4 ms·
It's interesting how so many people think this is a new problem because of IoT. This problem has existed for years with games. If you had a game that had to b
by jedberg 11y ago
It's interesting how so many people think this is a new problem because of IoT.
This problem has existed for years with games. If you had a game that had to be online to play, and the company decided to stop running the servers, you were screwed.
Sure, sometimes people reversed engineered it, and while the company usually didn't care, it was technically illegal.
We need some laws to protect consumers, that either say that they must release their API if they're going to shut down, or at least make reverse engineering the system legal.
- jasonkostempski 11y agoI'm with removing any law that says reverse engineering is illegal (regardless if some company is in business or not) but it would be unfair to require a company that's going out of business to do costly work before they're allowed to not exist anymore. It would be also be unfair to require all products be guaranteed to work forever. Consumers just need to educate themselves and if they can't accept the potential loss they can just not buy the product and maybe tell company that's why they're not buying it so the company can maybe improve the product. All I'm trying to say is, please, no more silly laws :)
- csours 11y agoI think the transition to a physical item makes a huge difference, mentally, to the customer: see also John Deere tractors [1] (and almost certainly automobiles in the coming years). You feel like you OWN physical products, even when they are tied to a service like this. 1. http://www.wired.com/2015/04/dmca-ownership-john-deere/ http://www.wired.com/2015/04/dmca-ownership-john-deere/
- magicalist 11y ago> We need some laws to protect consumers, that either say that they must release their API if they're going to shut down, or at least make reverse engineering the system legal. The EFF proposed making a DMCA exemption for reverse engineering game server functionality when the official servers have shut down, making the game useless. And of course the industry (with a little help from the MPAA) has fought it tooth and nail: http://arstechnica.com/gaming/2015/04/publishers-fight-to-block-third-party-revival-of-abandoned-game-servers/ http://arstechnica.com/gaming/2015/04/publishers-fight-to-bl... Apparently "hacking" abandoned games encourages hacking in general, and, as in the classic orphan work argument, allowing reverse engineering for all abandoned works would rob publishers of the revenue for the tiny, tiny portion of them that they may (or may not) re-release some day. The Librarian of Congress gave limited approval of the proposal, allowing circumvention of the case you mentioned, where an online check is required just to play local single player, but not anything else. Creating a new multiplayer server, for instance, is still illegal. http://arstechnica.com/gaming/2015/11/u-s-govt-grants-limited-right-to-revive-games-behind-abandoned-servers/ http://arstechnica.com/gaming/2015/11/u-s-govt-grants-limite...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]