4 ms·
This is so true, otherwise businesses would be flocking to set up in low regulation, low tax countries like Somalia.
by collyw 11y ago
This is so true, otherwise businesses would be flocking to set up in low regulation, low tax countries like Somalia.
- pron 11y agoLarger businesses disproportionately benefit from law-and-order and infrastructure.
- smsm42 11y agoI don't think it is true. Large corp can afford their own security force and infrastructure (and if you study the history of colonial corporate conquests, that's exactly what they have been doing). Small business or average consumer can afford none of this. Big corp can build their own protected bubble amid a desolated and decaying country, but if you are outside the bubble, you are in trouble.
- pron 11y agoA villa in the jungle is not what I was talking about. Large corporations benefit from their customers being safe and secure, and from infrastructure to distribute their products. And the companies involved in "colonial corporate conquests" were huge, royally chartered monopolies, directly supported by their countries, and usually acting as their official representative; there was a symbiotic relationship between the monopoly and the state, quite the opposite from an independent existence. Large, successful corporations virtually always get started only in well-run states, while fruit stands are set up everywhere.
- smsm42 11y ago>> Large corporations benefit from their customers being safe and secure Same way as the small ones do. Maybe even more so - you can find a market for luxury cars even in most brutal dictatorships (in fact, many brutal dictators are known for their love of luxury goods, and so are their henchmen as soon as they are wealthy enough) but trying to establish a small business with stable clientele might be quite hard. >> there was a symbiotic relationship between the monopoly and the state, quite the opposite from an independent existence. If you look at the relationship between big banks or insurance companies or resource companies, and governments, "symbiotic relationship" is not a bad description of what is still happening. What is good for GM is still good for the country, and the country spending billions to fix the screwups of GM management is a living proof of it. >> while fruit stands are set up everywhere. Fruit stands - yes. Startups - not so much.
- pron 11y ago> you can find a market for luxury cars even in most brutal dictatorships But you're unlikely to create a luxury car company in an unstable country. > trying to establish a small business with stable clientele might be quite hard. There are plenty of small businesses with stable clientele in Bangladesh, Haiti, Yemen, and pretty much every country in the world. > "symbiotic relationship" is not a bad description of what is still happening. I'm not saying it isn't. But you still can't have a large company in an unstable country, while you can easily have a fruit stand there. It is the large businesses that benefit disproportionately from the state. > Startups - not so much. Right, you probably need a stable country for startups, too. But most countries don't tax startups much anyway.
- smsm42 11y ago> But most countries don't tax startups much anyway. Because they reasonably think that letting them grow a bit is more profitable.
- collyw 11y ago"you can find a market for luxury cars even in most brutal dictatorships" But can you find a factory for them?
- smsm42 11y agoThis is not a smart example, since it assumes Somalia has no difference with developed countries except for low taxes. I'm sure if you try hard enough, you could find a better example of low tax countries and compare their business development with high tax countries. If, of course, your purpose is gain better understanding of the matter and not to try sounding witty for cheap without actually having any substance behind it. As for actual Somalia tax rates, they are kind of hard to find, but we can go other way. Somalia's GDP [1] is estimated around $1 billion, while their state budget is around $200 mln. [2]. Which means in the country the government is about 20% of the economy. Which is pretty close to US figures, surprisingly. More over, if you look up in [2], you will find: High tax burden with corruption and extortions exacerbates poverty and prevents economic recovery. So would I believe you saying Somali has low taxes and low regulation, or Somalians who complain about high taxes and oppressive government? Who knows best? Please help me choose. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economy_of_Somalia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economy_of_Somalia [2] http://hiiraan.com/op4/2014/aug/56172/somalia_fiscal_budget_and_federal_government_legitimacy.aspxhttp://hiiraan.com/op4/2014/aug/56172/somalia_fiscal_budget_and_federal_government_legitimacy.aspx http://hiiraan.com/op4/2014/aug/56172/somalia_fiscal_budget_...