any computer in the world which has TOR installed and therefore may have been "behind" that NAT router? The Internet is really complicated, how specifically would you write that warrant without details of the network design?
- FireBeyond 11y agoThose defenses - whilst valid in many cases, and for many reasons - also are a core part of the "reasonable" in "reasonable doubt". Many conflate reasonable doubt with "any doubt whatsoever", and think that any excuse that can be concocted which is technically feasible is an alibi. "But Your Honor, it is possible that someone snuck into his house, spoofed his MAC address to get on his Wifi, used that to download this and that, and then left undetected!" So there's a standard of reasonability, and there should be corroborating evidence. Should, at least. In theory.
- voxic11 11y agoPretty sure no one was claiming it should. Rather they are claiming that the police should be required to collect evidence showing probable cause. If raids on tor nodes find CP more then 50% of the time then yeah they are collecting enough evidence. But if they don't then the police are in violation of the Constitution.