4 ms·
I could be wrong, but in most cases the US government buys appliances from companies like Diebold and they don't develop or contract software for voting. The b
by chaostheory 11y ago
I could be wrong, but in most cases the US government buys appliances from companies like Diebold and they don't develop or contract software for voting. The best that can be done is regulation to force audits of the appliances like what Nevada does with casino slots. Even that would be a huge step up.
- nxzero 11y agoMight be a reason to long-term require all software used be open source and for that matter make it easy for a user to confirm that the system in use real-time is the system that's open-sourced too.
- tajen 11y agoHow do you allow a user to confirm this in real time? Hash displayed on th screen?
- nxzero 11y agoYes, that's correct, being able to download the code, hash it, and then compare it to the hash displayed real-time would be a first step towards enabling this.
- stepanhruda 11y agothe software can easily be modified to display the hash you are expecting
- nxzero 11y agoTo start, something is better than nothing. Long-term remote inbound two part authitacation combine with like measures for hardware via meta-programming would make bypassing this very, very hard for the average hacker.
- Spivak 11y agoUsers wouldn't confirm this in in real time just like users have no way of verifying in real time that their paper ballot was actually counted. A better outcome for this type of system would be a pre-election and post-election verification of each machine (which isn't unreasonable since the number of machines is far less than the number of ballots) in which interested agents from each party/group could be present during the verification process (and use their own machine if they desire) to ensure that all the digital signatures match and there's no foul play.
- HappyTypist 11y agoperhaps use a Merkle hash to verify your vote was counted?