8 ms·
IMHO one of the greatest, and most misguided straw men we have as a society is the boogeyman that is the lazy, stupid citizen. I've recently started working wit
by potatolicious 17y ago
IMHO one of the greatest, and most misguided straw men we have as a society is the boogeyman that is the lazy, stupid citizen. I've recently started working with the homeless, and had the opportunity to live in an industrial, working-class slum in Canada... what I see in those places is not maliciousness, nor laziness.
Have I met the lazy, good-for-nothing freeloaders living in a shack in the slums? Sure - but that guy is really not as common as people seem to think. It's a critical mistake that betrays the arrogance of the monied in this country to assume that these people are anything but a minority in homeless and poor population.
It's so easy to try and take full credit for your success, and try to push all blame for failure to the individual. It's far too easy to judge people you have never met using assumptions you have never truly tested. For everyone railing against the poor, I'd highly recommend volunteering some time with your local non-profit that handles these issues. Meet these people, put a face and name to your wild accusations, and you will find it much harder to scream about lazy, freeloading Americans - because they're actually kind of hard to find.
Instead of being monied and ignorant, be monied and informed.
- xenophanes 17y agoIn other words, you've met countless people who could easily live on $1595 per month? Cool. I have no doubt they exist. And that they could have handled the situation from the article better. Why can't welfare policy focus on helping those people? Competent slum people are more effective to help, and much more sympathetic, than incompetent people getting a monthly check for more than full time minimum wage work.
- potatolicious 17y agoBecause those people, and those other people, are really not that widely separated. I currently work at two places that deal with the homeless - one focuses on work placement, the other focuses on immediate relief, and what I see is that the population between those two groups are really separated by sheer luck, and the amount of support they have been able to receive from non-profits, family, and community. The people who have been able to bootstrap themselves out of homelessness and into gainful employment all have done so with a gigantic effort from countless concerned citizens, many of whom (including myself) work entirely for free. The notion of a homeless person who through sheer determination and savvy pulls themselves up, without the understanding support of those around them, is a complete fabrication. I find your argument as thus: I see some people who have been able to exit poverty and homelessness (conveniently ignoring the fact that the support programs that enable this are far less vindictive and judgmental than you seem to be), therefore anyone who can't is just unworthy of help. I have, in my brief time working with this issue, met many people far better than myself, who dedicate a ludicrous portion of their lives to enabling and improving lives... and none of them subscribe to the idea of the lazy, good-for-nothing poor. If I may be so bold - our homeless/poor support systems, as overtaxed as they are, succeed in spite of attitudes like yours, not because.
- xiaoma 17y agoAccording to the article, Mr. Eisen gets a $1,595 monthly disability check each month because he has diabetes, hypertension and liver failure. Surely you realize that medical care for these kinds of conditions costs something, especially in the US. Calling him and his 57 year-old wife "incompetent" and implying that an elderly couple with medical issues could live off of a single minimum wage salary is heartless. It's important to make sure that welfare policy doesn't become a disincentive to work, but we're talking about a disability check that doesn't even bring them up to the poverty line.
- xenophanes 17y agoHello? They are spending 1380/month on rent. That's what I said. Did you read it? Obviously if they stopped doing that they'd have far more money. And I'm saying I don't want them to be given more money, not to take away his check. If you don't find a job or a cheaper place for 2 years you shouldn't go "omg i'm gonna be homeless, we need help, we're the perfect sob story, write about us in the NY times and then mention how obama wants to extend unemployment so i could get more checks that i totally deserve for not working or managing my budget for 2 years".
- potatolicious 17y agoPlease keep it civil - the other poster didn't sling any mud at you, it would help your credibility if you did the same.
- xenophanes 17y agoWhat mud? He ignored what I said. I pointed this out. I didn't say anything about him.
