4 ms·
Only Gitlab CE is OSS, GitLab EE is "publicly viewable" but neither FOSS/OSS [1]. It's really a shame because I would pay good money to have GitLab EE under a
by Spivak 11y ago
Only Gitlab CE is OSS, GitLab EE is "publicly viewable" but neither FOSS/OSS [1].
It's really a shame because I would pay good money to have GitLab EE under a FOSS license.
[1] https://about.gitlab.com/license-faq/ https://about.gitlab.com/license-faq/
- connorshea 11y agoOut of curiousity, would you consider GPL Affero sufficiently FOSS?
- cyphar 11y ago> Out of curiousity, would you consider GPL Affero sufficiently FOSS? Of course it's a free software license (although I have my doubts about the enforceability of the Affero sections in the AGPL). GitLab EE is proprietary (even though you can read the source).
- Spivak 11y agoAs long as we're talking about the GNU AGPL then absolutely! I would say that the original AGPL is sufficiently FOSS but it's GNU GPL incompatible which might be annoying. It's not necessarily a deal breaker though if it's handled well.
- cyphar 11y ago> As long as we're talking about the GNU AGPL then absolutely! I would say that the original AGPL is sufficiently FOSS but it's GNU GPL incompatible which might be annoying. It's not necessarily a deal breaker though if it's handled well. It's GPLv2 incompatible. GPLv3 has a special exception for the AGPL.
- sytse 11y agoWe initially had GitLab EE under the MIT expat license. But this proved to be a problem for potential customers, their purchasing department didn't understand. We also like that now we can store the EE source in a public repository that accepts merge requests.