3 ms·
Theoretically with UBI there is no need for a social safety net beyond catastrophe insurance (Medicare). In practice I'm not so sure. Many social safety net p
by jandrese 11y ago
Theoretically with UBI there is no need for a social safety net beyond catastrophe insurance (Medicare).
In practice I'm not so sure. Many social safety net programs have restrictions because it's too easy for an alcoholic to pick up his entire family's check and spend it on booze.
Also, UBI is political poison for the people who wring their hands in worry that someone is mooching off of their had work. And make no mistake, there is a sizeable segment of the population that will be perfectly happy to sit at home and do nothing all day, wasting their lives and the public's resources. They will show up in papers and angry up the old folks. What the paper's won't have is the story of the charitable work people can do without the need to constantly work to eat. It won't have the story of the artists who are breaking new ground and doing exciting things in their tiny studios. It will have the story of the 300lb lazy asshole who watches TV all day long.
This is why we can't have nice things.
- sokoloff 11y agoSo the alcoholic takes their entire check and blows it on booze? Don't care. I specifically have to not care, so as to not erect a gigantic, wasteful government program designed to protect someone from their own short-sightedness (in my high-and-mighty opinion). In order for UBI to work, we have to give up substantially all notions of controlling what other people spend THEIR money on. That's the most appealing aspect of UBI to me. As someone who works hard and would end up shouldering the expense, I'm not particularly enamored of it, but the "get out of everyone else's business" aspects really do appeal.
- breischl 11y agoYes, but what about when the alcoholic's wife and adorable child show up on the news because they're starving and don't have heat? Or when someone's grandma gets scammed and ends up living on the street? Most people are not willing to tell them "tough luck." So you're back to having all social programs that try to prevent people from doing stupid, short-sighted things.
- sokoloff 11y agoThe wife has her own UBI presumably. I leave it to the family to work it out. Trying to get a UBI on top of all existing handouts seems doomed to failure to me.
- jandrese 11y agoYou missed the whole point. Said abusive drunk takes all of the money for the household. It happens in real life. You might say "just leave the bum already!", but it's not that simple. People get trapped in shitty situations all the time due to family or religious or mental conditions. In some ways UBI is the most libertarian of the social safety net options (as weird as that sounds), but it assumes that people act in their rational self-interest or if they are self destructive that there is no collateral damage. That's just not true in the real world. Like I said, this is why we can't have nice things.