5 ms·
Standard arguments against your position: - Using without paying is immoral, you should just do without. - Even if it's OK for you to do so, we know that many
by icebraining 11y ago
Standard arguments against your position:
- Using without paying is immoral, you should just do without.
- Even if it's OK for you to do so, we know that many people will illegally download films they could buy, hence offering these tools is unethical.
- As programmers, we rely on copyright for our income, hence it's unethical to infringe on the copyright of others.
Did I miss any? The feelings of deja vu in these threads are way too strong.
- staticelf 11y ago1. No one is caring about morality in the end. I believe many people do not believe illegal copying to be immoral. 2. Yes, are there any data on that these people would ever pay? 3. Yes and like all digital content we have the ability to spread our work across the globe very fast at little to no extra cost. If we limit our work to a certain country we only have ourselves to blame when people are illegally copying it.
- icebraining 11y agoSorry, I wasn't clear: I'm a pirate as well. I was just commenting on how these threads always seem to go through the same motions, and nothing is accomplished, because everyone has already heard the arguments against their position and has found them unconvincing.
- staticelf 11y agoWell yeah, but that could be said for every political discussion, yet I see a value in keeping the discussion alive.
- mbrock 11y agoThere's an interesting part in Alasdair MacIntyre's book "After Virtue" on the "interminable nature of contemporary moral discussions."
- icebraining 11y agoDon't get me wrong, I think there's plenty to discuss on this topic, it's just that HN is not a good avenue for it. First, threads always start as a blank slate, so by the time we get through the obvious arguments on both sides, it has already dropped off the front page and the discussion has died down. The next time, someone will again invariably argue that they can't watch stuff in their country, and someone will reply with one of the arguments I listed. Secondly, since many people consider this topic poses important moral questions, downvotes will invariably be used to suppress valid but disagreeable opinions, and then we'll have more posts of people justly complaining that they've been unfairly downvoted, plus a few assholes playing victim. HN is great for most discussions around technical and business matters, particularly regarding new developments; it's pretty shitty for serious discussion around social and political topics.