8 ms·
Unveil part 2 is "super next-level". And the "steering controls and system feels like a spaceship" And Musk tweeted a little while ago about getting a special
by grecy 11y ago
Unveil part 2 is "super next-level".
And the "steering controls and system feels like a spaceship"
And Musk tweeted a little while ago about getting a special team of Software Engineers reporting directly to him for self-driving that was "top priority" within the company.
And there are no gauges directly in front of the driver at all, which has been confirmed to be like that for production.
At this point, can it be anything other than full autonomous?
(and maybe you'll have to take over sometimes, but I'm thinking 95%+ of the time it will be driving itself)
- pmalynin 11y ago"95%+ of the time it will be driving itself" That's a shitty metric. Does it mean it will need intervention every 950ms for 50ms?
- kaonashi 11y ago> At this point, can it be anything other than full autonomous? On American roads? Not likely.
- davidiach 11y agoBy definition, fully autonomous means that you will never have to take over.
- NickM 11y agoIt seems impossible that they could have it be fully autonomous to the point of not needing a steering wheel though. You can tell an autonomous car "take me to the mall", or "pull out of the garage", but there are so many edge cases that seem like they would still require manual control. How do you tell it which spot to pick in a parking garage? Or how do you tell it to, say, drive on to a lift while inside a building with no GPS reception? It seems like they must still have some kind of manual controls: even if they somehow implement full autonomy, and take care of all the edge cases, and get past the regulatory hurdles...people just like to drive cars sometimes. So I could believe you're right, and they have massively improved autonomous driving features, but to me that still doesn't quite explain his comments about the steering controls being massively different and "feeling like a spaceship".
- Laaw 11y agoSelf driving cars don't use GPS, it is not reliable or granular enough.
- rpedela 11y agoAt all? How would it drive to the mall on the other side of town without GPS?
- TillE 11y agoA map, plus the assumption that it never moves without being powered on. (I'm sure it does use GPS for navigation. But it's hypothetically possible to do without.)
- talmand 11y agoSeems like it might need GPS at times, or some other means to know where it is at certain moments. Once it establishes where it is then I could see it no longer needing GPS, as it should be bright enough to keep track of location by itself using a map.
- 11y ago
- yoodenvranx 11y ago> At this point, can it be anything other than full autonomous? There is no way that autonomous driving is going to work in most small European town and villages. There are so many downtowns which were never meant to be used by car and it is already difficult to navigate those places as a human. I just don't see how this should work over here in Europe. Selfdriving on the highway or in a typical suburban sprawl in the US? Yes, that might work in the near future. Navigating twisted one-way streets in some old town from the middle ages during rush hour? That will take a long time to do this fully autonomously.
- Laaw 11y agoWhy? What specifically is hard about narrow streets? That actually sounds like the kind of thing a self driving car could excel at. The bigger problem, is imagine, would be weather. I dunno how completely they've solved that problem yet.
- rplnt 11y agoOftentimes there's a two-way street when only one car can pass. Sometimes there are signs for that, but not always. And sometimes you need to check mirror to see if car is approaching from behind the corner before you can proceed.
- yoodenvranx 11y agoOne of many examples would be a single lane street which goes up a hill and around the corner. Although there is only space for one car you can drive both directions. Rather often than not you have two cars meeting in the middle and then one car has to drive back to let the other car pass. This is pretty difficult to do as a human and I am not sure how an autonomous car would do that.
- maxerickson 11y agoThe same way it goes forward? 2 autonomous cars could negotiate which has the shorter trip, an autonomous car encountering a human could default to timidity.
- phkahler 11y agoWith the oblong steering wheel they mentioned and spaceship like controls, I'm thinking they just don't want the steering wheel sticking up in front of that awesome view. Perhaps an airplane-line yoke? There is the problem of the steering wheel needing to go multiple revolutions, but there do exist some variable ratio steering systems where you might limit rotation to +/-90 degrees but the wheel travel is speed dependent. There are options besides fully autonomous. As for the lack of instruments, I rarely look at much other than the speedometer while driving, and if the car can read the signs and help regulate speed for me, I may not even need that. My non-Tesla car has an audible chime at 50 and 25 miles to empty, so I don't even need to look at the fuel gauge.
- knodi123 11y ago> Perhaps an airplane-line yoke? Is there a reason that basically NO car manufacturer has EVER made a production model with steering by anything other than a wheel and pedals?
