3 ms·
These days of course you would be confronted with a lot more that would make it hard to simply deny things: (a) Absolute records of your physical movements. (C
by contingencies 11y ago
These days of course you would be confronted with a lot more that would make it hard to simply deny things:
(a) Absolute records of your physical movements. (Cellphone, car)
(b) Absolute records of your communications and social network. (Cellphone, email/social networks)
(c) Video evidence of activity in almost any semi-formal place of work, carpark, ATM, shop, or similar. (Physical surveillance ubiquity)
(d) Probable audio recording of your conversations via hacked cellphone.
- crdb 11y agoIn theory, you can watch anybody, but for this to work, you'd need someone to actually look at the evidence i.e. suspect the person in the first place. Quis custodiet ipsos custodes... And in this case it's the guardians of the guardians: who are you going to trust with watching the head of MI6's counter-intelligence division 24/7? As the CIA found in its paranoid early days, over-suspicion is highly counter-productive (see e.g. [1]). You just HAVE to trust your managers. Even if all services have some kind of internal intelligence setup to watch the watchers, it's focused downwards where the risks are higher and cost of suspicion lower, and it has to be run by people you trust the most. You balance the cost of a mole, versus the opportunity cost of turning down genuine defectors and trusting your own staff. This is why (according to [2]) many European services are run by people from wealthy, old families, preferably with at least a few members who have served. It's expected that on average, these people have profound ties to their country - if nothing else, in the form of immense property portfolios - and thus are much less likely to defect. You can't bribe them, you can't offer them a better life [3], what's left? Ideology, and that can be somewhat watched for. Of course, you deny yourself some great talent that way but as with managing a hedge fund, you want to limit downside rather than maximize upside. Nationalism and dynastic politics are a form of defense against foreign enemies. Hence Philby. He was trusted by design, not because MI6 were "bloody incestuous fools" or whatever, and no amount of surveillance would have changed that. [1] http://www.amazon.com/The-Main-Enemy-Inside-Showdown/dp/0345472500 http://www.amazon.com/The-Main-Enemy-Inside-Showdown/dp/0345... [2] http://www.amazon.fr/Missions-methodes-techniques-speciales-services/dp/1482745518 http://www.amazon.fr/Missions-methodes-techniques-speciales-... [3] Kalugin recalls in http://www.amazon.com/First-Directorate-Intelligence-Espionage-Against/dp/0312114265 http://www.amazon.com/First-Directorate-Intelligence-Espiona... that he was somewhat worried about Philby's living conditions in the Soviet Union (unheated flat, alcoholism, etc.). It's been a while since I read the book but I recall he or someone else decided to push for him to have a good quality of life as an advertisement to other potential defectors; only then was Philby put up in proper accommodation and welcomed by the Soviet system.
- cmdkeen 11y agoPhilby wasn't trusted from 1951 onwards, he was sacked from SIS and caught in lies by interrogators - using things like his wife's passport stamps to capture his movements. Technology these days may enable mass surveillance but historically the same thing happened - because there was much less international traffic. MI5 could "burgle their way across London", open all the international mail it wanted to, read the telegrams sent abroad etc. The sheer change in volume of international travel and communication is recent.
- msellout 11y agoPer capita this wave of globalization is about the same as the last one, 1860-1914.
- golergka 11y ago> you'd need someone to actually look at the evidence Not necessarily somebody. It can be something.
- Retric 11y agoNot enough signal to train your classifier. At best you can reduce the effort by removing dead time aka when someone is asleep.
- gozur88 11y ago(a) and (b) and (d) you can certainly control if you're not in an area with ubiquitous license plate readers. Anybody who isn't a rank amateur is going to assume his communications are or will be scrutinized. Hell, even the "good guys" who handle classified information are taught to assume public communications channels are compromised. (c) you might have a harder time coping with, but people have to suspect you before they'll try to piece together those kinds of records. And even then... Robert Hanson got away with it for decades using dead drops in public places. You need a whole lot of information before you can tell the difference between a day at the beach and a day at the beach where a potential spy passed classified information to someone. I would bet my last dollar the vast majority of spies are compromised by enemy agents in their own intelligence network. No matter how good you are, if your boss is working for the enemy you're going to get caught. Indeed, Philby himself was outed by a KGB agent who defected to the West.
- zwischenzug 11y agoDon't carry a cellphone.