6 ms·
Bullet indicates Lawrence of Arabia was no liar
- terravion 11y agoAmazing! Forensics after a century.
- manachar 11y agoYou should see what they've done in Olduvai and Pompeii!
- danielvf 11y agoGo read Lawrence's book, the Seven Pillars of Wisdom! If it were only a travelogue, it would be worth reading. But it's also the personal story of a low ranking man saw the solution to the impossible, and got nations and cultures working together to bring down an empire. The book has more derring-do and adventure than could fit into a summer blockbuster. And everything seen through with, Lawrence's quiet, reflective, selfless, "strange" personality. I'm going to go read a chapter now...
- alanfalcon 11y agoHmn, the Audible edition is only $3.50 if I own the Kindle edition. And that's only $0.99
- dankohn1 11y agoAmazon sold me the Kindle version for $0.99 but doesn't show a matched narration for $3.50. They want to charge me $9.95 and https://www.amazon.com/gp/audible/matchmaker https://www.amazon.com/gp/audible/matchmaker doesn't bring up an option.
- Mz 11y agohttp://gutenberg.net.au/ebooks01/0100111h.html http://gutenberg.net.au/ebooks01/0100111h.html
- knughit 11y agoCan I watch Lawrence of Arabia to start?
- schwarrrtz 11y agoSuch an incredible film. Well worth the 3.5hr running time.
- Mz 11y agoYes. I used to watch it annually. I also did a college paper on the man. It isn't a documentary, but I think it does a fair job of telling the tale.
- B1FF_PSUVM 11y ago> working together to bring down an empire. Profitable work. Though perhaps not for most of the people affected (T.E. Lawrence included), but screw them. P.S. curiously, I do own a copy of Lawrence's book. I even read it, long ago, and from my recollection I'm not inclined to re-read it.
- wtbob 11y agoNinety-nine years later and no-one's rebuilt the railroad? That seems wasteful.
- HillRat 11y agoLess than you'd think; it was a non-standard gauge railroad that didn't go anywhere the Sa'udis cared about -- they needed railways connecting their ports to the interior, so spending the money on a Madinah to Jordan line didn't make sense. KSA has invested a massive amount of money on rail lines, but the north-south track is a recent development. Plus, Land Rovers don't care if you have to go over a few kilometers of damaged road, and fuel is unsurprisingly cheap. And if you don't want to drive, there's a lot of airports.
- mlvljr 11y agoAny proof to his rape stories?
- Snowflame 11y agoThe headline is a tad hyperbolic. Notably, there was one area where Lawrence proooobably was, uh, stretching the truth (for good reason): he insisted that the Arabs had sneaked some ninja division into taking Damascus "first." This account isn't shared by anyone else and would imply these Arabs took the city, then retreated, then came back later or something. Why would Lawrence fudge here? Well, this will seem very quaint to modern eyes, but apparently there was a bias toward "whoever did the work gets the spoils" back then. If the British army took Damascus then it was theirs to distribute as they saw fit, if it was a combined British/Arab force then it'd be a little different. This is ludicrous since there's a unified commander-in-chief who is British who can pick whichever army they like to have the honor of entering the city first. Anyway, Lawrence was exaggerating the date where the Arab troops arrived to try and get them some of the glory & responsibility afterward, since he was considerably more pro-Arab independence than some of the other Brits. It's a silly issue since the Turks had basically lost regardless and who cares which army enters first, of course.
- fit2rule 11y ago> .. of course. Its a matter of course that the nature of covert action is that you must lie about it, even after the fact.
- chx 11y agoThis is one of the roots of the Middle East conflict: the British offered Hussein bin Ali, Sharif of Mecca Arab self governance if they would revolt against the Ottomans -- and gave them help in the person of T.E. Lawrence. Then agreed with their French buddies (Sykes-Picot) on how they will split up the region. The Syrian civil war can easily be traced back to this agreement. Then, to crown this all, the British issued the Balfour Declaration where they promised Palestine to the Zionist movement.
- freyr 11y agoFor anyone interested in learning more, Lawerence in Arabia by Scott Anderson is a pretty good book.
- chx 11y agoAnd http://www.amazon.com/The-Balfour-Declaration-Arab-Israeli-Conflict/dp/0812976037 http://www.amazon.com/The-Balfour-Declaration-Arab-Israeli-C... is even better :)
- berntb 11y agoSo the Mideast troubles comes from decisions a hundred years ago and a few million of "Zionists"? No local responsibility at all...? The problems had nothing to do with e.g. the Bath party, directly inspired by the Nazis? Or the hundreds of years of religious conflicts? Or the lack of experience of own governance, because of Turkish control? And so on...
- golergka 11y ago> Middle East conflict Middle East is a big place; there's no single "conflict" the whole region is involved it, but a complicated mess of all of them. http://cdn.theatlantic.com/assets/media/img/posts/2015/03/Sharro_Diagram/original.jpg http://cdn.theatlantic.com/assets/media/img/posts/2015/03/Sh...
- ArkyBeagle 11y agoThere is the larger decline of the Ottoman Empire as a single ... syndrome.
- jmnicolas 11y agoSo basically they found one bullet and one railroad sign ... pretty light evidence to prove or disprove anything.
- simonh 11y agoThose are just the most obvious evidence they chose to highlight in a brief article. If they examined dozens of sites and found physical evidence that fully supports Lawrence's accounts, and no evidence that is inconsistent with those accounts, that's pretty persuasive. After all if Lawrence made his accounts up, you'd expect it wouldn't take long to find discrepancies between his inventions and the real geography of the locations and physical evidence. I watched a documentary about Lawrence and some journalists visiting some of the sites including the Hallat Ammar attack. In the book Lawrence describes the attack being launched from a ridge (IIRC) 100m from the railway line. They found the ridge, but the railway line was 300m away, too far to be in effective rifle range. But then examining the site more carefully, they found that while the modern railway line was 300m away, the old WW1 era line had become buried with sand and was actually about 100m from the ridge. It's been a very long time since I read SPOW. It's not always an easy read, but full of character and wonderfully evocative. Lawrence clearly loved and appreciated Arab culture. He gave accounts of their camp fire stories and humour for example, but didn't flinch from describing and discussing some of the uncomfortable aspects of the customs and behaviour he encountered.
- bootload 11y ago"Professor Nicholas Saunders said: "The bullet we found came from a Colt automatic pistol, the type of gun known to be carried by Lawrence and almost certainly not used by any of the ambush's other participants." M1911?
- gozur88 11y agoMost likely, yes. An excerpt from a letter by his brother Frank: "The Colt is a lovely pistol. The more I examine it the more I like it. There is a vast gulf between it and the ordinary revolver. If you want anything in connection with it which you don’t want to write for I could get it for you. They keep two weights of bullets, I think 200 and 230 grains. The lighter weight has considerably higher velocity and penetrating power, though I suppose less shock." >This would indicate that both Frank and T. E. had Colt automatics that used the 200 or 230 grain bullets. In 1914 this would have been the .45 caliber Model 1911. (The British also used the Colt 1911 in .455 caliber, but this chambering was not introduced until 1915.) http://www.sightm1911.com/lib/history/telawrence.htm http://www.sightm1911.com/lib/history/telawrence.htm
- bootload 11y agointeresting quotes. what tipped me off was what appears to be .45 ACP HP (flat tip) in the article. cf https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/.45_ACP https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/.45_ACP
- gozur88 11y agoThat's a lot of sand sifting to find a bit of lead. It's some support for Lawrence's version of events, but I think the idea nobody else would be using an automatic is kind of a stretch.