2 ms·
>The other issue is that it takes millions of dollars to fund the research for many of these papers. With no incentive to make money on the research, companies
by andrepd 11y ago
>The other issue is that it takes millions of dollars to fund the research for many of these papers. With no incentive to make money on the research, companies will either stop the research, or it will go completely private and there will be no access for anyone.
You seem to be basically misunderstanding the whole thing. This isn't about research funding, it's about publisher fees. The issue with the papers is not that they take money to produce and so the researchers then charge money for others to see the results, and that therefore bypassing these fees would deprive the researchers of their hard-earned money they need to keep funding their million dollar research.
That is not at all what this is about. The fees being charged are publisher fees, absolutely ridiculous fees for a minimal service that is completely obsolete in the internet age, hampers collaboration and the flow of information, slows down science, prevents underprivileged persons from accessing the research that is in the vast majority of cases publicly funded, and serves only to give money to these publishers, of which absolutely 0% goes to the researchers themselves.
- pink_dinner 11y ago"The fees being charged are publisher fees, absolutely ridiculous fees for a minimal service that is completely obsolete in the internet age, hampers collaboration and the flow of information, slows down science, prevents underprivileged persons from accessing the research that is in the vast majority of cases publicly funded" So we should be able to do whatever we want when we don't agree with a law? this is between publishers and researchers. "and serves only to give money to these publishers, of which absolutely 0% goes to the researchers themselves." This sounds like the 'all music should be shared and free' argument all over again. The last decade of Napster and Torrents have pretty much destroyed any chances of an Indy musician to make a living without the sponsorship of a big corporation. It essentially pushed all of the Indy artists out. They actually had a chance to make a living with music before file sharing became part of our culture (and the belief that bits on a computer should somehow be free since it takes nothing to copy them). The irony is that the exact same thing is happening with job outsourcing and now those same people are clamoring for government intervention. We somehow need to stop the free flow of information when it directly affects your job. I worked in academia in a different life and nearly all research is conducted in some part by private entities pumping money into the University. This won't have the desired effect and will essentially make research even more private. I don't believe the GNU is a truly free license. If I decided to take software, use it in a proprietary app, and then sell it with no source, I would be taken to court (and people here on HN would want me sued out of existence (I've seen it many times already)). Should I have a right to do this? Because this is exactly what is going on here. A copyright license is being broken and you believe it's justified.
- effie 11y agoNobody is arguing what she is doing is legal in U.S. What people feel is that what she is doing is morally right despite it being illegal, regarding how publishers operate.