4 ms·
I have a sincere question that may sound hyperbole but worth to discuss in HN: what are the ethical/legal limits of leaks when some of the leakers are the class
by wslh 11y ago
I have a sincere question that may sound hyperbole but worth to discuss in HN: what are the ethical/legal limits of leaks when some of the leakers are the classical media? I mean what is the difference of a movie leak (e.g torrent share) with a political leak on media? I will clarify my question to not sound radically stupid: if the Panama Papers had been published anonymously or showing cases of attacks against social liberties or illegal government activities (e.g. Snowden) it is clear, but when the media is showing documents that are not illegal per se but the illegal activities are more connected to their clients [1] I think they can be hardly sued for it.
All this was triggered by the following quote: "Using information/documentation unlawfully obtained is a crime, and we will not hesitate to pursue all available criminal and civil remedies”.
[1] Mossack Fonseca was indeed engaged in illegal activities because they obstructed the US justice over companies suspected of connections to politicians. But this was not known in advance.
- Ensorceled 11y ago> I mean what is the difference of a movie leak (e.g torrent share) with a political leak on media? At it's most simple level: a movie leak is a social ill, breaking of the social copyright contract, and a political leak is a social good, revelation of corruptions and education. That's a simplification of course, copyright is abused, for instance to prevent all access to the copyrighted material in some places and fair use thwarted. Political leaks are sometimes simply scurrilous and provide more heat than light.
- ewzimm 11y agoI understand that you're simplifying, but I don't think social ill is the right word. It's more like a social good which is ill for the copyright holder. The question in that case is balancing the benefit to society against the benefits to the company which claims copyright or intellectual property. It's a social good in the sense that public domain is a social good when society can benefit, but also a deeper social good for the society which inspired and produced the copyrighted work because it allows it to be distributed to people in countries that would otherwise not have access to it. For example, perhaps the greatest weapon against anti-Americanism is American culture spread through Hollywood and other media. This would normally not be sold in areas that are hostile to American values, but leaked material penetrates the culture and reverses hostility. This really comes down to the classic question of whether it's more important to benefit society in general or the rights of property holders. There are people who strongly believe in both extremes and lots of people in the middle. Some say that property is the foundation of freedom and we should sacrifice social good for the promotion of property and others say that the needs of the many outsweigh the needs of the few, even that property is theft of social value. Where any person might stand on these issues is complicated, to say the least.
- netrus 11y agoYou do not mention that the existence of property is meant to benefit the society as a whole. Copyright provides us with blockbusters. We can discuss about fair use, expiration, fines etc, but let's not pretend that STAR WARS would have happend without copyright law.
- iamcurious 11y agoPlenty of works of art were created without copyright law. Would we have STAR WARS? No idea. Would we have awesome films? Definitely.
- talmand 11y agoBut, would those plenty of works of art were created before copying such things became incredibly easy? It seems to me that the concept of copyright became stronger over time as the ability to make money off the work of someone else became easier over time.
- iamcurious 11y agoSure, see all the graffiti everywhere? Laws aren't protecting that art, au contraire. The concept of copyright became stronger as lobbying and surveillance state became stronger. Creative people will create regardless. Creative people who have ample free time and who don't have to think about bills much, will create more and, more importantly, more accessible works. The sophisticated thing to do is to allow copying anybody's ideas¹ and give people a guaranteed income². ¹ I think plagiarism, ie not giving credit where its due, should be punished. I'm not sure if it should fall in the realm of the law though, maybe it could be kept check under social pressure. ² If it can't be universal, then make it scholarship based, subject to renewal, or something.
- gknoy 11y ago> See all the graffiti everywhere? Laws aren't protecting that art, au contraire. Is that really true? I would have thought that the art itself is still copyrighted, but the artist is unlikely to pursue redress as that would effectively be giving evidence of a crime (graffiti).
- pluma 11y agoThe general rule in journalism seems to be that if the information is sufficiently public and there is a sufficient public interest in it, it should be reported on as if it were published legitimately. There's an obvious trade-off between public interest and confidentiality and privacy concerns, of course. I'm not sure what the legal situation is in every country but as I understand it, similar trade-offs exist in German law (which otherwise has a very strong stance on privacy).
- psykpsyk 11y agoIsn't there sufficient public interest in having culture available to everyone? I think even the CIA used (or tried to use)culture to overthrow governments and political systems around the world. If Hollywood movies are culture/art is debatable, ofcourse, and maybe that's where lies the problem. People are confusing commercial and political agendas with culture/art, and that's no accident...
- petewailes 11y agoPithy version: one is interesting to the public, the other is in the public interest.
- jonnathanson 11y agoI'll try to give the simplest possible explanation that tries to be value-neutral and avoids getting bogged down in an ethics debate: copyright. Movies are intellectual property; political information is generally not.
- dave_sullivan 11y agoWhat about use as evidence in a court? If police illegally search and seize, you can conceivably get the case thrown out. If a whistleblower dumps the same information to the internet, that's a different story? The answer is yes, but it does create a new path for prosecution doesn't it? (Can't get a warrant? Hack anonymously, dump to internet, and presto. Good luck proving the source of the leak.) More worryingly, how hard is it to create fake data? People are leery of accusations by prosecutors, far less so of "data". Video and audio evidence can even be faked now. For instance, a bunch of your emails get dumped (all of which are indeed your real e-mails). But then there's one (fake) message to a random email address nobody knows the identity of, "Yes, I'd like to buy 100 kilos of coke and I need help laundering the money after I sell it." Who is the burden of proof on? You to prove that you didn't write it? Or them to prove that you did?
- tehmaco 11y agoI'd think that even if they can't use the leaked data in a prosecution, it'll give them some very good ideas on who needs to be thoroughly audited, and will provide some useful information for financial patterns that might indicate illegal activity in future.
- Broken_Hippo 11y agoIn the case of the movies, most of us know the movie would be released to the public after a short time without the leak. Few leak movies that won't be released in theaters later on, and most folks will have a venue to view the movie in a legal fashion. The release itself can hurt a few and the secretness surrounding the movie beforehand isn't seen as public deceit as there are a few good reasons to delay release (simply logistics of distribution and scheduling, for example). The panama papers, and such things, aren't actually available to the average person nor do I believe there are legal ways to check this sort of thing. It most definitely isn't socically acceptable - in fact, many of us attempting even a small portion of such a thing would be put in jail if ever found out. Furthermore, some of this seems to the expense of the people - Iceland, for example, took a hit as a country only to show that a politician had a nice, cushy account somewhere safe from the stuff that happened at home.