- replicatorblog 17y agoMy wife worked in a school that was in a Slum in the US. All the kids parents were on welfare. The amount of graft we saw was unbelievable. One kid came to school in a taxi every morning because the mother would go out partying at night and not wake up in time to bring him to school. Another was in pain because his pants were so old and tight. He walked around with his pants undone, but his mom had the money for fancy manicures. Notices to parents went unread. She would hold parent teacher conferences days and nights so everyone would have a chance to come no matter their schedule, but in a class of 30 1 or 2 would show. Her stories in the staff room were not unique. What is the alternative to this kind of behavior? We can't judge or criticize? I don't mean for sport or in spite, but how else can we evolve the laws?
- potatolicious 17y agoSurely we can judge or criticize - the idea is not to pretend that these don't exist, the idea is that it's dangerous to subscribe to it in broad strokes. The poor and homeless have complex situation that really should be dealt case-by-case. Note also that the notion that we shouldn't give a shit about these people, and just let 'em rot, is also unproductive - in this case the children would never get to school, would never have the opportunity to get educated, succeed, and exit poverty. I'm really not experienced enough in this field to say what would be the right solution to poverty - I doubt many people are. Whatever it is though, simply pulling the plug on irresponsible people is not helpful.
- Herring 17y ago>IMHO one of the greatest, and most misguided straw men we have as a society is the boogeyman that is the lazy, stupid citizen. It's a leftover from puritan/calvinist times. Success was a sign that you have God's approval. You might even be one of God's Elect (ie you basically have a contract assuring salvation).
- replicatorblog 17y agoThat is a bit of an oversimplification. There are many living embodiments of people who failed not for lack of God's grace, but rather self destructive behaviors, poor life decisions, and lack of motivation. Others see this and make judgments accordingly.
- elptacek 17y agoI like this response. Having watched my grandparents' and parents' generations age, and being the age I am, it's easier for me to discern what constitutes an individual failure and what is simply a mistake of ignorance. If only the problem of poverty were as simple as sloth, ignorance, lack of opportunity, insufficient education, poor habilitation or mental depression. Any one of those problems is easy to solve. Any two of them in tandem may also be easy to solve. But if you've got all of them AND add happenstance to that list; things that, even at your most cynical, you could not plan against, the complexity of the problem of poverty requires more consideration that any single one of us has. To some people, all the little things that foster individual success are just background noise -- you aren't aware of the noise until it's not there anymore. This has never been more apparent to me than now, as I am raising my children. Somehow I would like them to be grateful that they have so much more than I did, but the only way that can really feel that is to suffer like I did... and I can't let that happen. Volunteering is part of the solution, though. We are each other's most precious resource.
- jcnnghm 17y agoThat's certainly not true everywhere. Because it's that way in your experience in Canada, doesn't make it true anywhere else. My experience with the poor and homeless happened with actual ghetto dwellers in Baltimore, MD, not the sweet and fuzzy California or Canadian homeless. I got stuck, through my school, volunteering at a soup kitchen every weekend for about eight weeks. In that time, I witnessed the exact same people showing up every single day. They referred to their welfare checks as their paychecks, openly purchased drugs, wore new Fubu clothes and new Nike shoes, and talked about the latest HBO shows. This was somewhat ironic as, at the time, I couldn't afford cable TV or HBO, new brand name clothes, or very much of anything else, but I was able to pay for my own food. I just couldn't go somewhere and have a person serve it to me though, as they were able to. I could also afford to give up my weekend and drive to Baltimore to serve people that can afford fifty bucks for an eight ball, but cannot spare fifteen dollars for twenty pounds of rice. In the entire eight weeks, I only met a single person that was actually down on their luck, everyone else was just lazy. The reason poor people have no money is that they are awful at fiscal management. Instead of food, they pay for cable, instead of rent, they buy drugs, expensive clothes, and shoes. That's not my problem, and continuing to take care of people that refuse to care for themselves does nothing but perpetuate the problem. These people won't work because they have no incentive to do so. They receive more from the government than they could make with the amount of effort they're willing to expend. If you want to solve homelessness and hunger, solve the problem of rich liberals feeling guilty and deciding to solve other peoples problems because they have too much time on their hands.