36 ms·
The common complaint is that when github goes down so do issue trackers/project management/docs etc. What are the equivalent alternatives for these systems tha
by maccard 11y ago
The common complaint is that when github goes down so do issue trackers/project management/docs etc. What are the equivalent alternatives for these systems that are distributed, so tolerant to downtime.
If you are in a situation that you're using a DVCS but relying on centralised everything else, and saying that you're unable to work because your Issue tracker/CI server is down, have you really gained anything over the alternatives?
- akerro 11y agoYou can setup gitlab with clones, if one server goes down, second has a copy. You know, git is a distributed system, unlike github.
- mostlystatic 11y agoBut if two systems are identical, wouldn't it be likely that both would break at the same time?
- Piskvorrr 11y agoNo. Unless you do something dumb like "don't test that the failover system is fully functional before taking the primary offline;" this applies to any maintenance, which also includes upgrades. Usual HA tactics apply - don't rely on one power source, one network link, or just about any SPOF. (Which means that requirements start breeding like rabbits, which gets expensive rather quickly - whereas Github is free-as-in-beer, which is good enough for most people) Perhaps the only case breaking both at once would be deliberate action (DDoS etc.).
- Filligree 11y agoGithub is a distributed system, with a unifying front-end. The DDoS just ends up targeting all of it. How do you propose to stop that with your proposal?
- maccard 11y ago> You know, git is a distributed system, unlike github. Thanks for the snark. I know git is a distributed system. My question was about everything else being down (your issue tracker, CI server, wiki/documentation), not about git itself.
- CMay 11y agohttp://fossil-scm.org/ http://fossil-scm.org/
- maccard 11y agoThanks for the reasonable response - I've heard of fossil, but never had any experience with it.