- MagnumOpus 11y agoMercedes has presented a prototype with joystick in 1999, said to have been easier to learn for beginners than steering wheels, and quicker to perform emergency maneuvers with. They said that German legislation does not allow for cars with side-stick rather than steering wheels, and that it would be cost-prohibitive to introduce - the latter is probably no longer true... http://www.economist.com/node/290976 http://www.economist.com/node/290976
- hinkley 11y agoMy friend has a Prius and I hate driving it because the steering wheel isn't round. Turns out the way I drive involves letting the wheel slip under my hands when going around corners, and you can't do that if the circumference of the wheel moves as it turns.
- bitsoda 11y agoDon't rule out HUD gauges projected onto the lower left of the windshield. 95% autonomy in a commercially available car by 2018 is very unlikely IMO.
- vrfcodf 11y agoThis is what I'm thinking too. The lack of dashboard is not because the car will be autonomous, it will be but only on the freeway, but because there will be a HUD.
- grecy 11y ago> it will be but only on the freeway You're not thinking far enough into the future. We already had that, in 2015. These cars won't exist until late 2017, so you have to improve on what we've got, today, by more than 2 years.
- sschueller 11y agoIf the DOT approves this car it will not because it is safe. There is a reason cars have proper dials and buttons. The current model S is already problematic. I have had drivers adjusting their AC almost hit other drivers because they had to look down.
- vvanders 11y agoGood thing you can assign the AC to the steering wheel on the Model S, disaster avoided!
- sschueller 11y agoThanks, good to know, I will tell my friend to do that so I don't get a heart attack next time I ride with him.
- forgetsusername 11y ago>And there are no gauges directly in front of the driver at all, which has been confirmed to be like that for production Is that how you read it? Because I read it as Tesla feeling the pressure to get something tangible out there for people to see, so they demonstrated a car that wasn't finished (just like the battery swap tech, or "off the hook" Powerwall demand). It got huge hype, now it'll be two more years of "wait and see what we have planned!" Smart, I guess. I wish everyone would stop framing this as Tesla vs everyone else, instead of rooting on the EV industry as whole. There'd be less pressure on Tesla to take over the world, which ain't gonna happen.
- grecy 11y agoIn some of the ride-along vidoes the people driving (all heads of design) confirm the lack of gauges is going into production, as-is the landscape screen.
- madaxe_again 11y ago"Feels like a spaceship" sounds weird to me. piloting a spacecraft isn't all that easy. In fact, when we're criticising UX we say it's like the controls in the space shuttle.
- Reedx 11y agoPerception vs Reality. :) I think most people imagine piloting a spaceship as being awesome. And are thinking of it more like sci-fi spaceships rather than a modern day shuttle packed with obtuse controls.
- cryptoz 11y agoSure, but not the spaceships that Elon builds. Those spaceships have controls like a single digital button that says "land" or "dock".
- jkaunisv1 11y agoI think he means "feels like a spaceship from a sci-fi movie"
- Someone 11y agoIs it really hard to pilot a spaceship? You maneuver it out of the solar system (should not be _that_ difficult, certainly not if your destination is in a direction outside of the ecliptic), point it in the right direction, move to full throttle, and let it do its thing for a few centuries while you sleep or watch history on earth go by. Yes, there's a risk you may hit something and be killed, but per passenger mile, I expect it to be even safer than the space shuttle.
- chc 11y agoMusk said on Twitter that Autopilot convenience features would not be included in the base model, "same as S and X." So it doesn't seem like they would be basing the interior design on an optional feature.
- cookiecaper 11y agoHe says in the reveal presentation that Autopilot hardware will come standard on the 3.
- chc 11y agoYes, and it will have standard safety features like automatic braking that use that hardware. But what does that have to do with whether or not the Model 3 design is based around fully autonomous driving?
- omegant 11y agoWhen I saw no gauges the first thing that I thought was they are going to install a HUD (Head up display a la fighter jet).
- gutnor 11y agoYou don't really need gauge at all, autonomous car or not. Seriously, in every day driving you need the speed and that's it. (even on a clutch ICE car, the RPM is really unnecessary unless you have a racing driving style) They have confirmed in some video that the odometer is within the visual field of the driver and actually very visible. The rest of the information does not need constant visual presence, actually the GPS is probably more interesting than anything else. I would still be surprised if there is no HUD provided with the car. You still need some very visible notification area for event like running out of juice or any kind of malfunction. Also there still some stuff the car are bad at doing like fog lights, or putting the light on in a foggy situation ( actually almost had a crash because of that - so use of the car switching the light on or off, forgot that fog during day or overcast weather are the same to a light sensor ) Also if the car is not 100% of the time autonomous, you need to be able to tell immediately if it is enabled or not.