3 ms·
All of them are taxable. Interest is taxable income (to the lender), though it's also a prime opportunity for tax arbitrage so the lenders have a strong tendenc
by AnthonyMouse 11y ago
All of them are taxable. Interest is taxable income (to the lender), though it's also a prime opportunity for tax arbitrage so the lenders have a strong tendency to be incorporated in low tax jurisdictions.
And buybacks effectively get taxed as capital gains (because they result in higher share prices), but not until the shareholders sell their shares, and of course then it's at the capital gains rate.
So what you're really getting at is that dividends and capital gains should be taxed at the same rate.
And if you really want to promote dividends, let reinvested dividends defer taxes like buybacks do until the shares purchased with the dividends are sold, even if they're reinvested in a different company. Then you'll see investors demanding dividends because the tax advantage of buybacks would be gone and dividends would have the advantage of allowing investors to choose what to invest the new money in.
- sokoloff 11y ago> So what you're really getting at is that dividends and capital gains should be taxed at the same rate. In large part, they are: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qualified_dividend https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qualified_dividend
- roganp 11y agoExcept that with a capital gain you can choose when realize that gain (and when you pay that tax) whereas the company defines its dividend schedule. But I did not know that was the law...it is always/everywhere repeated that dividends are taxed at the personal income rates (e.g. many times in these comments that is repeated), but that is not true.
- eru 11y ago> [...] and of course then it's at the capital gains rate. Which might be zero, depending on where the shareholders sit.