6 ms·
The top marginal tax rate would have to be dramatically increased to pay for it. Also, you'd have to increase capital gains and estate taxes. Make no mistake,
by empath75 11y ago
The top marginal tax rate would have to be dramatically increased to pay for it. Also, you'd have to increase capital gains and estate taxes.
Make no mistake, basic minimum income would be a massive redistribution of wealth. I'm in favor of it, but let's not pretend we can pay for it by shuffling around some social safety net spending.
- alttab 11y agoIt would completely remove the necessity to be productive. That can't turn out well. What's preventing me from having as many babies as I can knowing that they too will not have to work or find a job to be supported? I know this won't work at scale, because I understand math.
- jack9 11y ago> It would completely remove the necessity to be productive. That can't turn out well. Take a look at mobile games. People do lots of things just to be 1 rung higher on an artificial competitive ladder (reset every month) about endlessly punching a "Battle" button. I think this idea that necessity has ever driven productivity (look around at your job) is a long running joke.
- emidln 11y agoThere's no necessity to be productive now. Most (all?) of the minimum wage jobs in the United States aren't productive to society except so far as that they have some minimal amount of money to make violent property crime slightly less attractive.
- lintiness 11y agoyou need to emotion this a little more and get back to us.
- tangent128 11y agoWhy would you <em>want</em> to have as many babies as you can?
- alttab 11y agoWhat if having a big family brings me joy? If welfare and basic income provide the support I need to have a huge family without being productive, why would I choose to live a life that is inconsistent with my life's motivations? Why work for a living when I can do what I want, and be just as comfortable? I don't need a Tesla, so I'll leave the working for the chumps.
- tangent128 11y agoCongratulations, you get to be productive by raising society's next generation. Sincerely. Many people don't desire large families, if any, or are physically incapable of reproduction. So why pressure them to when others are perfectly willing to pick up the slack?
- thesimon 11y ago>It would completely remove the necessity to be productive. That can't turn out well. As seen in welfare states in Scandinavia or Germany, where almost no one works because of the unemployment benefits.
- snerbles 11y agoOf course not, but the stability of such a state is becoming a concern with the current migration situation. http://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2016/02/welfare-state-refugees-europe/463272/ http://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2016/02/wel...
- alttab 11y agoAnd it's ignoring culture.
- usefulcat 11y agoWait, are you really suggesting that people decide how many children to have based on whether they believe those children will have to work when they become adults?
- aetherson 11y agoNot the top marginal tax rate, the tax rates on probably the top 50% -- certainly the top 25%. Which is not necessarily crazy -- I think that a basic income is an attractive idea, though I doubt the ability to implement it well. But just like we shouldn't pretend we could just shuffle some social safety net programs, we also shouldn't pretend that you could just tax the 1%.
- refurb 11y agoThe top marginal tax rate would have to be dramatically increased to pay for it Someone should do the math! Sure you could increase the top marginal rate, but where does that get you. Yes, the top 1% is very wealthy, but there aren't many of them. I would bet you'd have to increase income taxes well down the income ladder, dipping down into what most people call the middle class. You simply can't avoid it, that's where all the money is.
- JonFish85 11y agoAs with any tax increase, the middle class is always the ones that bear the brunt of it, because for all the noise about taxing the 1%, there just isn't enough money to take. The people that end up really paying the price are the people who worked their entire lives to be able to pay for their kids' college, not the people who have $10b in assets. Politicians are happy to talk about raising the taxes of the wealthy and to cut taxes to the middle class. However, in practice, this means a massive loss in tax revenue, so eventually the middle class taxes have to go back up, or cuts need to be made.
- jrs235 11y ago"As with any tax increase, the middle class is always the ones that bear the brunt of it" because we continually keep talking about taxing income instead of wealth. Tax wealth more and income less. WHAT?!?!?!! People say? Well that really fancy and expensive military we are paying for.. it's not just protecting your income. It's protecting your wealth. Pay your fair proportional share for security of your assets...
- JonFish85 11y agoHuh? As I said, it would take the combined wealth of the top 1000 wealthiest Americans to pay for the federal budget for one year. Pretty quickly you run out of people whose money you can take without getting to the middle class. No matter how you slice it, the real money is in the middle class.
- 11y ago
- SilasX 11y ago... and you'd have to stop everyone from throwing complicated tax structures around their incomes to avoid the increasing tax rates. I know, "just close the loopholes lol". Except that it's a battle of wits of nerds against a bureaucracy with every-bigger portions of the economy at stake, where every government victory is a longer, less transparent tax code.
- harryh 11y agoRecent increases in the capital gains tax rate were very effective at increasing taxes on people in the upper end of the income spectrum. The ability of high earners to avoid taxes through complex use of loopholes is vastly overstated.
- mdorazio 11y agoIncreasing capital gains taxes back to historical levels doesn't actually get you very far. Maybe another 100-200 billion [1]. Forcing corporations to pay taxes on all money earned in the US instead of tossing it offshore would get you another 90 billion or so [2]. Realistically, almost all of the revenue has to come from increasing personal income tax, probably mostly on the top 5% of earners, but realistically everyone would have to pay more. I haven't yet done the calculations, but it seems like we're talking double digit percentage increases. [1] http://people.opposingviews.com/percent-irs-revenue-comes-capital-gains-tax-3399.html http://people.opposingviews.com/percent-irs-revenue-comes-ca... [2] http://www.americansfortaxfairness.org/tax-fairness-briefing-booklet/fact-sheet-offshore-corporate-tax-loopholes/ http://www.americansfortaxfairness.org/tax-fairness-briefing...